| Lens | Core idea | Criticism |
|---|---|---|
| Colonial | Writers such as James Mill judged Indian civilisation by the 'condition of women' and used it to justify British rule as reform | Treated Indian society as static and backward; ignored Indian reformers' own arguments |
| Reformist | Indian reformers sought change through scriptural argument and colonial law | Debates on sati were often about what the texts said, with the widow herself barely heard (an argument made by the historian Lata Mani) |
| Nationalist | The political scientist Partha Chatterjee argued that nationalists placed women in an 'inner' spiritual domain of home and culture, to be protected from colonial interference | This framing allowed some reform while keeping women as symbols of tradition |
| Feminist and anti-caste | Gender inequality is tied to caste, class and the control of women's marriage and sexuality | Asks whose experience counts and brings in Dalit, Adivasi and working women |
Ask of every claim about women's history: whose sources, which women, and whose interest does the claim serve?
Key takeaways: the 'golden age' thesis rests on narrow sources; colonial, reformist and nationalist writers each used the women's question for their own aims; caste and gender are linked through control of marriage, as Phule, Ambedkar and later feminist historians argued.