Chapter 9 Constitution as a Living Document

Practice questions

According to the chapter's conclusion, where does final authority lie in a democracy?

  1. With the judiciary
  2. With the people
  3. With the executive
  4. With Parliament
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter concludes that the organs of government compete, but in the last instance the final authority lies with the people.

Assertion (A): The judiciary has amended the Constitution informally through interpretation. Reason (R): Principles such as the creamy layer and the fifty per cent ceiling on reservations are not written in the Constitution but came from court rulings.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
  3. A is true, but R is false.
  4. A is false, but R is true.
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Both are true and R explains A: these principles, created by interpretation and accepted in practice, show informal amendment.

What does the 2000 review commission's approach show, according to the chapter?

  1. That the basic structure doctrine had been abandoned
  2. That States could amend the Constitution
  3. That the Constitution was to be replaced
  4. The significance of the basic structure doctrine, since the commission did not suggest anything endangering it
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Despite controversy, the commission stuck to the basic structure theory, which the chapter says shows the doctrine's significance.

Who decides what constitutes the basic structure of the Constitution?

  1. The judiciary
  2. The President
  3. Parliament
  4. The Election Commission
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The Kesavananda ruling made the judiciary the final authority on whether an amendment violates the basic structure and on what it includes.

Which change was made by the 42nd amendment, according to the chapter?

  1. It lowered the voting age to 18
  2. It created panchayats
  3. It added Fundamental Duties and extended the Lok Sabha's term from five to six years
  4. It raised judges' retirement age
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The 42nd amendment was wide-ranging: among other things it added Fundamental Duties, extended the Lok Sabha's term to six years and restricted judicial review.

Which of the following is listed in the chapter as an amendment made through political consensus?

  1. The 42nd amendment
  2. The 39th amendment
  3. The 52nd (anti-defection) amendment
  4. The 38th amendment
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The anti-defection amendment (52nd) begins the chapter's list of consensus amendments; the 38th, 39th and 42nd were controversial.

Between which years did Parliament repeatedly amend the Constitution to overcome adverse judicial interpretations, according to the chapter?

  1. 1970 and 1975
  2. 1950 and 1955
  3. 1984 and 1989
  4. 2001 and 2003
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

In 1970-75 Parliament repeatedly made amendments to overcome judicial interpretations on rights, property and the amending power.

Which amendment did the chapter cite as merely clarifying that the Council of Ministers' advice binds the President?

  1. The 15th amendment
  2. The 61st amendment
  3. The 73rd amendment
  4. An amendment to Article 74(1)
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Amending Article 74(1) to state that the President shall act on ministerial advice only confirmed existing practice, so the chapter calls it explanatory.

Assertion (A): Ratification by half the States makes the amendment procedure unworkable. Reason (R): Only half the States must consent, and a simple majority in each State legislature is sufficient.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
  3. A is true, but R is false.
  4. A is false, but R is true.
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The assertion is false: the chapter says the procedure stays workable. The reason is true and is precisely why the procedure remains practicable.

A made-up amendment moves 'forests' from the Concurrent List to the Union List. What does it need?

  1. Only a simple majority in the Lok Sabha
  2. Special majority in both Houses and ratification by half the State legislatures
  3. Special majority in the Rajya Sabha only
  4. Approval by the Supreme Court in advance
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Changing the lists alters the distribution of powers, so it needs special majority in Parliament plus ratification by half the States.

A made-up House has a total strength of 400. If 280 members vote, what is the minimum number of yes-votes needed to pass an amendment bill?

  1. 187
  2. 200
  3. 141
  4. 267
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Condition (i): at least half of total strength = 400 ÷ 2 = 200. Condition (ii): two-thirds of 280 = 186.67, so at least 187. Both must hold, so the minimum is 200, the larger of the two.

Which of the following is TRUE about amendments?

  1. The President can send back an amendment bill for reconsideration
  2. Amendments must be approved by voters in a referendum
  3. Elected representatives in Parliament alone can initiate amendments
  4. Governors must sign every amendment
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Amendments are initiated only in Parliament by elected representatives; the President cannot return them; no referendum is needed.

Which method is used to change the area of a State under Article 3?

  1. Special majority plus ratification by half the States
  2. Special majority in both Houses
  3. A referendum
  4. A simple law of Parliament
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Article 3 says Parliament may 'by law' increase the area of any State, so it can be done like an ordinary law without the Article 368 procedure.

Assertion (A): The Indian Constitution is a combination of the view that a constitution is sacred and the view that it is an instrument that may need change. Reason (R): The framers placed it above ordinary law while recognising that future generations might need to modify it.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
  3. A is true, but R is false.
  4. A is false, but R is true.
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Both are true and R explains A: the framers' balance of supremacy over ordinary law with openness to amendment combines the two views.

Which is the best reason for amending a constitution from time to time?

  1. Circumstances change and require suitable changes in the constitution
  2. Every generation should have a constitution of its own liking
  3. It must reflect the philosophy of the existing government
  4. Any document becomes useless after a fixed period
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The chapter says a constitution must respond to changing needs; it is not rewritten for each generation or government.

How did the Court resolve the tension between Parliament and the judiciary in the Kesavananda Bharati case, according to the chapter?

  1. By following only the exact letter of the Constitution
  2. By asking the President to decide
  3. By turning to the spirit of the Constitution rather than its letter
  4. By declaring Parliament supreme in all matters
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The chapter says the Court found a way out by turning to the spirit of the Constitution rather than its letter, respecting the intent behind the document.

Assertion (A): The basic structure theory is an example of the Constitution as a living document. Reason (R): The theory is not mentioned in the Constitution and emerged from judicial interpretation.

  1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
  2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
  3. A is true, but R is false.
  4. A is false, but R is true.
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Both are true and R explains A: because the theory grew out of interpretation rather than formal amendment, it shows the Constitution evolving through practice, like a living document.

Which of the following is an example of informal amendment through judicial interpretation given in the chapter?

  1. The 61st amendment lowering the voting age
  2. Article 368
  3. The 73rd amendment on panchayats
  4. The rule that reservations cannot exceed fifty per cent of seats
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The fifty per cent ceiling on reservations came from Supreme Court decisions and became an accepted principle, an informal amendment.

In which case did the Supreme Court repeat its basic structure stand after the 42nd amendment asserted parliamentary supremacy?

  1. Hussainara Khatoon case
  2. Minerva Mills case (1980)
  3. Sunil Batra case
  4. Bandhua Mukti Morcha case
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The chapter says the Court again repeated its earlier stand in the Minerva Mills case (1980).

According to the chapter, which of the following is NOT an effect of the basic structure doctrine?

  1. It sets limits on Parliament's amending power
  2. It allows Parliament to amend any part within this limit
  3. It makes the judiciary the final authority on what the basic structure is
  4. It requires a referendum for every amendment
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The doctrine limits amendments that violate the basic structure, permits all other amendments and makes the judiciary the final judge. It does not introduce referendums.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery