Short answer
guess only when you can rule out at least one option, and prefer guessing when you can rule out two. With four options and a penalty of one-third of a mark, a blind guess has an expected value of exactly zero, so it gains nothing on average and adds risk. Every option you eliminate raises the expected value. The penalty differs by exam, so check your official notification for the marking scheme before applying the numbers below.
The arithmetic: expected value of a guess
Expected value is the average mark you gain per attempt if you repeated it many times. For one question: expected value = (chance of being right x marks for right) - (chance of being wrong x penalty).
Take an example scheme that many exams use: 4 options, 1 mark for a right answer, one-third of a mark deducted for a wrong answer. This is an illustration, not any particular exam's rule.
| Options you can eliminate | Options left | Chance of being right | Expected value per guess |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (blind guess) | 4 | 1/4 = 0.25 | 0.25 x 1 - 0.75 x 0.333 = 0.25 - 0.25 = 0 |
| 1 | 3 | 1/3 = 0.333 | 0.333 x 1 - 0.667 x 0.333 = 0.333 - 0.222 = +0.111 |
| 2 | 2 | 1/2 = 0.5 | 0.5 x 1 - 0.5 x 0.333 = 0.5 - 0.167 = +0.333 |
So a blind guess breaks even. One elimination gives about a ninth of a mark per question. Two eliminations gives a third of a mark. Over 20 such questions, guessing after eliminating two options is worth roughly 6.7 marks on average, but with ups and downs in the real paper.
The break-even rule
A guess is worth making when your chance of being right is higher than penalty / (1 + penalty). For a penalty of 1/3, that is (1/3) / (4/3) = 0.25, which matches the four-option blind guess. For a penalty of 1/4, the break-even is 0.25 / 1.25 = 0.2, so even a blind guess among four options gives 0.25 x 1 - 0.75 x 0.25 = +0.0625, slightly positive. For a penalty of half a mark, break-even is 0.5 / 1.5 = 0.333, so a blind guess loses and you need at least two options removed.
| Penalty per wrong answer | Break-even chance of being right | Blind guess (1 in 4) is... |
|---|---|---|
| 1/4 mark | 20% | Slightly positive |
| 1/3 mark | 25% | Exactly zero |
| 1/2 mark | 33.3% | Negative |
What 'eliminating an option' really means
Elimination must be genuine, not a feeling. Valid reasons: the option is out of range, the unit is wrong, the sign is wrong, the answer must be even and it is odd, it contradicts the passage, or it repeats a word in the question with an absolute like 'always'. A hunch that an option 'looks wrong' is not elimination. Over-confidence is the main reason guessing loses marks.
A worked example
A quant question asks for the time taken by a train to cross a platform, and you can see the answer must be under 20 seconds and a whole number. Of four options (12, 18, 25, 40), the last two break your limit. That leaves two options, so your chance is 1/2 and the expected value is +0.333 under the example scheme. Attempt it. If instead none of the options can be ruled out and you have no idea, skip.
A simple exam-hall rule
- First pass: attempt the questions you can solve with confidence.
- Second pass: return to the doubtful ones and try elimination.
- Guess only after eliminating at least one option (two if the penalty is large).
- Never leave the paper with easy questions unattempted because of fear. Fear of the penalty costs more marks than the penalty itself for most candidates.
- Keep a separate count of guesses in your mocks so you know whether your guesses pay.
Test your own guessing in mocks
In your mock tests, mark every guess. After the test, count how many guesses were right. If you got 4 of 12 guesses right, you are near break-even for a 1/3 penalty. If you got 2, your guesses are costing marks and you should skip more. The method is covered in our guide to using mock tests properly.
Cases where skipping is better
- Time is almost gone and one more wrong answer would also cost you the time to check others.
- You are already a long way above the exam's likely cut-off, so risk gains you little.
- The question is a lengthy calculation with no way to eliminate options.
- The exam has no negative marking: then always attempt every question.
Practise elimination under timed conditions with a mock test.
Take a practice testFrequently asked questions
Is it always better to guess if there is no negative marking?
Yes. If there is no penalty, a blank answer earns nothing and a guess may earn a mark, so attempt every question.
Does the arithmetic change with five options?
Yes. With five options a blind guess has a 20% chance. Under a 1/4 penalty that is break-even; under a 1/3 penalty it is slightly negative. Use the break-even rule with your exam's numbers.
How many questions should I guess?
Only those where you can genuinely eliminate options. A fixed number is less useful than the rule: eliminate first, then decide.
Does guessing risk my overall score a lot?
Guessing with eliminated options is a small positive bet. A few wrong guesses will cost marks, but across many questions the average works in your favour.
Where do I find my exam's marking scheme?
In the official notification and the instructions on the question paper. Never rely on a forum post for the penalty.