The three positions, a classification associated with David Held and colleagues
PositionCore claimThinkers usually linkedApplied to India
HyperglobalistsGlobalisation is creating a borderless world in which markets matter more than nation-statesKenichi Ohmae (the 'borderless world')Point to global IT supply chains and foreign capital shaping Indian policy
ScepticsTalk of globalisation is exaggerated; much trade is regional and states remain powerfulPaul Hirst and Grahame ThompsonPoint to the Indian state's continuing control over key sectors, borders and migration
TransformationalistsGlobalisation is real and transforms societies, but its outcomes are open, uneven and shaped by states and peopleAnthony Giddens, David HeldPoint to India's mixed outcomes: rapid change in some sectors and regions, little in others

Hyperglobalist: borderless world. Sceptic: exaggerated, states still rule. Transformationalist: real, deep, uneven and shaped by states and people. India fits the third best.

Key takeaways: know the three positions and who is linked to each; use time-space compression, disembedding, scapes, world-systems and network society to explain how globalisation works; and apply them to India's uneven outcomes.