Chapter 4 Social Justice

Practice questions

Which observation does the chapter make about free markets in its conclusion to the debate?

  1. They always distribute benefits equally
  2. They often show a tendency to work in favour of the already privileged
  3. They have no effect on the poor
  4. They make the state unnecessary
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter says arguments can be made on both sides, but free markets often exhibit a tendency to work in favour of the already privileged, which is why many argue for state provision of basic facilities.

Which statement reflects the view of many free-market supporters today, as described in the chapter?

  1. The state should own all schools and hospitals
  2. Markets must be absolutely unregulated with no help for anyone
  3. The state may ensure a basic minimum, but private agencies should provide services while the state empowers people to buy them
  4. Markets always work in favour of the poor
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says many free-market supporters now accept a basic minimum and help for the old and sick, but prefer private provision of services with state policies empowering people to buy them.

Which international organisation does the chapter mention as having devised methods to calculate basic needs?

  1. The World Health Organisation
  2. The International Cricket Council
  3. The World Bank only
  4. The United Nations Security Council
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter mentions that governments and international organisations like the World Health Organisation have devised methods of calculating people's basic needs.

Assertion (A): Rawls's theory does not depend on people being self-sacrificing. Reason (R): Under the veil of ignorance, ordinary self-interest leads people to think from the position of the worst-off.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  3. A is true, but R is false
  4. A is false, but R is true
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter says the veil's merit is that people need only be their usual rational selves; under it they find it in their interest to think from the worst-off's position. R explains why no self-sacrifice is needed.

Case: Behind the veil, a made-up person must choose between Rule 1 (worst-off get 10 units, best-off 100) and Rule 2 (worst-off get 40 units, best-off 95). Following Rawls's reasoning as the chapter explains it, which would she choose and why?

  1. Rule 1, because the best-off get more
  2. Rule 2, because she might be born worst-off, and it protects that position without greatly weakening the better-off
  3. Either, since she knows she will be rich
  4. Neither, because Rawls rejects all rules
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Not knowing her position, she thinks from the worst-off's point of view (40 is far better than 10) while ensuring society as a whole benefits (95 is close to 100). So Rule 2.

Under Rawls's veil of ignorance, which piece of information is hidden from the person choosing the rules?

  1. That they are a reasoning person
  2. That they care about their own interests
  3. Which position, family, caste or wealth they will have in the future society
  4. That society needs rules
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Behind the veil we do not know what family we would be born into, our caste, wealth or privilege; we still reason and pursue our interests.

The chapter says that, faced with passionate debates on reservations, students of political theory should:

  1. avoid the topic entirely
  2. support whichever side is louder
  3. calmly examine the issues in terms of principles of justice
  4. accept any decision without thought
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says that as students of political theory we should be able to calmly examine such issues in terms of our understanding of the principles of justice.

Which measure, according to the chapter, was meant to ensure that people of 'lower' castes have access to temples, jobs and basic necessities like water?

  1. Land reforms
  2. Free markets
  3. The abolition of untouchability by the Constitution
  4. Minimum wages
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says the Constitution abolished untouchability to promote social equality and ensure that 'lower' castes have access to temples, jobs and basic necessities like water.

Why might emphasising merit as the main principle of justice disadvantage marginalised sections, according to the chapter?

  1. Because merit cannot be measured
  2. Because they have not had access to facilities such as good nourishment or education
  3. Because they do not want jobs
  4. Because merit is illegal
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter says that stressing merit alone might put marginalised sections at a disadvantage because they lacked access to facilities like good nourishment or education.

Assertion (A): The principle of recognising special needs contradicts the principle of equal treatment. Reason (R): The principle of treating equals equally could imply that people who are not equal in certain important respects may be treated differently.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  3. A is false, but R is true
  4. A is true, but R is false
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says recognising special needs does not necessarily contradict equal treatment but extends it; so A is false. R is true and is the very reason the two principles are compatible.

Policemen and miners are mentioned in the chapter in connection with which principle?

  1. Proportionate justice, since their work may involve danger and skill that their pay may not sufficiently reflect
  2. Equal treatment for equals only
  3. Recognition of special needs
  4. The free market
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter says that if rewards took effort, skill and danger into account, workers like miners, skilled craftsmen and policemen may not always get a just reward. This is proportionate justice.

Case: Two made-up workers of different castes deliver the same number of parcels, but one is paid less because of caste. Which principle of justice is violated?

  1. Proportionate justice
  2. Recognition of special needs
  3. The veil of ignorance
  4. Equal treatment for equals
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Equal treatment for equals requires that people doing the same work get the same reward and are not discriminated against on grounds of caste.

Socrates compares the just ruler to a doctor because:

  1. both must be highly paid
  2. both use medicine
  3. just as a doctor cares for patients' well-being, a just ruler must care for the well-being of the people
  4. both should punish enemies
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says justice involves the well-being of all; just as a doctor is concerned with patients' well-being, the just ruler or government must be concerned with the people's well-being.

Confucius, according to the chapter, argued that kings should maintain justice by:

  1. punishing wrongdoers and rewarding the virtuous
  2. abolishing all laws
  3. holding elections
  4. following the veil of ignorance
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter says Confucius argued that kings should maintain justice by punishing wrongdoers and rewarding the virtuous.

In the chapter's comparison, how does justice differ from love?

  1. Justice is hated by most people
  2. Love concerns relationships with a few people we know well, while justice concerns our life in society and the distribution of social goods and duties
  3. Justice can be defined precisely, love cannot
  4. Love is central to politics, justice is not
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter says both are understood intuitively and no one hates either, but love concerns a few close relationships while justice concerns the ordering of public life and distribution of goods and duties.

Assertion (A): Disagreements about distribution and justice are healthy in a democratic society. Reason (R): They force us to examine different points of view and rationally defend our own views.

  1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
  2. A is true, but R is false
  3. A is false, but R is true
  4. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The chapter says such disagreements are inevitable and even healthy because they force us to examine different views and defend our own rationally. R explains A.

Case: In a remote made-up district there are very few private schools, and those that exist are of low quality. According to the chapter, this illustrates:

  1. that rural people do not want education
  2. that private agencies may avoid markets that are not profitable or provide substandard services, so the government may need to step in
  3. that free markets always provide the best services everywhere
  4. that education is not a basic need
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter says if private agencies do not find a market profitable they may not enter or may give cheap, substandard service, which is why there may be few good private schools in remote rural areas and the state may need to step in.

Which argument for free markets is mentioned in the chapter?

  1. The market is neutral and does not care about caste, religion or gender, only talent and skill
  2. Markets always serve remote rural areas
  3. Markets make all services free
  4. Markets never need any laws
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter reports the argument that the market does not care about caste, religion or gender; it is neutral and concerned with talents and skills.

Which of the following is NOT listed in the chapter among basic minimum conditions of life?

  1. Clean drinking water
  2. A minimum wage
  3. Housing
  4. A private car
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The chapter lists nourishment, housing, clean drinking water, education and a minimum wage. A private car is not a basic need.

According to the chapter, does justice require absolute equality in the way people live?

  1. Yes, everyone must live identically
  2. Yes, but only in cities
  3. No, but a society is unjust if rich and poor live in different worlds and the deprived have no chance to improve
  4. No, justice has nothing to do with living conditions
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says justice does not require absolute equality or sameness, but a society is unjust if the gap is so great that rich and poor seem to live in different worlds and the deprived cannot improve however hard they work.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery