What goes wrong when one quality is missing
Missing qualityWhat the officer looks likeRisk to the public
Integrity missingSkilled and loyal, but serves whoever rewards himCompetence used for wrong ends; capable cover-ups
Competence missingHonest and loyal, but cannot deliverGood intentions, poor results; honest failure
Loyalty missingHonest and able, but no commitment to the team or missionUnreliable cooperation; the organisation cannot depend on him

Rule to remember: loyalty runs from the widest circle inward, law and public first, organisation next, individuals last. Use voice within the system before considering exit; silence is not loyalty.

Key takeaways: loyalties are layered and ranked from the Constitution inward; loyalty to a superior covers lawful official conduct only; Hirschman's exit and voice clarify the options, and constructive voice is usually best; integrity, competence and loyalty are all needed, with integrity setting the limits on the other two.