Why the two set-ups differ
-
Open flask
- Carbon dioxide escapes into the air
- Balance reading falls
- Looks as if mass is lost
-
Closed flask
- Gas stays trapped in the balloon
- Reading stays the same
- Shows that mass is conserved
Law of conservation of mass: mass can neither be created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction. Total mass of reactants = total mass of products.
| Change | Open container | Closed container |
|---|---|---|
| Salt dissolving in water | Mass unchanged | Mass unchanged |
| Precipitate forming (no gas) | Mass unchanged | Mass unchanged |
| Reaction giving off a gas | Mass appears to fall | Mass unchanged |
| Burning a candle or fuel | Mass appears to fall (gases escape) | Mass unchanged |
Key takeaways: Mass stays the same in physical changes and in chemical reactions. If a gas forms in an open container, the balance shows a drop only because the gas escapes. Lavoisier's law of conservation of mass says the total mass of the reactants equals the total mass of the products, which lets you find a missing mass by addition or subtraction.