| Question | Gita | Buddhist | Jain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starting point | Duty of one's role | Intention and suffering | Gravity of all harm |
| Meaning of detachment | Renounce the fruits, not the action | Freedom from craving through insight | Restraint to stop the binding of karma |
| Use of force | Right when duty requires it and it is done without hatred | Breaks the first precept; never ends hatred | Deliberate harm forbidden; defensive harm only at the minimum |
| What counts most | Right duty with right inner state | Good intention and less suffering | Least possible harm to any being |
Duty may demand hard action, but act without hatred, keep harm to the minimum, and relieve the suffering your action causes to others.
- Gita: action is unavoidable; renounce the fruits, not the act; duty done without hatred is right action.
- Buddhist: intention and the reduction of suffering decide the moral quality of an act.
- Jain: every harm is grave; householders avoid deliberate violence and minimise the unavoidable.
- In dilemmas, find where the traditions converge (proportion, no hatred) and explain where they diverge.