Four lenses on the women's question
LensCore ideaCriticism
ColonialWriters such as James Mill judged Indian civilisation by the 'condition of women' and used it to justify British rule as reformTreated Indian society as static and backward; ignored Indian reformers' own arguments
ReformistIndian reformers sought change through scriptural argument and colonial lawDebates on sati were often about what the texts said, with the widow herself barely heard (an argument made by the historian Lata Mani)
NationalistThe political scientist Partha Chatterjee argued that nationalists placed women in an 'inner' spiritual domain of home and culture, to be protected from colonial interferenceThis framing allowed some reform while keeping women as symbols of tradition
Feminist and anti-casteGender inequality is tied to caste, class and the control of women's marriage and sexualityAsks whose experience counts and brings in Dalit, Adivasi and working women

Ask of every claim about women's history: whose sources, which women, and whose interest does the claim serve?

Key takeaways: the 'golden age' thesis rests on narrow sources; colonial, reformist and nationalist writers each used the women's question for their own aims; caste and gender are linked through control of marriage, as Phule, Ambedkar and later feminist historians argued.