Accountability
Practice questions
Which option is most likely wrong in a 'first step' accountability MCQ?
- Suspend junior staff before any facts are gathered
- Secure safety and gather all the relevant records
- Inform the higher authority about the incident
- Order a fact-finding inquiry into the incident
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Punishing before facts risks blaming the wrong people and is usually the trap option.
'The CAG should punish officials whose spending it finds irregular.' This statement:
- Is correct, because the CAG has full powers of discipline over officials
- Applies only to state governments, because the CAG audits state accounts alone
- Confuses audit with enforcement; the CAG reports and the legislature and executive act
- Is correct only for private firms, which the CAG audits on behalf of owners
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The CAG's role is audit and reporting; enforcement lies elsewhere.
Which grievance rule best prevents fake closure?
- Treat forwarding the complaint to another office as resolution
- Close a complaint only after resolution and confirmation by the complainant
- Close after thirty days automatically whether or not it is resolved
- Close it when the officer handling the complaint is transferred out
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Confirmation-based closure ensures complaints are actually resolved.
A disputed allegation turns out false after a joint site visit. Explaining this at the gram sabha is:
- Unnecessary, because the allegation has already been shown to be false
- A cover-up meant to shield the staff from the villagers' questions
- Political interference in the independent work of the social audit team
- Part of accountability, since honest answers can clear the wrongly accused
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Answerability includes explaining when work was genuine, not only punishing wrongdoing.
At a social audit, findings implicate your staff. The response that protects both fairness and accountability is:
- Dispute the findings at once and ask the villagers to produce further proof
- Suspend all staff on the spot and announce publicly that they were guilty of fraud
- Record the findings, order independent verification within a fixed time, act and report back
- End the meeting and ask the villagers to submit a formal written complaint later
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Recording, verification, action and reporting back serve both fairness and accountability.
A hospital passes all procedural inspections but has poor surgical outcomes. This shows that:
- Outcome accountability is useless in hospitals
- Process compliance alone does not guarantee results
- Procedures should be abolished in all hospitals
- Inspections are too strict in public hospitals
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Process and outcome accountability are complementary; one does not guarantee the other.
Campbell's observation about indicators is that:
- Indicators used heavily for decisions become subject to corruption pressures and distort what they measure
- Numbers never lie, so a well-chosen indicator can always be trusted fully in decisions
- Indicators should never be used in any decision about public services, staff or budgets
- Only financial indicators can be gamed, while non-financial indicators are always safe
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Campbell noted that heavy reliance on a quantitative indicator invites distortion.
Which is an example of escalation as a fix?
- Files wait on the officer's desk until he returns from his long leave and resumes work
- A safety request not acted on in seven days moves automatically to the head of department
- All decisions on safety requests are made by a large committee that meets rarely
- Oral approvals given by the officer over the phone, without any written record
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Automatic escalation prevents urgent risks from stalling at one desk.
An official says, 'I only passed the file on.' Under Thompson's analysis, he is still responsible for:
- What he knew and could reasonably have done
- Nothing at all, since he only passed it on
- Everything that goes wrong in the department
- Only his own attendance and leave record
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Individuals answer for their knowledge and capacity to act, not just their formal role.
Thompson's problem of many hands is best countered by:
- Holding only the most junior person responsible, since he handled the file last
- A single point of accountability for outcomes, escalation rules and records of who knew what
- Holding nobody responsible, because many people contributed to the outcome
- Adding more committees and more levels of approval to every file in the process
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
These measures restore clear answerability where responsibility is diffused.
Which recommendation best addresses past wrongdoing as well as future prevention in an unfinished-works case?
- Only new rules for the future, with no action on payments already made
- Only disciplinary action against the engineers who signed the certificates
- Only a press release explaining that the matter is being looked into by the department
- Recovery and disciplinary action, plus performance security and pre-payment verification
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Strong answers deal with the past and close gaps for the future.
A panchayat receives complaints but has no register or time limit and never acts. The gaps are:
- No actor in the panchayat
- Too many forums for complaints
- No record and no consequence
- Excess enforcement action
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Without records or action, both information and enforcement are missing.
An engineer certifies a road complete; nobody checks such certificates. The gap is:
- No information for the approving forum
- Too much transparency in the process
- Judicial overreach into administration
- Excess consequence for minor errors
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The approving officer relies on a certificate with no independent check, so the forum lacks information.
The final step of the compact case structure is:
- A long quotation from a famous thinker
- A systemic fix that closes the diagnosed gap
- Blaming the lowest official in the chain
- A press release explaining the decision
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Ending with a system fix shows that the answer prevents recurrence, not just reacts.
'Vertical accountability' refers to accountability:
- Of the state to citizens, for example through elections
- Of a clerk to a section officer in the same office
- Between courts and the legislature, as in judicial review
- Of auditors to the CAG, through the audit reports
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Vertical accountability runs between citizens and the state; superior-subordinate relations are hierarchical.
After a death caused by an oxygen shortage, the best first step for the hospital head is to:
- Suspend the night-shift staff immediately and announce that they caused the shortage
- Wait for the family to complain formally before starting any kind of inquiry
- Secure backup supply, order fact-finding across all units and inform the district authority
- Deny negligence to the press and say that the shortage was only the supplier's fault
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Safety, facts and informing the higher forum come before assigning blame.
Reporting back to the gram sabha on action taken matters because it:
- Adds paperwork and delays the next round of village works
- Completes the loop of answerability and enforcement and builds trust
- Is required only in courts and not in any village-level audit
- Replaces audits and removes the need for any later verification
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Citizens see that their findings led to action, which sustains participation.
After restoring the man's pension, the officer should also:
- Do nothing more, since the pension has now been restored and the case is closed
- Ask him to stop complaining now that he has received what he was owed
- Close all other complaints of the same kind without reviewing each of them
- Check whether a system error affects others and change the grievance closure rule
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Fixing the cause for everyone and changing the rule prevents recurrence.
Records show a pond was dug but later silted; villagers say it was never dug. You should:
- Dismiss the complaint because the records show the pond was dug
- Punish the engineer anyway to show that you take the complaint seriously
- Arrange a joint site visit, show records and explain at the gram sabha
- Ignore it until the next audit brings up the matter again
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Honest explanation with evidence is also accountability; it clears those wrongly accused.
At a social audit, villagers allege fake measurements by your staff. The best first response is to:
- Defend the staff publicly and ask the villagers to withdraw their allegation
- Acknowledge and record the finding and order independent verification within a fixed time
- Leave the meeting and deal with the allegation later through office channels
- Suspend all the staff immediately and begin the inquiry only afterwards
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Acknowledgement, recording and prompt independent verification balance fairness to staff with accountability to citizens.