CollisionTypical settingWhat is lost either way
Compassion vs impartialityA desperate applicant asks to jump a long queueEither the applicant suffers, or others in the queue are treated unfairly
Loyalty vs integrityA respected senior has made a serious error and asks you to stay quietEither a relationship and team trust, or honesty and public interest
Transparency vs privacyA citizen requests records that include personal data of othersEither openness, or another person's dignity and safety
Neutrality vs justiceA lawful order produces a clearly unjust result for a vulnerable groupEither faithful implementation, or fairness to those harmed

In a true dilemma, name both values, search for a third option, weigh stakes and role, decide, and then repair what was sacrificed.

  • Advanced cases set real values against each other; there is a loss either way.
  • Look for a third option before choosing.
  • Weigh by gravity, reversibility, vulnerability and role.
  • After deciding, reduce the harm to the value placed second.