The short answer: the toys that help most are simple, open-ended ones that a child can use in many ways, such as blocks, balls, dolls and animal figures, puzzles, crayons and clay, and card and board games as they grow. The biggest ingredient is not the toy but you playing with it. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) says research shows the best toys "need not be flashy or expensive or come with an app", and recommends choosing toys that are not overstimulating and encourage children to use their imaginations.

Why simple toys beat flashing ones

A toy that does everything by itself leaves little for the child to do. A plain set of blocks can be a tower, a train, a wall for toy cows or a road for a car. The AAP's report on toys says that one of the most important purposes of play with toys, especially in infancy, "is not educational": it is the warm back-and-forth between the child and the adult. It also says you do not get the same rewards from a tablet or screen. In other words, a steel katori and a wooden spoon in your hands can teach more than a gadget left in a corner.

Kinds of toys and what they build

Five kinds of toys worth having

  • Pretend play
    • Dolls and soft toys
    • Animal figures
    • Kitchen set or real steel utensils
  • Hands and fingers
    • Blocks
    • Shape sorters and puzzles
    • Stacking cups
  • Art
    • Crayons
    • Clay or dough
    • Old newspaper to draw on
  • Words and thinking
    • Picture books
    • Card games
    • Board games
  • Big movement
    • Balls
    • Push and pull toys
    • Tricycle or ride-on
Groups based on the AAP's toy categories. Aim for a little from each, not lots from one.

What to choose at each age

A rough guide. Choose by what your child can do now, not only by the age on the box.
AgeToys that helpSimple home versions
Under 1Rattles, soft balls, cloth books, a safe unbreakable mirrorA steel bowl and spoon to bang, a cloth to play peek-a-boo
1 to 2Stacking cups, large chunky blocks, push and pull toys, board booksNesting katoris, a cardboard box to push, a big ball
2 to 3Simple puzzles, shape sorters, dolls, toy animals, crayonsSorting rajma and moong into bowls with you, a doll's bath with a mug
3 to 5Building blocks, dough, pretend kitchen or shop, picture lotto, a tricycleA pretend dukaan with empty packets, playing chef with dough
6 to 8Board and card games, construction sets, art supplies, skipping ropeSnakes and ladders, ludo, carrom, a homemade marble run from tubes
9 to 12Strategy games like chess, models and kits, musical instruments, sports gearCooking without fire, gardening tools, a cricket bat and tennis ball

The AAP says ideal toys are those that match children's developmental abilities, and its report also looks at how suitable toys are for children with special needs. In practice: pick toys that match what your child can do now and gently stretch them.

Safety checks before you buy or make a toy

  • Small parts and under-3s. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission advises keeping small toys and parts of toys, marbles, balloons, small balls and coins off the floor and out of reach of children. It also warns that uninflated balloons and pieces of popped balloons can choke and kill a small child. This matters in homes with older siblings, whose toys often have small pieces.
  • Batteries and magnets. The AAP advises avoiding toys with button batteries or high-powered magnets.
  • Follow the age label. The CPSC says age recommendations on labels are based on safety concerns.
  • Think about supervision. The AAP suggests considering how much adult help is needed for safe play, and how the toy might be misused.
  • Homemade toys. Seal bottle shakers firmly with tape, use only food-safe items, and keep scissors and glue guns with the adult.

A parent-child activity: the toy rotation basket

Too many toys at once can make children flit from one to another. Put most toys away in a bag or trunk and keep out only one basket with five or six things, one from each group above if you can. Every Sunday, swap the basket with your child. Let them choose one toy to bring back and one to put away. Old toys feel new again, your child plays longer with each, and you can see which toys they really use. While they play, sit nearby and talk about what they are doing: "You put the big block at the bottom. Will the small one stay on top?"

Common mistakes

  • Believing the box. Words like "genius" or "brain-boosting" on packaging are marketing, not evidence.
  • Buying for the next age up. Toys that are too hard frustrate children, and may not be safe for them.
  • Leaving the child alone with the toy. Talk, name things and take turns; that is where much of the learning happens.
  • Swapping toys for screens. The AAP notes that electronic toys by themselves do not give children the interaction they need.
  • Gender rules. The AAP warns that toys can promote stereotypes. Let boys cook and girls build.

Want ideas that need no toys at all? Print free activity sheets, from counting to tracing letters, to use with what you already have at home.

Browse free printables

Frequently asked questions

Are electronic learning toys bad?

Not bad, but not necessary. The AAP says the best toys need not be flashy or expensive or come with an app, and that electronic toys by themselves do not provide children with the interaction and parental engagement they need. If you have one, play with it together.

How many toys does a toddler need?

Fewer than you think. A handful of open-ended toys, rotated every week or two, keeps play fresh. Kitchen utensils, boxes and cloth are toys too.

Can my 2-year-old play with an older sibling's toys?

Only with care. Many toys for older children have small parts, marbles or batteries. Keep the older child's sets on a high shelf or a separate room, and check the floor after play.

Are traditional Indian toys good for learning?

Many are excellent: spinning tops, wooden kitchen sets, pallanguzhi or chowka bara boards, and dolls all invite counting, turn-taking and pretend play. Check that paints are child-safe and that small pieces are kept away from under-3s.

Is a tablet a learning toy?

The AAP report says you do not get the same benefits from a screen as from toys used with a caregiver. If you allow screen time, keep it short and shared, and see our guide on educational games versus other mobile games.

More reading: learning through play, board games by age and educational games vs mobile games.

Sources