| Aspect | Compliance approach | Integrity approach |
|---|---|---|
| Core aim | Prevent misconduct | Enable responsible conduct |
| Image of the employee | Someone who may cheat if unwatched | A moral agent who can be trusted with judgement |
| Main tools | Rules, controls, audits, penalties | Values, leadership, training, ethics advice, fair systems |
| Typical failure | Box-ticking; 'if it is not forbidden, it is allowed' | Vagueness; values without consequences |
| Philosophical echo | Rule-based deontology, legal positivism | Virtue ethics and Kantian autonomy |
Rules fix the floor; values raise the ceiling. A code needs both, and leadership decides which one people actually believe.
- Paine distinguished compliance strategies from integrity strategies.
- Kant's shopkeeper shows the gap between right action and right motive.
- Glaucon's ring of Gyges is the challenge every detection-only system implicitly accepts.
- Use compliance for red lines and integrity tools for grey zones.