| Model | Strength for public service | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Weberian bureaucracy | Impartiality, predictability, protection against favour | Rigidity, goal displacement, coldness |
| Wilson's dichotomy | Neutral, professional implementation | Moral detachment from policy effects |
| Managerial reform (New Public Management) | Results, efficiency, user focus | Gaming targets, neglect of equity |
| New Public Service | Citizenship, dialogue, public interest | Can be vague; slower decisions |
Keep Weber's impartiality, avoid Merton's rigidity: apply rules faithfully to their purpose, with recorded reasons.
- Weber's bureaucracy made impartiality and integrity central to public service.
- Merton showed how rule-following can become goal displacement and trained incapacity.
- Wilson's divide supports neutrality but risks moral detachment.
- Aptitude combines impersonal fairness with purposive judgement, as in Aristotle's epieikeia.