Chapter 8 Secularism
Practice questions
Which concern about vote bank politics is stated in the chapter?
- It is the same as secularism
- It always benefits every group equally
- It treats a diverse group as a single monolithic unit and may put short-term electoral gains above long-term development
- It strengthens social reform within groups
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chapter says vote bank politics distorts elections by treating a group as one monolithic unit despite its diversity, prioritising short-term electoral gains and emotive issues over genuine problems, and making internal reform harder.
What, according to the chapter, is the real question to ask about a politician seeking a group's votes?
- Whether the politician belongs to that group
- Whether voting should be abolished
- Whether the group is large
- What the vote is sought for: only the politician's power, or also the welfare of the group, and not at the cost of others' rights
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says seeking votes is normal in a democracy; the real question is what the vote is sought for, and a new injustice arises if one group's welfare is pursued at the cost of others' rights.
The chapter's 'deeper' response to the charge that secularism is a western import is that:
- India invented zero
- Secularism has both western and non-western origins, and India evolved its own variant in which peaceful coexistence of communities matters
- Many western things are used in India
- Secularism is purely Christian
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The chapter calls the 'trousers and internet' reply shallow; its deeper point is that secularism has western and non-western origins, and India evolved its own variant.
Assertion (A): Indian secularism is compatible with state-supported religious reform. Reason (R): A secular state must be concerned equally with intra-religious domination.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
- A is true, but R is false
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The chapter says that since a secular state must be concerned equally with intra-religious domination, Indian secularism has made room for state-supported religious reform. R explains A.
Case: A made-up state law lets every religious minority set up its own schools and allows these schools to receive state aid. In the chapter's terms, this is:
- an established religion
- negative engagement to oppose religious tyranny
- mutual exclusion
- positive engagement under principled distance
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says the Indian Constitution's grant to minorities of the right to establish educational institutions that may receive state assistance is a positive mode of engagement.
Nehru was firm and uncompromising, according to the chapter, on:
- complete opposition to communalism of all kinds
- hostility to all religions
- complete separation of religion and state
- adopting a state religion
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The chapter says Nehru was flexible on many counts, but secularism for him meant complete opposition to communalism of all kinds, and he was particularly severe on majority communalism.
Which statement about the western model's view of freedom and equality is correct, according to the chapter?
- It is community-based
- It stresses minority rights
- It is individualist: liberty of individuals and equality between individuals
- It supports state-led religious reform
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chapter says the mainstream conception interprets freedom and equality individualistically, leaving little scope for community or minority rights, and has no place for state-supported reform.
Ataturk's secularism differed from the mainstream western model mainly because it:
- kept a principled distance from religion
- funded all religious schools
- established an official religion
- involved active intervention in and suppression of religion
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says Ataturk's secularism was not about principled distance but active intervention in and suppression of religion, including ending the Khalifa and banning the Fez.
Under the mainstream western model, which of these can the state NOT do?
- Stay out of religious affairs
- Give financial support to educational institutions run by religious communities
- Treat religion as a private matter
- Allow religious communities to function within the law
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The chapter says that under mutual exclusion the state cannot aid any religious institution or give financial support to schools run by religious communities.
Assertion (A): A secular state's separation from religion may take different forms. Reason (R): The nature and extent of separation depend on the specific values it is meant to promote and how those values are spelt out.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chapter says there is no reason separation should take one form; its nature and extent depend on the values it promotes. R explains A.
To be truly secular, according to the chapter, a state must refuse to be theocratic and also:
- ban all religions
- be run by elected priests
- make one religion official
- have no formal, legal alliance with any religion
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says a truly secular state must not only refuse to be theocratic but also have no formal, legal alliance with any religion.
Which pair correctly matches the kind of state with the textbook's example?
- Theocratic state: medieval Papal States
- Established religion: medieval Papal States
- Theocratic state: sixteenth-century England
- Secular state: medieval Papal States
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The chapter gives the medieval Papal States as a theocratic state, and sixteenth-century England with its Anglican Church as a state with an established religion.
Case: Within a made-up religious community, a conservative faction expels anyone who questions its interpretation of scripture. This is an example of:
- inter-religious domination
- intra-religious domination
- principled distance
- an established religion
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Domination within a religion, such as a conservative faction suppressing dissent, is intra-religious domination, which secularism also opposes.
The view that religion is merely the 'opium of the masses' and will disappear when needs are met is described in the chapter as:
- the basis of Indian secularism
- Nehru's view
- coming from an exaggerated sense of human potential
- the official view of the Constitution
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chapter says such a view comes from an exaggerated sense of human potential, since disease, accident and loss will remain and some suffering is not man-made.
What do the three instances of violence from recent Indian history cited in the chapter have in common, according to the textbook?
- They were natural disasters
- They took place outside India
- They were economic disputes only
- Members of one community were targeted and victimised on account of their religious identity
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says that in each case members of one community were targeted and victimised because of their religious identity, denying basic freedoms; such incidents reflect inter-religious domination.
Assertion (A): The textbook says secularism undermines some forms of religious identity. Reason (R): It undermines identities that are dogmatic, violent, fanatical, exclusivist or that foster hatred of other religions.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The chapter says secularism protects religious identity in general but undermines dogmatic, violent, fanatical and exclusivist forms that foster hatred. R specifies and explains the identities referred to in A.
The chapter's response to the criticism that secularism is an 'impossible project' includes the point that:
- religious diversity is shrinking worldwide
- only small countries can be secular
- Indian secularism mirrors the future of a world becoming more diverse through migration and globalisation
- coexistence has never existed
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chapter says coexistence has been realised in Indian history and in the Ottoman Empire, and that India's experiment mirrors the future of the world as Europe, America and parts of the Middle East grow more diverse.
According to the chapter, how should reform of personal laws be brought about?
- By state coercion
- By group coercion
- By the state staying totally aloof
- By the state acting as a facilitator supporting liberal and democratic voices within every religion
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The chapter says such reform should come neither by state or group coercion, nor should the state keep total distance; it should act as a facilitator supporting liberal and democratic voices within every religion.
What lesson does the chapter draw from the auditorium example?
- Minority rights need not and should not be viewed as special privileges
- Only young people should watch films
- Stairs are unfair to everyone
- Majorities should always decide
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The chapter says a ramp or lift treats people with the same respect and dignity as others; so minority rights need not, and should not, be viewed as special privileges.
In the chapter's train compartment example, why is voting inappropriate once the non-smoker has asthma?
- Because voting is always wrong
- Because his preference now expresses a fundamental and urgent interest, to which he has a prior right
- Because smokers are a minority
- Because trains do not allow voting
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The chapter says that when it comes to fundamental interests, voting is inappropriate; a person has a prior right to the satisfaction of significant interests. The same holds for minority communities.