Competing goodWhy it mattersRisk if overridden
PrivacyPersonal dignity, safety and autonomyExposure of health, financial or family details; harassment
SecurityProtection of people and the stateHarm to operations, informants or infrastructure
Candid deliberationOfficials need space to test ideas and disagree before decidingAdvice becomes cautious, vague or oral to avoid scrutiny

Transparency is the default; departures need a specific harm, the least restrictive form, and where possible only a delay rather than a denial.

  • Privacy, security and candid deliberation are legitimate competing goods.
  • The chilling-effect concern is best answered by timing, not permanent secrecy.
  • Use specific harm, public interest, timing, severance and least restriction.
  • Summary disclosure often reconciles accountability with privacy.