The short answer: a live video call with grandparents or family is not the same as watching videos, and you do not need to count it the way you count cartoons. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has said since 2016 that it is fine for infants and young children to video chat, and calls it "relationship time". What makes the difference is a real person responding to your child, with you beside them. A call that drifts into your child watching the phone alone is back to being ordinary screen time.

Why video calls are treated differently

Most screen-time advice for young children is about passive watching. The World Health Organization's guidelines say screen time is not recommended for babies under 1, and that for children aged 2 to 4 sedentary screen time should be no more than 1 hour a day, with less being better. The AAP notes that infants under 18 months learn best from real-world interactions.

A video call is closer to a real-world interaction than to a cartoon. The AAP's media experts point out that calls are usually short and full of language, and that research suggests toddlers can learn new words over video chat, especially when the adult responds to and builds on what the child says. Surveys during the COVID-19 pandemic found grandparents felt closer to their grandchildren when they video chatted more often.

Video call or screen time?

  • Relationship time
    • A real person talks and listens to your child
    • A parent sits alongside and helps
    • Short, warm, two-way
    • Ends with a goodbye
  • Ordinary screen time
    • Your child watches or scrolls alone
    • Nobody responds to what the child says
    • Goes on and on
    • Ends with a tantrum when the phone is taken
The same phone can be used both ways. What matters is what happens on it.

What babies and toddlers understand

According to the AAP, around 18 to 24 months toddlers start to understand that what they see on a screen represents something in real life, that the face on the screen really is Nani. At first a toddler may think the person is inside the phone. With repeated calls they learn that Nani is in her own home far away. It helps if the grandparent shows their surroundings: the balcony, the tulsi plant, the dog.

Babies need your help most. The AAP notes that infants look at the screen only about 41% of the time during calls, so a parent guiding their attention makes a big difference.

How to make calls work: practical steps

  1. Pick a regular time. The AAP suggests scheduling calls at a consistent time, every night or every week, so they become a routine your child looks forward to. Sunday morning with Dadi, for example.
  2. Link the call to an activity. Mealtime, a shared storybook, or toys kept nearby. Grandparents can read the same book on their side.
  3. Turn off the TV and silence notifications. Ask the grandparents to do the same, so everyone can hear.
  4. Sit with your child and narrate. Point at the screen and say, "Look, Nanu is waving! He is showing you his newspaper."
  5. Play, do not interview. Peek-a-boo, singing, a dance, making funny noises or showing a favourite toy. The AAP suggests all of these.
  6. Explain glitches. If the picture freezes, say, "Oh, the phone is stuck. Nani is still there."
  7. Let your child take the lead as they grow. A 5-year-old can press the call button, choose what to show and say goodbye.

What to try at each age

Video calls with family, as a rough guide
AgeTry thisKeep in mind
Under 1Short calls on your lap; grandparent sings and smilesYour baby will look away often; guide their attention
1 to 2Peek-a-boo, showing toys, waving goodbyeToddlers may think Nani is inside the phone at first
2 to 4Shared book reading, show-and-tell, singing rhymes togetherKeep it short and end before your child gets restless
5 to 8Your child tells about their day, shows schoolwork, plays a guessing gameTeach them to sit where they can be seen and to say goodbye
9 and upYour child calls grandparents themselves, perhaps to ask about family storiesAgree when and how long, as part of your family's screen rules

A parent-child activity: the guessing box

Before the call, help your child put three things in a small box or bag: a spoon, a toy car, a flower from the garden. During the call, your child gives clues ("It is shiny and we eat with it") and the grandparents guess. Then swap: Nana hides something at his end and gives clues. It keeps everyone talking, builds describing words and gives the grandparents a real part to play.

  • For toddlers: just hide one toy behind your back and say "Where is it? Here it is!"
  • For older children: add a rule, such as three clues only, or clues in Hindi or your home language.
  • Safety: for children under 3, choose objects too big to fit in the mouth, and keep the phone charger and cable out of reach during calls.

Write your family's screen rules together, including when video calls happen, with the free family screen agreement from Sikhora Kids.

Get the agreement

Common mistakes

  • Leaving a toddler alone with the phone. Without you, a call quickly becomes your child tapping and staring.
  • Letting a call slide into videos. "Just one cartoon after Nani hangs up" is screen time, and it is fine to count it that way.
  • Calls at bedtime that run long. Keep calls well before sleep, or very short and calm if they are part of the bedtime routine.
  • Forcing a tired child to talk. If your child is cranky, say a quick goodbye and try tomorrow. Grandparents usually understand.
  • Different rules for grandparents' phones. If grandparents live with you, agree together what counts as a call and what counts as screen time.

If grandparents and parents see screens differently, read grandparents and screen time rules. For the youngest children, see screen time for 2-year-olds. On Sikhora Kids' grown-ups' page you can set break reminders and a daily play limit for the games, separately from calls.

Frequently asked questions

Should I count video calls in my child's daily screen limit?

The AAP treats live calls with family as relationship time rather than screen time, so you need not count them, as long as a parent is involved and the call is two-way. If a call becomes your child watching alone, count that part.

Is it okay for my 10-month-old to video call her grandparents?

Yes. The AAP has said since 2016 that video chatting is fine for infants and young children. Hold your baby on your lap and keep calls short.

My toddler just grabs the phone and presses buttons. What should I do?

Hold the phone yourself at a little distance, give your child a toy to show, and narrate what the grandparent is doing. Interest grows with repeated calls.

Are recorded voice or video messages from grandparents the same as calls?

They are lovely to have, but they are one-way, so they are closer to watching a video. Watch them together and talk about them.

My child talks to cousins on video calls for an hour. Is that too much?

Long calls between children can turn into watching each other's screens. Agree on a time limit, and suggest something to do together, like drawing the same picture.

Sources