The short answer: for young children, printed books are usually the better choice, and for older children, e-books are fine for some reading but paper still has an edge for study. A 2019 study in Pediatrics found that parents and toddlers talked less and collaborated less when reading electronic books than print books. The American Academy of Pediatrics calls print books the gold standard for young children. E-books are not harmful in themselves; what matters is the distractions that come with the screen, and whether a grown-up reads along.
What the research found
In the 2019 study by Munzer and colleagues, 37 parent-toddler pairs read three kinds of books in a lab: a print book, a basic e-book and an enhanced e-book with sounds and animation. With print books:
- Parents made more dialogic comments, the back-and-forth kind of talk that builds language: 11.9 with print, compared with 8.3 with basic e-books and 6.2 with enhanced e-books.
- Toddlers spoke more about the book: 15.0 times with print, 12.5 with basic and 11.5 with enhanced e-books.
- Parents made fewer comments about the device itself: 1.9 with print, compared with 8.3 and 10.0 with the e-books.
The authors concluded that paediatricians "may wish to continue promoting shared reading of print books, particularly for toddlers and younger children."
For older readers, a 2018 meta-analysis by Delgado and colleagues pooled 54 studies with over 170,000 participants. As summarised by Themantic Education, reading on screens led to slightly lower comprehension than reading on paper, with an effect size of -0.21. Paper did better when time was limited and when the text was non-fiction; there was no clear difference for stories. Scrolling texts did worse than non-scrolling ones.
By age: what to choose
Printed books and e-books
-
Printed books
- More talk between parent and child
- No pop-ups, ads or notifications
- Easier to flip back and find a page
- Fine at bedtime
-
E-books
- Wide choice, including Indian languages
- Adjustable text size
- Easy to carry while travelling
- Best read with a grown-up for young children
| Age | Mostly | If you use a screen |
|---|---|---|
| Under 3 | Board books and picture books read together on your lap | Keep it rare and shared; choose plain e-books without games or animation |
| 3 to 5 | Picture books, read aloud with lots of talk | Read along and talk about the story, not the buttons |
| 6 to 8 | Printed early readers and library books | E-books for variety; turn off sounds and in-book games |
| 9 to 12 | A mix, with paper for study and non-fiction | Fine for stories; avoid reading on the same device used for games and chat |
How to use e-books well
- Choose simple design. The AAP notes that "electronic books that contain bells and whistles can distract from the actual book content" and that children learn best from simple, streamlined design.
- Read together. Treat the screen like a book on your lap: point at pictures, ask what might happen next, and let your child turn the pages.
- Switch off extras. Turn off sound effects, games, notifications and autoplay where you can.
- Keep e-books away from bedtime. The AAP suggests e-books may be best avoided at bedtime or naptime. A printed book fits better into a bedtime routine.
- Try audiobooks. The AAP says audiobooks are particularly beneficial when adults listen with children and talk about the story. They suit long car rides and train journeys.
A parent-child activity: the two-book evening
Choose one short story in print and one similar-length story on a tablet or phone. Read the printed one first, then the screen one, a different evening. After each, ask your child to retell the story using three pictures they draw. Talk together about which one they remember better, and why. Older children enjoy being the "researcher" in their own small experiment. Keep the screen version with no games and no sounds.
Track printed books on the free reading tracker: one colouring square for every book finished. Our guide to free children's books online has ideas for finding stories to start with.
If your child uses Sikhora Kids, you can set a daily play limit and break reminders on the grown-ups' page. For ages 2 to 5 the screen pauses when the session time is up.
Open grown-ups' settingsCommon mistakes
- Handing over the tablet as a babysitter. The benefit of reading comes largely from talking together, which a device cannot replace.
- Choosing the flashiest e-book. Animations and games pull attention away from the story.
- Using the game device for reading. If the tablet is also where your child plays, reading time can slip into game time. A separate e-reader or a printed book helps.
- Assuming paper is always better for everything. For a child who struggles to read small print, larger text on a screen or an audiobook can make reading possible.
- Quizzing instead of chatting. Whether paper or screen, ask what your child thinks, not just what happened.
Frequently asked questions
Is it bad to read e-books to my toddler?
Not bad, but print books usually lead to more talking together. If you do use an e-book, choose a simple one, sit together and talk about the pictures as you would with paper.
My 10-year-old prefers reading on a tablet. Should I stop it?
No need, if they are reading. Stories on a screen are fine. For study and non-fiction, research suggests paper is understood slightly better, especially under time pressure, so encourage printed textbooks and notes for revision.
Do audiobooks count as reading?
They build listening, vocabulary and love of stories. The AAP describes audiobooks as particularly beneficial when adults listen along and talk about the content, and helpful for some children with reading difficulties.
Are e-readers better than tablets?
E-readers usually have fewer apps and notifications, so there is less to distract a child. The same simple rules apply: read together for young children and keep screens out of bedtime.
Does reading on a screen count as screen time?
It is still time on a screen, so it fits within your family's plan. Many families treat shared reading differently from games or videos. See our guide to family screen time rules.
Play along: Sikhora Kids has free reading, phonics and alphabet games for kids to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.