The short answer: in the early years, a child learns most easily in a language they already understand and speak, and English can be learnt well alongside it. India's National Curriculum Framework for the Foundational Stage (NCF-FS, NCERT 2022) says the primary medium of instruction would optimally be the child's home language, mother tongue or familiar language from age 3 to 8, in both public and private schools. So the real question is less "English or not" and more "Will my child understand what is being taught, and will they get good English teaching too?"

What India's curriculum framework says

The NCF-FS covers the Foundational Stage, ages 3 to 8 (pre-school to Class 2). On language, it says:

  • Young children learn and grasp nontrivial concepts most quickly and deeply in their home language, mother tongue or familiar language.
  • When a child is taught through an unfamiliar language, the 3 to 4 years of language experience they bring to school gets disregarded.
  • Children who study through their mother tongue or a familiar language perform better in other subjects such as Mathematics and Science than peers taught through an unfamiliar language, according to the evidence the framework cites.
  • Skills and concepts gained in the home language do not have to be retaught when a child learns a new language.
  • Children should develop strong oral language skills in at least two languages by the end of the Foundational Stage, and English can be one of them.
  • A child must never be discouraged from speaking, or made to feel ashamed of, their home language.

UNESCO says something similar: education in the mother tongue is a key factor for inclusion and quality learning, and it improves learning outcomes and academic performance.

The framework is also practical. It accepts that teaching in each child's home language is not always possible, for example where teachers do not speak it, and says that the home language should then be used to help the child move to the school's language without losing what they already know.

Rules differ by state and school

The NCF-FS is a national framework. How each state, board and school puts it into practice differs, and the language a school uses in Class 1 may not be the same in Class 6. Before you decide, ask the school directly and check your state education department's or board's own notices. This guide explains the framework; it does not describe any particular school's rules.

Comparing the two options

What each kind of school can offer

  • Mother-tongue or regional medium
    • Your child understands lessons from day one
    • Easier for parents to help with homework
    • Check: how well is English taught as a subject?
  • English medium
    • More classroom exposure to English
    • May suit families who speak English at home
    • Check: do teachers explain in the home language when children do not understand?
A good school of either kind can work well; the quality of teaching matters a great deal.

Questions to ask a school

  1. In which language do teachers explain new ideas in pre-school and Classes 1 and 2?
  2. Can children answer or ask questions in their home language if they are stuck?
  3. How is English taught, and from which class does reading and writing in English begin?
  4. Which languages are taught as subjects, and from which class?
  5. Does the medium change in later classes? If so, how are children helped through the change?
  6. Can I see the reading books children use in Class 1?

The NCF-FS suggests that, where possible, teachers allow children to respond and discuss in their home language, read simple storybooks to them in it, and explain difficult words through it. A school that does these things is following the spirit of the framework, whatever the name on its board.

Situations families often face

Common situations and what may help; every child and school is different
Your situationWhat to think aboutAt home
You speak Hindi or another Indian language at home and choose English mediumCheck that teachers explain in a language your child understands in the early yearsKeep talking and reading in your home language; add English rhymes and stories
You choose mother-tongue or regional mediumCheck how strong the English teaching isRead simple English picture books together and play English word games
Your family speaks two or more languagesThe NCF-FS says learning in more than one language, with the home language as the main one, helps children switch between languagesEach adult can keep speaking the language they speak best
You have moved to a new stateThe school language may be new to your childLearn a few words of the new language together; keep your home language strong

A parent-child activity: two-language story time

The NCF-FS describes a helpful approach for teachers: tell a familiar story in the home language several times, then retell it in the new language using the target words. Do the same at home. Pick a story your child loves, such as the thirsty crow. Tell it in Hindi or your home language on Monday and Tuesday. On Wednesday, tell it again in simple English: "The crow is thirsty. He finds a pot. There is a little water." Let your child fill in words they remember. Because they already know the story, the new words make sense straight away.

Looking for stories and letters in a calm, ad-free space? Visit the Castle world on Sikhora Kids: free, no chat, short sessions you set.

Open the Castle world

Common mistakes

  • Stopping the home language at home. Some parents switch to English only, hoping to help. The NCF-FS stresses the value of the home language for learning and for a child's identity. Your child can have both.
  • Judging a school by its name alone. An "English medium" label says little about how well teachers explain or how much children read.
  • Worrying about mixing languages. The NCF-FS encourages acceptance of mixed use of the home language and the new language while children are learning. Mixing is a normal step.
  • Expecting fluency in months. Learning a new language takes time. Look for steady progress, not perfection.

If your child seems very unhappy at school, is not speaking at all in class for a long time, or is struggling to understand lessons, talk to their class teacher. If you have concerns about your child's speech or language development, talk to your paediatrician.

For more on choosing a school, read CBSE, ICSE or state board. To support Hindi at home, see teaching Hindi to young children, and for older children, Sikhora School has chapter lessons for classes.

Frequently asked questions

Will my child fall behind in English in a mother-tongue medium school?

Not necessarily. The NCF-FS aims for oral skills in at least two languages by the end of the Foundational Stage, and English can be one of them. What matters is how well English is taught as a subject and how much your child hears and reads it.

Is it confusing for a child to learn two or three languages at once?

The NCF-FS says bilingual or multilingual approaches with the home language as the main language help children switch efficiently between languages. Many Indian children grow up with two or three languages.

We speak English at home. Is English medium then the mother-tongue option for us?

If English is the language your child understands and speaks best, then it is their familiar language. The framework's point is to teach in a language the child already knows well.

Does the board decide the medium of instruction?

Boards, states and schools each have their own rules, and these can change. Ask the school and check your board's or state's official notices before you decide.

My child's school uses a language we do not speak at home. What can I do?

Keep your home language strong, learn a few words of the school language together, and ask the teacher how they help children who are new to it. The NCF-FS suggests that the home language should be used to support a child's move into the school's language.

Sources