| Collision | Typical setting | What is lost either way |
|---|---|---|
| Compassion vs impartiality | A desperate applicant asks to jump a long queue | Either the applicant suffers, or others in the queue are treated unfairly |
| Loyalty vs integrity | A respected senior has made a serious error and asks you to stay quiet | Either a relationship and team trust, or honesty and public interest |
| Transparency vs privacy | A citizen requests records that include personal data of others | Either openness, or another person's dignity and safety |
| Neutrality vs justice | A lawful order produces a clearly unjust result for a vulnerable group | Either faithful implementation, or fairness to those harmed |
In a true dilemma, name both values, search for a third option, weigh stakes and role, decide, and then repair what was sacrificed.
- Advanced cases set real values against each other; there is a loss either way.
- Look for a third option before choosing.
- Weigh by gravity, reversibility, vulnerability and role.
- After deciding, reduce the harm to the value placed second.