The short answer: a conclusion follows only if it is true in every possible Venn diagram that fits the statements. If you can draw even one diagram in which the conclusion is false, it does not follow. Treat the statements as true even if they look silly in real life, and ignore your own knowledge of the world.

The four statement types

Statement types and what they allow
StatementMeaningYou can also say
All A are BA circle sits inside BSome B are A
No A is BTwo separate circlesNo B is A
Some A are BThe circles overlapSome B are A
Some A are not BPart of A lies outside BNothing about B reversed

Combining two statements

What follows from two statements
FirstSecondConclusion
All A are BAll B are CAll A are C
All A are BNo B is CNo A is C
Some A are BAll B are CSome A are C
No A is BAll B are CSome C are not A
Some A are BSome B are CNo definite conclusion

Example 1: all, then all

Statements. All pens are books. All books are cups.

I. All pens are cups. Pens sit inside books, which sit inside cups, so this follows. II. Some cups are pens. Since all pens are cups, at least some cups are pens, so this follows. III. All cups are books. Cups may be larger than books, so it does not follow. Answer: I and II.

Example 2: some, then all

Statements. Some doctors are teachers. All teachers are singers.

I. Some doctors are singers. The doctors who are teachers are inside singers, so this follows. II. All doctors are singers. Only some doctors are teachers; the others may not be singers, so it does not follow. Answer: only I.

Example 3: no, then all

Statements. No cat is a dog. All dogs are animals.

I. No cat is an animal. Cats may well be animals; the statements say nothing against it, so it does not follow. II. Some animals are not cats. Dogs are animals and no dog is a cat, so some animals are not cats. This follows. Answer: only II.

Example 4: some, then some

Statements. Some roads are wide. Some wide things are rivers.

Conclusion. Some roads are rivers. Draw roads and rivers as two separate circles, each overlapping a third circle for 'wide', without touching each other. Both statements hold and the conclusion is false, so it does not follow. Two 'some' statements give no definite conclusion.

Either-or

When two conclusions are 'Some A are C' and 'No A is C', exactly one of them is true, whichever diagram you draw. Banking-style papers often ask for this case: the answer is that either I or II follows.

Common mistakes

  • Using real-life knowledge. 'All dogs are cats' is true in the question if the statement says so.
  • Drawing only one diagram. Always try the diagram that breaks the conclusion.
  • Treating 'Some A are B' as 'Some A are not B'. In exam logic these are separate statements.
  • Assuming 'All A are B' means 'All B are A'.
  • Accepting a 'some' conclusion from two 'some' statements.

Why the Venn method is safer

Rules in a table are quick, but they only cover the common pairs. A diagram lets you test any conclusion, including ones with three statements. Draw each statement with the loosest circles it allows, then try to move the circles about so that the conclusion becomes false. If you cannot, it follows. This habit of trying to break the conclusion is what separates correct answers from lucky ones.

Course · Beginner · Free

Logical Reasoning — Syllogism: Foundation

Foundation course on Syllogism (Logical Reasoning): the basics, explained from the start.

Practise syllogisms in a timed test.

Take a practice test

Frequently asked questions

What does 'follows' mean in syllogism?

A conclusion follows if it is true in every possible diagram of the statements. If one valid diagram makes it false, it does not follow.

Is 'Some A are B' the same as 'Some B are A'?

Yes. A 'some' statement can be turned around without losing its meaning.

Does 'All A are B' give 'Some B are A'?

Yes. If every A is in B, at least some of B are A, as long as A has members, which is assumed in these questions.

What is the either-or case?

When one conclusion is the direct opposite of the other, for example 'Some A are C' and 'No A is C', one of them must be true, so either follows.

Should I draw a diagram every time?

For two statements, the table of rules is faster. For three or more statements, or if you are unsure, draw the diagram.