The short answer: disagreements between parents and grandparents are normal, and both sides usually want the same thing: a happy, healthy child. Decide which of your rules are flexible and which are firm, explain the firm ones to elders privately and with respect, and let small differences go. Keep arguments away from the children, and make sure the child hears one clear message on the things that matter.
You are not alone
Research on this comes mostly from other countries, but the patterns will sound familiar. A 2020 national poll in the United States by C.S. Mott Children's Hospital asked 2,016 parents about their children's grandparents. Among parents whose child sees a grandparent often or occasionally, 6% reported major disagreements and 37% minor ones. The most common topics were discipline (57%), meals and snacks (44%) and TV or screen time (36%). Of parents reporting disagreements, 40% said grandparents were 'too soft', 14% said too tough, and 46% said both. An article from the Triple P parenting programme puts it this way: research has found that 4 out of 10 parents disagree with grandparents over how to raise children.
In a joint family, where grandparents live under the same roof and often do much of the daily care, these questions come up every day: the extra laddoo, the late-night TV serial, the 'one slap never hurt anyone', the oil massage, the phone at dinner.
Why it happens
- Advice has changed. What was standard when grandparents raised their own children may differ from what doctors and schools say today.
- Different roles. Triple P notes that grandparents often like to indulge grandchildren and may feel day-to-day discipline is no longer their job.
- Advice can sound like criticism. Triple P also notes that grandparents' frequent suggestions, meant as help, can feel to parents like constant criticism.
- In-laws add delicacy. When the disagreement is with your spouse's parents, it can feel harder to speak up.
Step by step: sort, talk, agree
From friction to a family plan
- Sort your rules Which are firm (safety, health, sleep) and which can bend (an extra sweet at Dadi's)
- Agree as parents first Both parents decide together before talking to elders
- Talk privately A calm moment, not in front of the children or guests
- Explain the why Share what the doctor or teacher said; ask for their experience too
- Give them a yes Keep or invite a tradition they love, so it is not only rules
- Review after a few weeks Thank them for what is working; adjust what is not
Sarah Clark, a co-director of the Mott poll, suggested parents determine which rules are flexible and which are deal-breakers, and for the firm ones, help grandparents understand why they matter. She also noted that it is easy to fall back on old habits. So expect to give gentle reminders more than once.
Words that help
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| You are spoiling him. | He loves his time with you. Can we keep sweets to after lunch so he eats his dal? |
| That is old-fashioned. | The doctor told us to do it this way now. What did you do when I was small? |
| Don't give her the phone. | We are trying no screens before school. Could you help us with the morning story instead? |
| You never listen to me. | I need your help with this one. It really matters to us. |
Keep the children out of the middle
- Do not argue in front of them. Step into another room or wait.
- Do not ask children to choose. 'Who is right, Mummy or Dadi?' puts a child in an impossible place.
- Explain small differences simply. 'At Nani's house there are different rules, and that is okay. At home, we do it this way.'
- Never use grandparents as the villain, or the reverse. Children should feel all their elders love them.
- Back each other. If a grandparent has already said no, check with them before saying yes.
A family activity: the 'house rules' poster
Make a big poster with everyone, grandparents included. Children draw, elders and parents decide the words. Keep it to five rules that everyone, adults too, will follow, such as 'No phones at dinner', 'We speak softly when someone is sleeping', 'Bedtime story at 9'. Our family screen agreement can be the screen part of it. Let the grandparents add one family tradition, like Sunday evening bhajans or Dada's stories after dinner. Stick it where everyone can see. When a rule is broken, point to the poster rather than at a person. With little ones, keep scissors with an adult and use child-safe glue.
Agree screen rules that the whole household follows, grandparents included. Print the free family screen agreement.
Get the screen agreementCommon mistakes
- Fighting every battle. If everything is a deal-breaker, nothing is. Save firmness for safety, health and the few values that matter most.
- Talking through the children. Messages like 'Tell Dadi I said no' cause more hurt.
- Only the daughter-in-law speaking up. In a joint family, it often works better when each parent speaks to their own parents.
- Forgetting to say thank you. Grandparents who help with care give a great deal. Appreciation makes the hard conversations easier.
- Expecting change overnight. Long habits take time.
Frequently asked questions
My mother-in-law feeds my child sweets all day. How do I raise it?
Speak with your spouse first, then have your spouse raise it gently with their mother. Suggest a middle path, such as one sweet after lunch, rather than a complete ban. Meals and snacks were the second most common topic in the Mott poll, so this is a very common worry.
Grandparents believe in a slap now and then. What can I do?
Treat this as a firm rule. Explain privately and calmly that you have decided against hitting, and offer what you do instead, like a time-in or taking away a privilege. Ask for their help to stay consistent. Our guide on teaching good manners has gentle approaches you can share.
My child plays one adult against the other. How do I stop it?
Agree that a 'no' from one adult stands until you have checked with each other. Children quickly learn when the adults are on the same team.
What if grandparents refuse to change?
Keep talking calmly, focus on the one or two things that matter most, and acknowledge their love. If tension at home is causing your child distress, or the adults cannot talk without fighting, a family counsellor can help everyone find common ground.
Is it okay for rules to be different at the grandparents' place?
Small differences, like a later bedtime on holidays, are usually fine and part of what makes time with grandparents special. Keep the firm rules about safety and health the same everywhere.
For more on agreeing family-wide screen rules, read family screen time rules, or browse all our parent guides.