Three ethics of action compared
QuestionGitaBuddhistJain
Starting pointDuty of one's roleIntention and sufferingGravity of all harm
Meaning of detachmentRenounce the fruits, not the actionFreedom from craving through insightRestraint to stop the binding of karma
Use of forceRight when duty requires it and it is done without hatredBreaks the first precept; never ends hatredDeliberate harm forbidden; defensive harm only at the minimum
What counts mostRight duty with right inner stateGood intention and less sufferingLeast possible harm to any being

Duty may demand hard action, but act without hatred, keep harm to the minimum, and relieve the suffering your action causes to others.

— Rule to remember
  • Gita: action is unavoidable; renounce the fruits, not the act; duty done without hatred is right action.
  • Buddhist: intention and the reduction of suffering decide the moral quality of an act.
  • Jain: every harm is grave; householders avoid deliberate violence and minimise the unavoidable.
  • In dilemmas, find where the traditions converge (proportion, no hatred) and explain where they diverge.