| Evidence | What it supports | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Ashokan edicts | Tamil kingdoms recognised by the 3rd century BCE | Does not date any poem |
| Roman trade, Periplus, Pliny, coins | Many poems in the early centuries CE | Trade lasted a long time; dating is broad |
| Gajabahu synchronism | Senguttuvan around the 2nd century CE | Rests on a later epic; disputed |
| Tradition of three Sangams | Pandya patronage of poetry | Legendary; written centuries later |
Outside evidence dates the kingdoms; trade and the Gajabahu synchronism date the poems; the three-Sangam story dates nothing. Say 'debated' and give a range.
Key takeaways: Ashoka's edicts and Kharavela prove early Tamil kingdoms; Roman trade evidence points to the early centuries CE; the Gajabahu synchronism places Senguttuvan around the 2nd century CE but is disputed; the three-Sangam tradition is legend. The honest answer is a range.