How strong is each strand?
EvidenceWhat it supportsLimit
Ashokan edictsTamil kingdoms recognised by the 3rd century BCEDoes not date any poem
Roman trade, Periplus, Pliny, coinsMany poems in the early centuries CETrade lasted a long time; dating is broad
Gajabahu synchronismSenguttuvan around the 2nd century CERests on a later epic; disputed
Tradition of three SangamsPandya patronage of poetryLegendary; written centuries later

Outside evidence dates the kingdoms; trade and the Gajabahu synchronism date the poems; the three-Sangam story dates nothing. Say 'debated' and give a range.

Key takeaways: Ashoka's edicts and Kharavela prove early Tamil kingdoms; Roman trade evidence points to the early centuries CE; the Gajabahu synchronism places Senguttuvan around the 2nd century CE but is disputed; the three-Sangam tradition is legend. The honest answer is a range.