A four-layer analysis
| Layer | Meaning | Illustration |
| Root causes | Long-standing conditions that create grievance | Land alienation, identity insecurity, exclusion |
| Triggers | Events that turn grievance into violence | A killing, a rumour, an eviction |
| Enablers | Factors that let violence continue | Terrain, porous borders, funding, weapons, weak policing |
| Outside support | Help from foreign state or non-state actors | Training, sanctuary, money, propaganda |
Where the federal design is tested
| Strain | Union perspective | State perspective |
| Threats cross State and national borders | National agencies and laws are needed | Policing must stay local and accountable to the State |
| NIA's power to take over cases | Ensures uniform, specialised investigation | Seen by some States as limiting their police powers |
| Deployment of central forces | Article 355 makes it a duty | Deployment should follow the State's request and consultation |
| Dependence on central funds and forces | Builds capacity quickly | Can leave State police under-developed |
Root causes create grievance, triggers ignite it, enablers sustain it. Police is a State subject, but Article 355 makes protecting States a Union duty: security in India is cooperative by design.
- Analyse threats in layers: root causes, triggers, enablers and outside support.
- The Constitution splits security powers; Article 355 links them.
- Friction over NIA, central forces and funding is a recurring answer theme.
- Conclude with cooperative federalism and capable State police.