Environmental Ethics
Practice questions
Which statement shows sentientism rather than biocentrism?
- Every living organism has a good of its own
- Plants deserve respect because they are alive
- The biotic community has integrity
- A being matters morally because it can feel pain
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Sentientism rests on the capacity to feel; biocentrism on being alive; 'the biotic community has integrity' is Leopold's holism.
'A person who cares for a river would not dump waste into it.' This reasoning belongs to:
- Utilitarianism
- Rights theory
- Virtue ethics
- Cost-benefit analysis
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The reasoning asks what a person of good character would do, which is the pattern of virtue ethics.
Peter Singer's argument for animals is based mainly on:
- Divine command
- The capacity to suffer
- A cost-benefit analysis of timber prices
- The aesthetic value of species
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Singer, a utilitarian, argues that the interests of any being that can suffer should be counted equally.
Which is the best criticism of relying only on net benefit?
- It does not allow any calculation to be made
- It counts only the moral rights of animals
- It can never be applied to a real project
- It can hide a heavy loss borne by a small group
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A positive total can coexist with serious harm to a few people, so fairness must be checked separately.
An illustrative project gives 500 people a gain of Rs 80 each and 50 people a loss of Rs 300 each. What is the net benefit?
- Rs 40,000
- Rs 15,000
- Rs 25,000
- Rs 55,000
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Gain = 500 × 80 = 40,000. Loss = 50 × 300 = 15,000. Net = 40,000 − 15,000 = 25,000.
A planner accepts a project because total gains exceed total losses. The reasoning is most similar to:
- Utilitarianism
- Rights-based ethics
- Virtue ethics
- Deep ecology
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Comparing total gains with total losses is consequence-based reasoning, the pattern of utilitarianism.
The 'environmentalism of the poor' describes:
- Wilderness protection by wealthy groups
- Resistance by resource-dependent communities
- Concern only about the beauty of landscapes
- A market scheme for pollution permits
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The phrase refers to resistance by resource-dependent poor communities, as in Chipko, to projects that take away their livelihood base.
Which statement about social ecology is correct?
- It sees human hierarchy as a root of the problem
- It was founded by Françoise d'Eaubonne
- It says that all hierarchy is natural
- It rejects any link between society and nature
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Social ecology locates the roots of environmental problems in domination between people. The term ecofeminism, not social ecology, was coined by d'Eaubonne.
A hazardous waste site is repeatedly placed near poor settlements. The ethical concern is best called:
- Speciesism
- Reverence for life
- Environmental justice
- Land ethic
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The issue is unfair distribution of environmental harm, which is the focus of environmental justice.
The central claim of ecofeminism is that:
- Only women can protect forests
- The domination of women and of nature are linked
- Women are biologically closer to nature
- Nature has no value apart from humans
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Ecofeminism holds that the same patterns of thought justify dominating women and nature. It is not a claim about biology.
Which thinker is chiefly associated with social ecology?
- Aldo Leopold
- Arne Naess
- Peter Singer
- Murray Bookchin
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Murray Bookchin developed social ecology, arguing that ecological problems arise from social hierarchy.
The idea that present and future generations have equal claims to the Earth's resources is called:
- Intergenerational equity
- Polluter pays principle
- Precautionary principle
- Tragedy of the commons
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Fairness between generations is intergenerational equity, which is at the heart of the Brundtland definition.
Raising the discount rate, other things equal, makes harm that occurs far in the future seem:
- Larger in present value
- Unchanged
- Equal to current harm
- Smaller in present value
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A higher rate divides by a larger factor, so the present value of a distant harm falls. This is why discounting raises questions of fairness to future generations.
An illustrative harm of Rs 200 occurs 40 years from now. Using a 5 per cent discount rate, the present value is nearest to (take 1.05^40 as 7.04):
- Rs 40.0
- Rs 28.4
- Rs 5.0
- Rs 140.8
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
200 ÷ 7.04 = 28.4 (to one decimal place). Dividing by the growth factor gives the present value.
Which belief is typical of strong sustainability?
- Critical natural capital cannot be replaced by money
- Money from timber can always replace a whole forest
- Machines can replace any lost water source
- Intergenerational equity is not a real concern
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Strong sustainability holds that critical natural capital has no adequate substitute. Weak sustainability allows substitution.
The widely used definition of sustainable development comes from:
- The Stockholm Conference on the Human Environment
- The declaration of the Chipko movement
- The Brundtland Commission's report, Our Common Future
- The Rio Conference on Environment and Development
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The definition was given by the World Commission on Environment and Development (Brundtland Commission) in its 1987 report Our Common Future.
Which reason expresses intrinsic value?
- 'Rivers must be cleaned because tourists bring income.'
- 'Mangroves should be kept because they protect coasts.'
- 'We should protect this lake for our grandchildren.'
- 'A river has value in itself, apart from any human use.'
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Only this statement claims value independent of human use or interest. The others give instrumental reasons, including future-generation (bequest) value.
Keeping wild crop relatives in a gene bank in case a future pest needs a resistance gene illustrates:
- Bequest value
- Existence value
- Option value
- Direct use value
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The reason is to keep a possible future use available, which is option value.
Which statement about existence value is correct?
- It rests on human preference, so it is human-centred
- It shows nature has value apart from human interest
- It arises only when a resource is used directly
- It is exactly the same thing as option value
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Existence value is a preference of people, so it is a value for humans. It does not show that nature has value independent of people.
A person who never expects to visit the Arctic still pays to protect polar bears. The value expressed is best called:
- Direct use value
- Option value
- Indirect use value
- Existence value
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The satisfaction comes from the bear merely existing, without any use or visit, so it is existence value.