Sources and their limits
SourceExamplesWhat it givesLimits
Buddhist textsAnguttara Nikaya, Digha Nikaya (including the Mahaparinibbana Sutta), JatakasThe list of sixteen mahajanapadas; kings, cities and gana-sanghas in the Buddha's timeWritten down long after the events; religious aims
Jaina textsBhagavati Sutra and other canonical worksAnother list of sixteen; accounts of Magadhan kings and warsTheir list differs from the Buddhist one
PuranasDynastic lists of MagadhaRoyal genealogies and reign lengthsOrder and lengths often differ from Buddhist accounts
Sri Lankan chroniclesDipavamsa, MahavamsaOrder of Magadhan kings in the Buddhist traditionCompiled much later
GrammarPanini's AshtadhyayiMentions many janapadas and terms such as sanghaExamples, not history
Greek and Latin writersHerodotus; historians of Alexander such as ArrianPersian rule in the north-west; Alexander's campaign; a fixed date in 326 BCEOutsiders' view; limited to the north-west
ArchaeologyNBPW pottery, punch-marked coins, city wallsMaterial life: cities, crafts, moneyRarely names kings

Texts tell us about kings and teachers; archaeology tells us about daily life; Greek accounts give a fixed date (326 BCE). Where Buddhist and Puranic accounts differ, textbooks follow the Buddhist order.

  • The list of sixteen is Buddhist (Anguttara Nikaya); the Jaina Bhagavati Sutra gives a different sixteen.
  • Puranic and Buddhist accounts differ on the order of Magadha's early kings.
  • Greek accounts provide the anchor date of 326 BCE.
  • Archaeology (NBPW, coins, walls) reveals economic and urban life.