Case Study Approach
Practice questions
Which argument is often effective with a factory owner who wants to skip effluent treatment?
- Treatment is so cheap that it does not matter whether or not the plant is run
- Inspections never happen, so running the plant only on inspection days is safe
- Penalties and closure risks cost more than treatment, and health harm is serious
- Competitors also pollute, so he should not worry about being the only one
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Linking ethics to long-term business interest often persuades, alongside the legal and health case.
A quality manager is told to pass a failed safety batch. After refusing and recording, if pressure continues she should:
- Escalate through the company's compliance channel, and report to the regulator if unsafe products are shipped
- Pass the batch next time, once the firm's management has given her written assurance that it is safe
- Destroy the test results so that nobody can later use them against the company or the regulator
- Do nothing further, since her duty ended once she had refused and recorded the test failure
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Escalation inside, then to the regulator, protects consumers who cannot see the risk.
A mining project divides a forest community. Your role as collector is to:
- Approve the project without consultation, since the state government wants the investment
- Reject the project outright, whatever the law and the impact assessments may say
- Ensure lawful consultation, independent assessment and fair rehabilitation before any displacement
- Leave it entirely to the company to settle terms with the forest community directly
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The collector's duty is a lawful, informed, fair process that protects the weakest.
Two section heads refuse to cooperate. The first step is to:
- Suspend both without hearing them first
- Meet each separately to understand concerns
- Announce the dispute to the whole office
- Dissolve both sections and merge the staff
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Understanding each side is the first step to resolving the conflict on facts and goals.
Staff serve a colleague separately because of his caste. The immediate step is to:
- Hold a debate about the practice before deciding what to do
- Stop the practice at once and begin due inquiry and disciplinary action
- Ask the colleague to eat elsewhere to avoid causing any trouble
- Wait for a written complaint from the colleague before acting
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Untouchability is forbidden by Article 17; the practice must be stopped immediately and dealt with properly.
A junior employee reports harassment by a senior who is your friend. You should:
- Investigate informally yourself first, since you know both of them personally
- Advise her to ignore it and avoid trouble, since the senior is a respected officer
- Transfer her to another office without her consent to keep her away from him
- Help her approach the Internal Complaints Committee, protect her, and declare your friendship
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The lawful committee should inquire; you protect the complainant and stay out because of your conflict.
A retired mentor lobbies you for a private firm's bid. The best response is to:
- Decline politely, record the contact and inform your superior
- Help him, since he was your mentor and you owe him a favour
- Ignore him without recording the contact or telling anyone
- Report him to the police for attempting to bribe the officer
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Polite refusal plus a record protects impartiality and the relationship.
A friend who is a candidate messages you before an interview. The best response is to:
- Reply with encouragement and some tips for the interview
- Not discuss it, inform the chair and withdraw from assessing her
- Assess her yourself without telling anyone about the contact
- Block her number and recommend that the panel reject her
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Silence on the matter, declaration and recusal protect both the process and her fair chance.
Your brother runs a firm that has bid for a contract your section evaluates. You should:
- Evaluate the bid strictly yourself to prove that you are fair
- Ask your brother to withdraw the bid from the contract
- Reject the bid so that nobody can suspect any favour
- Declare the relationship and recuse yourself from the evaluation
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Declaration and recusal let the bid be judged fairly by others.
Emergency purchases during a flood are made without tender. Accountability is best preserved by:
- Recording every purchase and having it reviewed later
- Buying from one trusted relative of the officer in charge
- Avoiding receipts to save time during the emergency
- Paying in cash only and keeping no record of payments
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Speed is allowed by emergency rules; records and review prevent leakage.
In a shortage of ventilators, allocation should be decided by:
- The preference of the most senior officer present
- Requests from influential families and local leaders
- Published clinical criteria applied by doctors and recorded
- Ability of each patient's family to pay a high price
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Need-based clinical criteria are the fair and accountable basis.
Food for an overcrowded relief camp will run out tonight. The immediate priority is to:
- Write a detailed report on the shortage for the higher authorities
- Arrange food from nearby community sources while seeking more supplies
- Close the camp and send the people to their homes or relatives
- Wait for the next day's supply to arrive from the district store
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Basic needs of people in the camp come first.
When pressed to act doubtfully, asking for written instructions:
- Creates a record and makes the instruction-giver answerable
- Is disrespectful to seniors and should always be avoided
- Means that you must then do anything that is written
- Is needed only in private companies, not in government
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Written orders create accountability; they do not make unlawful acts lawful.
A legislator wants a school building opened before its safety certificate is issued. The legitimate part of his request is:
- Skipping the safety certificate to save time
- Opening the school without any teaching staff
- Ignoring the fire exits during the inauguration
- Wanting children to start using the school soon
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Speed is legitimate; skipping safety is not.
A minister's office presses you to approve a building plan that violates setback rules by Monday. The best response is to:
- Approve it to meet the Monday deadline, since the minister's office has asked for it
- Hold the file indefinitely so that no decision has to be taken on the matter at all
- Decide by Monday in accordance with rules, with a reasoned note, after briefing your superior
- Leak the pressure from the minister's office to the media and refuse to decide
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Lawful, timely, reasoned decisions show you are neither obstructive nor compliant with improper demands.
Stakeholder theory in business holds that firms owe duties to:
- Shareholders only, since they are the legal owners of the firm
- Customers, workers and communities as well as shareholders
- The government only, as the regulator of every business activity
- No one except the managers who run the firm day to day
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Stakeholder theory widens a firm's responsibilities beyond shareholders.
Running an effluent plant only on inspection days mainly harms:
- The inspectors, who have to visit the plant repeatedly
- The factory's competitors in the same industry
- The owner's family, who lose some of the profits
- Downstream communities' health and the environment
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Untreated effluent harms people downstream and the river.
A manager asks you to pass a batch that failed a safety test. The first step is to:
- Pass it since the margin of failure is small and the buyer is waiting
- Resign immediately and leave the batch for the next manager to handle
- Refuse to certify and record the results and your refusal in writing
- Tell customers on social media before informing anyone inside the firm
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Refusal with a written record is the necessary first step; escalation follows if pressure continues.
As collector facing a mining project that would displace a forest community, your main role is to:
- Approve it quickly because of the revenue it will bring to the state
- Ensure a lawful, informed and fair process with protection for the weakest
- Reject all mining in the district to protect the forest and its people
- Let the company decide how to deal with the affected forest community
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The collector ensures consultation, assessment and fair rehabilitation; national policy is not the collector's call.
Two section heads feuding with no law broken should be handled by:
- Suspending both of them immediately without a hearing or any inquiry
- Ignoring it completely until one of them submits a written complaint
- Meeting separately, then jointly, setting roles and timelines, and reviewing
- Asking all the staff in the section to vote on which head is right
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Conflict resolution focuses on facts, shared goals and clear roles, with administrative action only if needed.