| View | Idea |
|---|---|
| Safety-valve theory | Hume's plan gave educated Indians a lawful outlet to prevent a violent outbreak; later critics took it as a British-guided idea |
| Nationalist view | Indians of many regions wanted a national platform, shaped by earlier associations such as the Indian Association of Calcutta |
| Balanced view | A mix: Hume gave organisation, but the educated Indians who joined had their own national aims |
1885 Bombay - Hume organiser - Bonnerjee president - safety-valve is a theory, not the whole story.
Key takeaways: facts of 1885 and a balanced answer on motives.