| Position | Core claim | Thinkers usually linked | Applied to India |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hyperglobalists | Globalisation is creating a borderless world in which markets matter more than nation-states | Kenichi Ohmae (the 'borderless world') | Point to global IT supply chains and foreign capital shaping Indian policy |
| Sceptics | Talk of globalisation is exaggerated; much trade is regional and states remain powerful | Paul Hirst and Grahame Thompson | Point to the Indian state's continuing control over key sectors, borders and migration |
| Transformationalists | Globalisation is real and transforms societies, but its outcomes are open, uneven and shaped by states and people | Anthony Giddens, David Held | Point to India's mixed outcomes: rapid change in some sectors and regions, little in others |
Hyperglobalist: borderless world. Sceptic: exaggerated, states still rule. Transformationalist: real, deep, uneven and shaped by states and people. India fits the third best.
Key takeaways: know the three positions and who is linked to each; use time-space compression, disembedding, scapes, world-systems and network society to explain how globalisation works; and apply them to India's uneven outcomes.