| Competing good | Why it matters | Risk if overridden |
|---|---|---|
| Privacy | Personal dignity, safety and autonomy | Exposure of health, financial or family details; harassment |
| Security | Protection of people and the state | Harm to operations, informants or infrastructure |
| Candid deliberation | Officials need space to test ideas and disagree before deciding | Advice becomes cautious, vague or oral to avoid scrutiny |
Transparency is the default; departures need a specific harm, the least restrictive form, and where possible only a delay rather than a denial.
- Privacy, security and candid deliberation are legitimate competing goods.
- The chilling-effect concern is best answered by timing, not permanent secrecy.
- Use specific harm, public interest, timing, severance and least restriction.
- Summary disclosure often reconciles accountability with privacy.