Revision notes

Moral Thinkers of India: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Matching a situation to the right thinker: a five-step method and common confusions

Matching values to ideas
Value at stakeIdeas that fit best
Doing one's duty under pressure, without seeking rewardGita: nishkama karma, svadharma
Seniors setting an exampleGita: lokasangraha
Honesty with public money, checking officialsKautilya: honey and fish analogies, tests of integrity; Gandhi: wealth without work
Choosing for the poorestGandhi: talisman, sarvodaya; Kautilya: the ruler's good in the people's good
Many conflicting viewsJain anekantavada; Ashoka: restraint in speaking of other sects
Dealing with suffering or angerBuddha: karuna, right speech
Dignity of every kind of workBasavanna: kayaka; Guru Nanak: kirat karo
Sharing resourcesBasavanna: dasoha; Guru Nanak: vand chhako; Gandhi: trusteeship
Caste discrimination, equal rightsAmbedkar, Phule, Basavanna
Service with respectVivekananda: practical Vedanta; Sikh seva
Exclusion of other peoples, narrow nationalismTagore: universalism
Pairs that students mix up
Often confusedThe difference
Jain triratna vs Buddhist three jewelsJain: right faith, right knowledge, right conduct. Buddhist: the Buddha, the Dhamma, the Sangha.
Nishkama karma vs inactionNishkama karma is action without attachment to reward; the Gita rejects giving up action.
Satyagraha vs passive resistanceGandhi distinguished them: satyagraha rejects violence even in thought and aims to win over the opponent; passive resistance can be a tactic of the weak that does not rule out hatred.
Sarvodaya vs BhoodanSarvodaya is the ideal of the welfare of all; Bhoodan was Vinoba Bhave's movement for voluntary gifts of land, one way of pursuing it.
Trusteeship vs dasoha vs aparigrahaTrusteeship: the rich hold surplus wealth for society. Dasoha: sharing one's earnings. Aparigraha: limiting possessions and attachment.
Svadharma vs swadeshi vs swarajSvadharma: one's own duty. Swadeshi: reliance on one's own locality and its goods. Swaraj: self-rule, for Gandhi also rule over oneself.
Karuna vs mettaKaruna: compassion for those who suffer. Metta: loving-kindness and goodwill towards all.

Name the value at stake first, then the thinker. An idea that only shares a word with the case is the wrong idea.

— Rule to remember
  • Follow the five steps: moral core, keyword, map, test the fit, apply.
  • Always test the fit; surface similarity is the most common source of wrong answers.
  • Learn the confusable pairs, especially the two sets of three jewels and satyagraha versus passive resistance.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Duty, detachment and service in public office: the Gita, Vivekananda and Guru Nanak applied

Duty and service tools
ToolSourceQuestion it asks the officer
SvadharmaGitaWhat does this post require of me, even if I dislike it?
Nishkama karmaGitaAm I acting for the work and the people, or for praise and promotion?
SthitaprajnaGitaCan I stay calm and fair under praise and abuse alike?
Service as worship; strengthVivekanandaAm I serving people with respect, and do I have the courage to resist wrong?
Kirat karo, sevaGuru NanakIs every rupee I take honestly earned? Do I help without expecting return?
Misreadings and corrections
Wrong readingCorrect reading
Nishkama karma means not caring whether a policy worksIt means not acting for personal reward; caring about results for people is part of doing the work well
Svadharma means staying in the role of one's birthIn administrative ethics, it is the duty of one's post; the caste-based reading is widely criticised and should not be used
Seva is doing favours for people one likesSeva is selfless service given equally, without expecting any return
Service as worship means charity from aboveFor Vivekananda, the person served is honoured as divine, so service must be respectful

Do the duty of your post wherever you are posted, act for the people rather than for praise, stay calm under criticism, and serve without expecting anything back.

— Rule to remember
  • Svadharma answers what the post requires; nishkama karma answers why one acts.
  • The sthitaprajna's steadiness is a practical skill for handling criticism and pressure.
  • Vivekananda adds respect and courage to service; Guru Nanak adds honest earning and selfless seva.
  • Duty is not recklessness: take reasonable care while doing what the post demands.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Integrity and anti-corruption cases: Kautilya, Thiruvalluvar, Ashoka and Gandhi's seven social sins

Integrity problems and the ideas that address them
ProblemIdea from the thinkersModern equivalent
Officials quietly misusing fundsKautilya: like honey on the tongue and fish drinking water, misuse is tempting and hard to see, so check accountsAudit, surprise inspection, vigilance
Untested people given powerKautilya's secret tests of ministers; the Kural's advice to test character before appointmentBackground checks, probation, integrity screening
Leaders who will not hear criticismThe Kural warns that a ruler with no advisers willing to correct him is ruined even without enemiesInternal dissent channels, independent review
People unable to reach the authorityKautilya: a ruler who keeps petitioners waiting causes disaffection; Ashoka: affairs of the people to be reported to him at any timeGrievance redress, open hours, time limits
Gain without honest effortGandhi: wealth without work, commerce without morality, politics without principleConflict-of-interest and gift rules

Expect temptation and build checks around it: test before trusting, keep the authority reachable, let the public see the records, and never take gain that your work has not honestly earned.

— Rule to remember
  • Kautilya assumes temptation and answers it with audits, inspections and tests of integrity.
  • The Thirukkural adds testing character before appointment and the value of advisers who dare to correct.
  • Ashoka's accessibility is the ancestor of grievance redress.
  • Gandhi's social sins name the attitudes, such as wealth without work, from which corruption grows.
  • Pair a personal virtue with a system in every integrity answer.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Handling conflict with truth and non-violence: the Buddha, Mahavira and Gandhi in case studies

Firm but non-violent
SituationNon-violent response that is still firm
Peaceful protest blocking a roadDialogue, a fair review, an emergency corridor; no force against peaceful protesters
Crowd turning violentProtect the threatened, use the minimum force necessary, no revenge
Rumour causing panicQuick, true, non-divisive public information; action against deliberate spreaders

Listen to every side, speak truthfully and without harshness, respond to peaceful protest with dialogue, and use force only as the last and least resort, never in anger.

— Rule to remember
  • Right speech and karuna help calm conflict; mindfulness helps an officer control his or her own anger.
  • Anekantavada and syadvada encourage hearing all sides before judging.
  • Satyagraha is open, truthful, non-violent and free of hatred, and officers should respect it.
  • Ahimsa is courage without hurting, not cowardice; it allows the minimum force needed to protect people.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Equality and social justice in practice: Ambedkar, Phule, Basavanna and Vinoba Bhave

Reformers of equality
ReformerKey ideasMain method
Jyotiba Phule (1827-1890)Caste as a form of slavery (his book Gulamgiri, 1873); truth-seeking against priestly dominationEducation, especially of girls and the oppressed; the Satyashodhak Samaj (1873)
Basavanna (12th century)No caste distinction; dignity of all work (kayaka)A community of equals; the Anubhava Mantapa
B. R. Ambedkar (1891-1956)Constitutional morality; liberty, equality and fraternity together; social democracyRights, law, education, political organisation; public protests such as the Mahad satyagraha (1927) for access to a public water tank
Vinoba Bhave (1895-1982)Sarvodaya; sharing land as a moral dutyBhoodan (land-gift) movement from 1951: voluntary gifts of land for the landless

Equality needs both a change of heart and a guarantee of rights: persuade where you can, but secure in law what people are entitled to, and treat education as the door to freedom.

— Rule to remember
  • Phule: education as liberation, girls' schools, the Satyashodhak Samaj.
  • Basavanna: a community of equals and the dignity of every kind of work.
  • Ambedkar: constitutional morality, fraternity, rights secured by law and organisation.
  • Vinoba Bhave: Bhoodan, voluntary sharing of land through persuasion.
  • Good answers combine moral persuasion with legal guarantees.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery