| Test | Question | Compassion passes when | Favouritism shows when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basis | Is there a lawful, preferably published, basis for the help? | A rule, scheme or discretion exists for such cases | Help is invented for this person |
| Consistency | Would anyone in the same situation get the same help? | Yes, the same is done for all similar cases | Only this person, because of who they are |
| Relevance | Is the reason for help the person's need? | Need, vulnerability or urgency | Relationship, caste, religion, influence or likeability |
| Transparency | Could the help be recorded and explained publicly? | Reasons are recorded and defensible | It must be kept quiet |
Basis, consistency, relevance, transparency: compassion passes all four; favouritism fails at least one.
- Use the four tests to judge any act of 'help'.
- Compassion must be equally accessible; unpublicised relief can become unfair.
- Favouritism often disguises itself as compassion; check the reason and consistency.
- Repeated hardship should lead to fairer rules.