The short answer: carrying (haasil) and borrowing are both about one idea: ten ones make one ten. Teach that idea with real objects first, such as bundles of ten ice-cream sticks or pretend ₹10 notes and ₹1 coins, then with drawings, and only then with the written sum. A child who has physically swapped ten loose sticks for one bundle understands why the little 1 goes on top of the tens column, and will not forget it.

Check this first: does your child understand tens and ones?

Before carrying, your child should be able to show 34 as three bundles of ten and four loose sticks, and tell you that the 3 in 34 means thirty. If they cannot yet, spend a week on that first. Our guide to counting with objects has activities for this stage.

Many teachers now say regrouping or exchanging rather than carrying and borrowing. A blog for teachers at HFL Education, drawing on the maths educator Derek Haylock, calls concrete and pictorial materials vital for understanding written addition and subtraction, and recommends a place value chart used with objects. The written method comes last.

What you need

  • About 100 ice-cream sticks, matchsticks with the heads removed, or straws, plus rubber bands
  • Or pretend money: paper ₹100, ₹10 and ₹1 notes you make together
  • A sheet of paper ruled into columns labelled H, T and O (hundreds, tens, ones)
  • Keep rubber bands and small sticks away from babies and toddlers, who may put them in their mouths

Teaching carrying in addition

The order to teach regrouping

  1. Objects Bundle ten loose sticks into one ten with your hands
  2. Pictures Draw lines for tens and dots for ones, and circle ten dots
  3. Columns Write the sum in tens and ones columns beside the sticks
  4. Written sum The child explains each carried 1 in their own words
Spend several sessions on each step. Move on only when the step before feels easy.

Work through 47 + 25 together. Put out 4 bundles and 7 loose sticks, then 2 bundles and 5 loose sticks. Start with the ones, always: 7 + 5 is 12 loose sticks. Ask, "Can we make a bundle?" Your child counts out ten, puts a rubber band round them and moves the new bundle across to the tens. Two loose sticks stay in the ones. Now count the bundles: 4 + 2 + 1 is 7. The answer is 72. Only now write it as a column sum, putting the small 1 above the tens, and ask, "Where did this 1 come from?"

Teaching borrowing in subtraction

Borrowing is the same swap in reverse: one ten is opened up into ten ones. Try 52 − 17. Put out 5 bundles and 2 loose sticks, and only those. Do not put out the 17, because that is the amount you are taking away. You need to take 7 loose sticks, but there are only 2. Ask, "What can we do?" Your child takes the rubber band off one bundle: now there are 4 bundles and 12 loose sticks. Take away 7 loose sticks, leaving 5. Take away 1 bundle, leaving 3. The answer is 35. Then write it, crossing out the 5 to make 4 and writing a small 1 next to the 2 to make 12.

Go in small steps. The teaching materials of England's National Centre for Excellence in the Teaching of Mathematics (NCETM) follow the same order: regrouping in the ones column first, then in the tens column, and subtraction with exchanging from a two-digit number before moving to three-digit numbers.

Worked examples to try in order, from easiest to hardest
SumWhat happensAnswer
34 + 25No regrouping: 9 ones, 5 tens59
47 + 2512 ones become 1 ten and 2 ones72
68 + 57Regroup in ones, then 12 tens become 1 hundred and 2 tens125
52 - 17Open 1 ten into 10 ones: 12 - 7, then 4 - 135
403 - 158No tens to open: open 1 hundred into 10 tens, then 1 ten into 10 ones245

The last example, with a zero in the middle, is where most children get stuck. Do it with sticks (or pretend ₹100, ₹10 and ₹1 notes) more than once before trying it on paper.

A parent-child activity: the bank game

Make paper ₹1, ₹10 and ₹100 notes. One player is the banker. Roll two dice and take that many ₹1 notes from the bank. Whenever you have ten ₹1 notes, you must go to the banker and swap them for one ₹10. Ten ₹10s swap for a ₹100. The first to reach ₹100 wins. For borrowing, play in reverse: everyone starts with one ₹100 note and pays the bank the dice total; when you cannot pay, you must ask the banker to break a bigger note. Younger children can practise with pretend rupees in the Toyshop world on Sikhora Kids, which is free, with no ads and no real purchases.

Common mistakes to watch for

  • Writing 12 in the ones place. 47 + 25 becomes 612. Go back to the sticks: can a column hold more than nine loose sticks?
  • Forgetting to add the carried 1. Ask your child to say each step out loud.
  • Subtracting the smaller digit from the bigger one. For 52 − 17, a child writes 45 because 7 − 2 is 5. Ask, "Do we have 7 loose sticks to take away?"
  • Forgetting to reduce the tens after borrowing. Have them cross out and rewrite the tens digit every time.
  • Starting from the left. Always begin with the ones column.
  • Rushing to speed. Accuracy and explanation come first; speed comes with practice.

Short, free maths games with pretend rupees, with no ads, no chat and break reminders you control.

Open the Toyshop world

Frequently asked questions

Which class learns carrying and borrowing?

It usually comes in the early primary years, with two-digit numbers first and three-digit numbers later, but the order differs by board and textbook. Check your child's maths book or ask the teacher, and practise the same method the school uses.

My child's school uses a different method from the one I learnt. What should I do?

Use the school's method and words so your child is not confused. Objects and drawings help with any method, because they show what the numbers mean.

My child can do the steps but cannot explain them. Is that a problem?

It can become one with harder sums. Ask them to show you the sum with sticks or notes. If they can, they understand it.

How long should practice take?

Ten to fifteen focused minutes, a few times a week, is plenty. Stop while your child is still enjoying it.

My child keeps struggling even with objects. What next?

Go back a step to tens and ones, and talk to their teacher about what they see in class. If number difficulties persist across many topics, the teacher can advise whether further support would help.

For more maths through daily life, read everyday maths at home.

Play along: Sikhora Kids has free maths and counting games for kids to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.

Sources