The short answer: play the app yourself before your child does, and keep it only if it makes your child think and do, not just tap and watch. A good app has a clear purpose, few distractions, no pushy ads or purchases, and a natural place to stop. For children under 2, the Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) says no screens at all, so this guide is for ages 2 and up, and even then an app is a small extra, never the main way a child learns.
Why the label "educational" is not enough
Back in 2015, a team of child-development researchers led by Kathy Hirsh-Pasek, Jennifer Zosh and Roberta Michnick Golinkoff noted that there were "over 80,000 apps marketed as 'educational'" in the Apple app store, and that such claims were "completely unregulated". In other words, anyone can call an app educational. The same team, publishing in Psychological Science in the Public Interest, gave parents a better test: does the app support the way children actually learn?
Five questions to ask about any app
These five questions follow the researchers' guidance. You do not need to be a tech expert to answer them; ten minutes of playing the app yourself is enough.
- Does my child have to think? The researchers suggest looking for apps that need real mental effort and avoiding ones built on passive activities like repetitive swiping. Sorting, building, matching sounds or solving a small puzzle is better than tapping a balloon again and again.
- Does it keep attention on the task? Constant sparkles, sounds and pop-ups can "take away from, rather than enhance, learning", in the researchers' words. A calm screen is a good sign.
- Does it connect to my child's life? Good apps link new ideas to what a child already knows. Counting mangoes, naming animals they saw at the zoo, or shapes they see at home all count.
- Does it bring people together? Look for apps that spark talk, turn-taking or a shared laugh, rather than ones that shut your child away from everyone.
- Does my child get to explore? Apps that let children try, make mistakes and discover are better than ones that only tell them the answer.
Red flags that should make you think twice
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) points out that "features like autoplay, endless scrolling and targeted ads aren't built with children's well-being in mind", and that some apps use rewards just for signing in to keep children coming back. When you test an app, watch for these:
- Adverts, especially ones a child can tap by mistake.
- Buttons that ask for purchases, coins or "gems", or a timer that pushes your child to buy.
- Autoplay, where the next video or level starts without anyone choosing it.
- Daily rewards just for opening the app, or streaks that make a child anxious to return.
- Chat with strangers, or sharing photos and names.
- Violent or scary content, or characters who behave badly with no one noticing.
UNICEF suggests that younger children ask permission before downloading any new app, and that parents consider controls for screen time limits, in-app purchases and content filtering. For step-by-step settings, see our guide on parental controls on an Android phone.
Quick checklist
| Look at | Good sign | Warning sign |
|---|---|---|
| What your child does | Thinks, builds, sorts, says words aloud | Swipes and taps the same thing again and again |
| The screen | Calm, simple, easy to follow | Flashing rewards, sounds and pop-ups everywhere |
| Money | No ads and no purchase buttons | Ads, coins, gems, unlock offers |
| Ending | Short rounds with a clear stop | Autoplay, endless levels, streaks |
| People | Something to talk about with you | Chat with strangers or none at all |
| Content | Age-appropriate, kind, non-violent | Scary, violent or full of marketing |
What to keep in mind at each age
- Under 2: The IAP says children below 2 years "should not be exposed to any type of screen", except occasional video calls with family who live far away. Choose stacking cups, picture books and songs instead of apps.
- 2 to 5 years: The IAP advises a maximum of 1 hour a day, with each session not more than 20 to 30 minutes, always supervised, and content that is "educational, age-appropriate, non-violent, healthy, and preferably interactive". Pick one or two good apps, not twenty.
- 5 to 10 years: The IAP says less than 2 hours a day, including screen time for homework, and that the device should belong to a parent rather than the child. Children this age can help you judge an app: ask them what they learnt and whether it felt like a game or a trap.
A parent-child activity: the app test-drive
Before a new app goes on the phone for good, give it a one-week trial together.
- Day 1: Play it alone for ten minutes. Check for ads, purchase buttons and chat. If any of the red flags show up, stop here.
- Day 2: Sit with your child while they play. Notice their face. Are they thinking, giggling, talking to you, or staring silently?
- Day 3 to 6: Let them play one short round a day while you are nearby. Ask, "What did you do today in the game?"
- Day 7: Decide together. Keep it, or delete it. If you keep it, do one real-life thing linked to it: count steps, sort spoons, or find the animal in a picture book.
This also teaches your child something useful: that apps are chosen on purpose, not picked up because they appeared on the screen.
Common mistakes
- Trusting the store label or star rating. As the researchers found, "educational" is not checked by anyone.
- Downloading many apps at once. A few good ones, used briefly, are better than a phone full of choices your child jumps between.
- Using an app to keep a child quiet at meals or before sleep. The IAP advises against screens during meals and within one hour before sleep.
- Never playing the app yourself. You cannot judge what you have not seen.
- Forgetting the off-screen version. An alphabet app is fine, but tracing letters in a tray of atta or on paper teaches more for the hand.
How Sikhora Kids fits in
We built Sikhora Kids with the checklist above in mind. It is free, has no ads and no chat, and sessions are short. On the grown-ups' page you can set break reminders and a daily play limit, and for ages 2 to 5 the screen pauses when the session time is up. Run it through the same test-drive as any other app and decide for yourself.
Want help setting simple screen rules with your family? Print our free family screen agreement and fill it in together.
Get the screen agreementFrequently asked questions
Are free apps safe for children?
Not always. Many free apps earn money through adverts or in-app purchases. Play the app yourself first and look for ads, purchase buttons and chat before you hand it over.
Is a phonics or alphabet app better than a cartoon?
It can be, if your child has to listen, think and respond, and if the sounds are clear. But it is still screen time, so keep it short and pair it with off-screen practice like tracing letters or reading a picture book together.
How many apps should my 4-year-old have?
There is no official number. In practice, two or three well-chosen apps are plenty. Fewer choices mean less jumping between apps and an easier time stopping.
My child cries when the app ends. Does that mean it is a bad app?
Not necessarily; stopping something fun is hard at this age. But if an app has endless levels, streaks or rewards just for opening it, it is designed to be hard to leave. A warning before the end, a timer and a fixed routine help.
Should my child have their own tablet?
For children aged 5 to 10, the IAP says the device should belong to one of the parents and the child should not get an independent phone, tablet or laptop. A shared family device also makes it easier to see what is being used.
Play along: Sikhora Kids has free learning games by skill and age, free to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.
Sources
- Association for Psychological Science: Educational App or Digital Candy? Helping Parents Choose Quality Apps for Kids
- Indian Academy of Pediatrics: Guidelines on Screen Time and Digital Wellness (Indian Pediatrics, March 2022)
- HealthyChildren.org (AAP): Helping Kids Thrive in a Digital World, AAP Policy Explained
- UNICEF Parenting: Healthy digital habits