Ethical Dilemmas

Practice questions

Which situation is a genuine ethical dilemma rather than a temptation?

  1. Deciding whether to accept a bribe offered to clear a contractor's pending bill without the usual checks
  2. Deciding whether to tell a grieving friend a painful truth now or later, when both honesty and kindness matter
  3. Deciding whether to falsify a bill so that a friend's company can be paid earlier than the rules allow
  4. Deciding whether to steal office stationery and a few small items for use by one's family at home
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Only telling a grieving friend a painful truth now or later involves two genuine values, honesty and compassion. The others are right versus wrong.

One ambulance, two emergencies: which response reflects the model answer?

  1. Send it to the farther case only, since that case is more serious
  2. Wait for instructions from the state capital before moving it anywhere
  3. Send it to the case it can clear fastest while arranging backup transport for the other
  4. Let the crew decide alone and without any information about either case
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Using every legitimate resource and sequencing the ambulance saves the most lives.

A journalist friend asks for an unpublished list with personal details. What best serves transparency and privacy together?

  1. Leak the list to the journalist at once
  2. Leak it to the journalist without the addresses
  3. Decline and push for a timely official announcement
  4. Publish the list yourself on social media
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Proper official disclosure serves transparency while protecting personal data and preventing exploitation.

What is the right order when a patient refuses to tell an at-risk spouse about an infection?

  1. Disclose the infection immediately to everyone in the patient's family and workplace
  2. Never disclose it to anyone under any circumstances, whatever danger the spouse is in
  3. Tell the employer of the patient first, so that the workplace can protect others
  4. Counsel and seek consent first; disclose to the person at risk only if necessary, informing the patient
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Consent first, then limited disclosure when serious, identifiable risk remains.

A psychiatrist learns that a patient intends serious violence against a named neighbour. Which principle most supports taking protective steps?

  1. The duty to protect identifiable third parties, associated with the Tarasoff decision
  2. Absolute confidentiality between a patient and a doctor in every case
  3. Ethical egoism, which asks what is best for the doctor
  4. Political neutrality in the conduct of a public servant
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Serious danger to an identifiable person can override confidentiality.

A court orders removal of footpath encroachments, including a poor widow's stall. Which response best combines justice and mercy?

  1. Comply, with notice, help to register in a vending zone and links to welfare support
  2. Exempt her from the order of the court because she is poor, and remove all the other vendors
  3. Remove her stall first as an example for the other vendors, without any notice or help
  4. Delay the whole drive indefinitely until all of the vendors agree to leave the footpath
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Binding orders are carried out; lawful discretion softens their effect on the vulnerable.

Your superior gives an oral order to bypass tendering without a real emergency. What is the right response?

  1. Comply silently with the order, since he is the superior officer
  2. Ask for the order in writing with reasons and follow the rules
  3. Refuse rudely on the telephone and end the call at once
  4. Leak the call to the press so that the matter is public
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

A written order with reasons adds accountability and allows correct procedure.

When Kidder's principles disagree, what does this course recommend?

  1. Choose the principle that you personally like the most and follow it
  2. Keep the rule and let consequences and care shape how it is carried out
  3. Do nothing, because the principles cancel one another out here
  4. Always follow the ends-based principle, whatever the rule says
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Disagreement usually concerns how to act; the rule is honoured while its impact is managed humanely.

A family missed by a flood survey is clearly affected. Which course do all three of Kidder's principles support?

  1. Pay outside the list on the word of a leader, with no further check
  2. Refuse the claim because the list is final and cannot be altered
  3. Pay only if the family agrees to pay a bribe to the clerk
  4. Verify quickly, add the family to the list and pay relief
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Verification and inclusion help the family while keeping the system fair.

An exam observer cannot admit a late candidate under the rules. How can compassion still be shown?

  1. Help her report the reason to the examining body and record the incident
  2. Admit her quietly, without informing anyone of the rule
  3. Give her extra time secretly, without telling the other candidates
  4. Ignore her, because the rules have no place for her
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Compassion within the rules uses legitimate remedies.

A case involves a polluting factory employing many workers. Which stakeholder is most often forgotten?

  1. The factory owner, who is present in every discussion
  2. People downstream and future residents who are affected but absent
  3. The district magistrate, who is present in the discussion
  4. The pollution control board, who is present throughout
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Voiceless or absent stakeholders are the easiest to miss and often carry the gravest interests.

Which line belongs to the 'prevention' part of the structure?

  1. The injured are the most vulnerable people in this case
  2. A district ambulance dispatch plan with backup tie-ups
  3. The conflict here is really between speed and fairness
  4. Send the ambulance to the nearer of the two cases
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Prevention proposes a systemic change to avoid or ease the same problem in future.

Why is 'resign' usually a weak answer to a dilemma case?

  1. It abandons responsibility and the people the officer could protect
  2. Resignation is illegal for a public servant in a case of this kind
  3. It is always the best option, since it avoids any later blame
  4. Examiners prefer longer answers, and a resignation is a short answer
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Resignation may be a last resort, but it usually leaves the problem and the vulnerable unaddressed.

During a cyclone, which approach to buying tarpaulins without tender is best?

  1. Buy from a trader chosen secretly, without any record of the price paid
  2. Wait for a full tender process, even while the families are exposed to rain
  3. Refuse all purchases until the state government gives written permission in full
  4. Use emergency procurement provisions, record reasons, check prices and disclose afterwards
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Emergency rules allow speed; records and disclosure preserve accountability.

A viral video shows a junior being rude to a citizen. Which response best balances accountability and fairness?

  1. Suspend him immediately without giving him a hearing, to show the public quick action
  2. Ignore the video, because a clip on social media is not proof of anything
  3. Apologise to the citizen, resolve her work, and take proportionate action after a quick inquiry
  4. Delete the accounts of the office on social media, so that nobody can see it
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

It respects the citizen and due process together.

In the ambulance case, why is arranging other vehicles for the accident victims part of the model answer?

  1. To avoid using the ambulance at all for the injured at the scene
  2. Because every legitimate resource should be used to save as many lives as possible
  3. Because accident victims are less important than the original patient waiting
  4. Because the rules forbid the use of ambulances for road accident victims
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Using backup transport while the ambulance clears the nearer case maximises the chance of saving all lives.

Which approach best combines honesty and compassion when giving very bad news?

  1. A deliberate lie told with kindness, to spare the feelings of the listener
  2. Truthful communication with careful choice of timing, manner and messenger
  3. Blunt disclosure of the facts, without regard for the state of the listener
  4. Avoiding the person entirely until someone else has given the news to him
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Many ethicists favour truthful but compassionate communication rather than either deception or bluntness.

A journalist friend asks an officer for an unannounced list of households to be relocated, with personal details. What is right?

  1. Share it with the journalist, because transparency is always good in every case
  2. Share it without the names, but with all the other details about the households
  3. Decline, and press for a timely official announcement with information on rights and rehabilitation
  4. Sell it to the highest bidder among the newspapers that are interested in the list
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Personal data must be protected, and transparency is served properly by official announcement, not by leaks.

Before disclosing a patient's infection to an at-risk spouse, what should the doctor first do?

  1. Counsel the patient to disclose and offer help
  2. Post the news on the hospital notice board, so that the spouse is certain to see it
  3. Tell the patient's employer, who can then talk to the family of the patient
  4. Do nothing, because medical secrecy applies in every case without exception
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Seeking consent and supporting voluntary disclosure comes first; disclosure without consent is a last resort, limited to what is necessary.

A student tells a counsellor he plans to harm a named classmate on a stated day. What should the counsellor do?

  1. Keep it secret from everyone, to maintain the trust of the student, and offer him counselling in the school
  2. Share it with the other students in the class, so that they can protect themselves and warn their friend
  3. Wait to see whether it happens, and act only if the classmate is actually harmed on the day that was stated
  4. Inform the school head and parents as policy requires, protect the classmate, and keep supporting the student
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

A specific, serious threat to an identifiable person overrides confidentiality; support for the student continues.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery