The short answer: a smartwatch can be a reasonable middle step for some children who travel alone or need to call home, but it is not a safety guarantee, and it is a device that sends your child's location and sometimes voice over the internet. Decide what problem you want it to solve first. If you do get one, choose it carefully, lock down its settings, and keep talking with your child about safety, because a watch cannot replace that.
What a children's smartwatch usually does
Most children's smartwatches can make calls to a few saved numbers, show the child's location to a parent's app, and send an alert if the child presses an SOS button or leaves a set area (often called a geofence). Some add cameras, messaging, games or step counting. Each extra feature is something more to set up, check and talk about.
What testing has found
In October 2017, the Norwegian Consumer Council tested four children's smartwatches bought in Norwegian shops, with a technical analysis by a security company. Consumers International, reporting the findings, said that "in a few simple steps, a stranger can take control of the watch" on some models, that data travelled and was stored without encryption, that SOS functions on two watches were particularly poor, and that alerts for a child leaving a permitted area were unreliable. Those were specific models in 2017, and products change, but the lesson holds: a watch can give a false sense of security, and a weak one can put a child's information at risk.
Questions to ask before you decide
Do we need a smartwatch?
-
What is the reason?
- Travelling alone to tuition or school
- Calling home after an activity
- Worry about getting lost in crowds
- Friends have one
-
Is there a simpler way?
- A trusted adult at pick-up
- Your phone number written inside the bag
- A basic phone with calls only
- Practising what to do if lost
-
If yes, what is the least we need?
- Calls to a few saved numbers
- Location for the parent only
- No open chat, no camera, no games
- Who can contact the watch? Prefer watches where only numbers you add can call or message it.
- Where does the data go, and can you delete it? Read the app's privacy information. If you cannot find who stores the data or how to delete the account, think twice.
- Is there a listening or 'monitor' feature? Some watches let an adult call the watch silently and hear the surroundings. That is a serious privacy matter for your child and the people around them. Avoid it.
- How long will it get updates? The UK's National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) suggests checking how long the maker will support a device and calls the support date a "use by" date for your device.
- What does your child's school allow? Rules on watches and phones differ by school, so check before buying.
Settings to check on day one
The NCSC's advice on smart devices at home applies to children's watches too:
- Change any default password, on the watch and the parent app, to a strong one. NCSC suggests three random words.
- Turn on 2-step verification for the parent app if it is offered.
- Switch on automatic updates, and install any manual updates when prompted.
- Switch off remote access if you do not need it, as NCSC advises. On a child's watch, also switch off extras you do not need, such as the camera, games or open messaging.
- Factory reset before passing it on to a younger child, or selling or giving it away.
| Age | What often makes sense | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Under 6 | Usually no need; children this age should be with a trusted adult | Games and screens on the wrist add screen time |
| 6 to 8 | Only if there is a clear need, with calls to two or three numbers | Children may press SOS by mistake or think it makes them safe anywhere |
| 9 to 12 | Can help with independent travel, with clear family rules | Messaging, cameras and peer pressure; agree rules before, not after |
A parent-child activity: the 'what if' walk
Whether or not you buy a watch, take a walk around your area or market with your child and play "what if". What if you cannot find me? (Stay where you are, ask a shopkeeper or a mother with children, say my number.) What if someone you do not know says I sent them? (Do not go; we will have a family code word.) Let your child lead the way home while you follow. At home, write the plan on a card for their bag. This builds the habits a watch cannot. If you do get a watch, practise pressing the call button together and agree when the SOS button is for.
Write your family's device rules together. The free family screen agreement is a simple printable you can fill in with your child, and it works for watches too.
Get the family agreementCommon mistakes
- Treating the location dot as a guarantee. Location can be slow or wrong, and testing has found alerts that did not work well. Keep your other safety plans.
- Buying the most features. Every extra feature is another way in. Choose the simplest watch that does the job.
- Tracking secretly. Older children deserve to know what the watch shares and with whom. Secret tracking damages trust.
- Skipping the setup. Default passwords and open contact lists are the biggest risks, and they take minutes to fix.
- Using it to end all worry. Talk with your child often about safety; that matters more than any device.
If you are also thinking about a phone, read the right age for a first smartphone and teaching your child not to share personal details.
Frequently asked questions
Is a smartwatch better than a phone for a young child?
It can be a smaller step, with fewer apps and less internet, if you choose a simple one. But it still shares location and may have messaging, so it needs the same care with settings and rules.
Can I rely on the SOS button?
Do not rely on it alone. Consumer testing in 2017 found SOS functions on some watches were particularly poor. Test it yourself at home, and keep teaching your child what to do if they are lost.
Should my child's watch have a camera or games?
For most children, no. Cameras and games add screen time and privacy questions without adding safety.
Will the school allow it?
Rules differ by school. Ask the class teacher or check the school handbook before buying.
What should I teach my child about the watch?
What it shares and with whom, who can call it, when to use SOS, never to share its number with strangers, and to tell you if anything strange happens on it.