Models of administration and their risks
ModelStrength for public serviceRisk
Weberian bureaucracyImpartiality, predictability, protection against favourRigidity, goal displacement, coldness
Wilson's dichotomyNeutral, professional implementationMoral detachment from policy effects
Managerial reform (New Public Management)Results, efficiency, user focusGaming targets, neglect of equity
New Public ServiceCitizenship, dialogue, public interestCan be vague; slower decisions

Keep Weber's impartiality, avoid Merton's rigidity: apply rules faithfully to their purpose, with recorded reasons.

  • Weber's bureaucracy made impartiality and integrity central to public service.
  • Merton showed how rule-following can become goal displacement and trained incapacity.
  • Wilson's divide supports neutrality but risks moral detachment.
  • Aptitude combines impersonal fairness with purposive judgement, as in Aristotle's epieikeia.