The short answer: they can be worth it for some children, if your child enjoys them and the class does not crowd out rest, play and school maths. The best study we found showed that mental abacus training improved young children's calculation and place-value skills, but it did not improve their wider thinking abilities or their feelings about maths, and some children did not benefit much. For Vedic maths, the studies we could open were small. Treat both as an optional extra skill, not as a cure for maths trouble or a brain booster.

What these classes teach

Abacus and Vedic maths at a glance

  • Abacus
    • Children move beads on a frame to add, subtract and more
    • Later they picture the abacus in their mind and calculate without it
    • Needs regular practice to keep the skill
  • Vedic maths
    • A set of shortcut methods for multiplying, squaring, dividing and checking answers
    • Usually done on paper or in the head, no equipment
    • Usually suits children who already know their basic operations
Both are mostly about calculation. Neither replaces understanding school maths.

What the research found

Mental abacus. The best-known study was done in India. A summary by the British Psychological Society describes a three-year randomised controlled trial at a charitable school in Vadodara with 183 children aged five to seven. One group had three hours a week of extra abacus lessons; the comparison group had three hours a week of extra ordinary maths tuition. The abacus group improved more in calculation, arithmetic and understanding place value, and the summary describes some "modest advantages" in school maths and science grades. But the abacus training did not change broader thinking abilities, attitudes to maths or maths anxiety, and children who started with weak spatial and working memory skills did not show the same gains. The researchers wrote that mental abacus is "likely to afford some children a measurable advantage"; note the words some children.

Vedic maths. We could open one recent study, published in the Innovare Journal of Education in 2026. It followed 30 middle-school students at a government-aided school in Tamil Nadu through six weeks of Vedic maths sessions. Their average test scores rose from 42.5 to 68.4, and accuracy rose from 65% to 87%. However, the study had one group and no comparison group, so we cannot tell how much of the rise came from the method and how much from six weeks of extra, focused maths practice of any kind.

What the studies we opened do and do not show
Claim you may hearWhat we found
Abacus makes children faster at sumsSupported for calculation and place value in one large Indian trial
Abacus boosts the whole brain, memory or concentrationNot shown in that trial; broader thinking abilities did not change
Abacus reduces fear of mathsNot shown; maths anxiety and attitudes did not change in that trial
Every child benefitsNo; children with weaker spatial and working memory skills gained less
Vedic maths improves marksOne small six-week study saw scores rise, but with no comparison group

Questions to ask before you enrol

  1. Why do we want this? Faster calculation is a fair goal. "So my child is not left behind" or "to increase IQ" are not things the research we found supports.
  2. Does my child enjoy it? Ask for a trial class and watch your child's face, not the speed of the beads.
  3. What gives way? Count the hours. A weekly class plus daily practice sheets can eat into play, sleep and family time. Read our guide on the overscheduled child.
  4. How does it fit with school maths? Abacus and Vedic methods are tools for calculating. School maths also needs understanding: why we carry, what a fraction means, how to solve a word problem.
  5. What does the class claim? Be careful with promises about brain power, memory or guaranteed marks. Ask what evidence they rely on.
  6. How long is the commitment? Ask how many levels or months the course has, and whether you can stop at any level without losing what was paid for or learned.

Signs a class is helping, or not

  • Helping: your child talks about it happily, shows you tricks, and uses mental calculation in real life, like adding up the vegetable bill.
  • Helping: school maths feels a little easier and your child is not more tired than before.
  • Not helping: tears before class, practice sheets done only under pressure, or your child getting fast at sums but stuck on what the question is asking.
  • Not helping: you are spending evenings arguing about practice. That cost is real, even if the speed is improving.

A parent-child activity: the kitchen-shop sum game

Whether or not you choose a class, everyday maths at home builds number sense. Set up a pretend shop with a few things from the kitchen shelf and paper price tags in small round numbers. Your child is the shopkeeper. You buy two or three things and ask, "How much do I owe?" Let your child work it out in their head, on fingers, on paper or on an abacus if they have one, then explain how they did it. Swap roles. Ask "How did you get that?" more than "Is that right?" Explaining the method is where understanding grows.

  • Safety: use only closed packets and unbreakable containers, no glass jars or knives, and keep the game away from the stove.
  • For younger children: use numbers up to 10 and real objects to count.
  • For older children: add a discount or ask for the change from a round amount. See teach Indian money for more.

Want an ad-free way to practise counting and money play? The Kitchen and Toy Shop worlds in Sikhora Kids have free games with counting and pretend coins, short sessions and breaks you set.

Open the Toy Shop

Common mistakes

  • Expecting a class to fix maths fear. In the Vadodara trial, abacus did not change maths anxiety. If your child is anxious about maths, talk to their teacher about where they are stuck.
  • Comparing speeds with other children. Children who started with weaker spatial or memory skills gained less in that trial. That says nothing about how clever they are.
  • Using speed as the only measure. Fast answers to sums do not show whether a child understands place value, fractions or word problems.
  • Adding a class to a full week. Sleep, play and free time matter too.

Frequently asked questions

What is the right age to start abacus?

The large trial we found taught children aged five to seven. That does not mean younger is better or that later is too late. Look at whether your child can sit for the class, enjoys it, and is comfortable with numbers up to 10 or 20.

Will abacus confuse my child with the school method?

Some children switch between methods easily; others mix them up. If your child seems confused in school maths, talk to both the class teacher and the abacus teacher, and keep school methods as the priority.

Is Vedic maths useful for competitive exams later?

We did not find a study that answers this. The evidence we could open on Vedic maths was small and short-term. Understanding the concept matters first; shortcuts are a later extra.

Can I teach these at home instead of joining a class?

You can teach mental maths, place value and number games at home with everyday things. A structured abacus course is harder to replicate, but it is optional.

My child wants to stop. Should I insist?

Ask why. If the class is boring, tiring or stressful, stopping is a reasonable choice. The research we found does not suggest that missing abacus or Vedic maths holds a child back.

For more, read everyday maths at home, choosing extracurricular classes, or see chapter-wise lessons on Sikhora School.

Play along: Sikhora Kids has free maths and counting games for kids to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.

Sources