Two strategies compared
AspectCompliance approachIntegrity approach
Core aimPrevent misconductEnable responsible conduct
Image of the employeeSomeone who may cheat if unwatchedA moral agent who can be trusted with judgement
Main toolsRules, controls, audits, penaltiesValues, leadership, training, ethics advice, fair systems
Typical failureBox-ticking; 'if it is not forbidden, it is allowed'Vagueness; values without consequences
Philosophical echoRule-based deontology, legal positivismVirtue ethics and Kantian autonomy

Rules fix the floor; values raise the ceiling. A code needs both, and leadership decides which one people actually believe.

  • Paine distinguished compliance strategies from integrity strategies.
  • Kant's shopkeeper shows the gap between right action and right motive.
  • Glaucon's ring of Gyges is the challenge every detection-only system implicitly accepts.
  • Use compliance for red lines and integrity tools for grey zones.