Testing communal claims
Communal claimWhat the evidence shows
Each religion forms a single, uniform communityEvery religion in India is divided by language, region, caste, class and sect
Members of a religion share the same worldly interestsA landless labourer and a large landowner of the same faith have different economic interests
Communities have always been in conflictLong histories of shared saints, shrines, music, crafts and markets show coexistence
One's religion decides one's nationIndian nationhood is defined by the Constitution and equal citizenship, not by religion

Communalism hides shared worldly interests and exaggerates religious difference. It is modern, political and present in any community that adopts its logic.

Key takeaways: treat communalism as a modern ideology, not an ancient hatred. Test its claims against the diversity within each religion and the shared interests across them. Criticise it in every form, distinguish it from faith and from civic nationalism, and structure long answers from definition to remedy.