Ethical Dilemmas
Practice questions
Which situation is a genuine ethical dilemma rather than a temptation?
- Deciding whether to accept a bribe offered to clear a contractor's pending bill without the usual checks
- Deciding whether to tell a grieving friend a painful truth now or later, when both honesty and kindness matter
- Deciding whether to falsify a bill so that a friend's company can be paid earlier than the rules allow
- Deciding whether to steal office stationery and a few small items for use by one's family at home
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Only telling a grieving friend a painful truth now or later involves two genuine values, honesty and compassion. The others are right versus wrong.
One ambulance, two emergencies: which response reflects the model answer?
- Send it to the farther case only, since that case is more serious
- Wait for instructions from the state capital before moving it anywhere
- Send it to the case it can clear fastest while arranging backup transport for the other
- Let the crew decide alone and without any information about either case
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Using every legitimate resource and sequencing the ambulance saves the most lives.
A journalist friend asks for an unpublished list with personal details. What best serves transparency and privacy together?
- Leak the list to the journalist at once
- Leak it to the journalist without the addresses
- Decline and push for a timely official announcement
- Publish the list yourself on social media
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Proper official disclosure serves transparency while protecting personal data and preventing exploitation.
What is the right order when a patient refuses to tell an at-risk spouse about an infection?
- Disclose the infection immediately to everyone in the patient's family and workplace
- Never disclose it to anyone under any circumstances, whatever danger the spouse is in
- Tell the employer of the patient first, so that the workplace can protect others
- Counsel and seek consent first; disclose to the person at risk only if necessary, informing the patient
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Consent first, then limited disclosure when serious, identifiable risk remains.
A psychiatrist learns that a patient intends serious violence against a named neighbour. Which principle most supports taking protective steps?
- The duty to protect identifiable third parties, associated with the Tarasoff decision
- Absolute confidentiality between a patient and a doctor in every case
- Ethical egoism, which asks what is best for the doctor
- Political neutrality in the conduct of a public servant
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Serious danger to an identifiable person can override confidentiality.
A court orders removal of footpath encroachments, including a poor widow's stall. Which response best combines justice and mercy?
- Comply, with notice, help to register in a vending zone and links to welfare support
- Exempt her from the order of the court because she is poor, and remove all the other vendors
- Remove her stall first as an example for the other vendors, without any notice or help
- Delay the whole drive indefinitely until all of the vendors agree to leave the footpath
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Binding orders are carried out; lawful discretion softens their effect on the vulnerable.
Your superior gives an oral order to bypass tendering without a real emergency. What is the right response?
- Comply silently with the order, since he is the superior officer
- Ask for the order in writing with reasons and follow the rules
- Refuse rudely on the telephone and end the call at once
- Leak the call to the press so that the matter is public
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
A written order with reasons adds accountability and allows correct procedure.
When Kidder's principles disagree, what does this course recommend?
- Choose the principle that you personally like the most and follow it
- Keep the rule and let consequences and care shape how it is carried out
- Do nothing, because the principles cancel one another out here
- Always follow the ends-based principle, whatever the rule says
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Disagreement usually concerns how to act; the rule is honoured while its impact is managed humanely.
A family missed by a flood survey is clearly affected. Which course do all three of Kidder's principles support?
- Pay outside the list on the word of a leader, with no further check
- Refuse the claim because the list is final and cannot be altered
- Pay only if the family agrees to pay a bribe to the clerk
- Verify quickly, add the family to the list and pay relief
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Verification and inclusion help the family while keeping the system fair.
An exam observer cannot admit a late candidate under the rules. How can compassion still be shown?
- Help her report the reason to the examining body and record the incident
- Admit her quietly, without informing anyone of the rule
- Give her extra time secretly, without telling the other candidates
- Ignore her, because the rules have no place for her
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Compassion within the rules uses legitimate remedies.
A case involves a polluting factory employing many workers. Which stakeholder is most often forgotten?
- The factory owner, who is present in every discussion
- People downstream and future residents who are affected but absent
- The district magistrate, who is present in the discussion
- The pollution control board, who is present throughout
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Voiceless or absent stakeholders are the easiest to miss and often carry the gravest interests.
Which line belongs to the 'prevention' part of the structure?
- The injured are the most vulnerable people in this case
- A district ambulance dispatch plan with backup tie-ups
- The conflict here is really between speed and fairness
- Send the ambulance to the nearer of the two cases
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Prevention proposes a systemic change to avoid or ease the same problem in future.
Why is 'resign' usually a weak answer to a dilemma case?
- It abandons responsibility and the people the officer could protect
- Resignation is illegal for a public servant in a case of this kind
- It is always the best option, since it avoids any later blame
- Examiners prefer longer answers, and a resignation is a short answer
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Resignation may be a last resort, but it usually leaves the problem and the vulnerable unaddressed.
During a cyclone, which approach to buying tarpaulins without tender is best?
- Buy from a trader chosen secretly, without any record of the price paid
- Wait for a full tender process, even while the families are exposed to rain
- Refuse all purchases until the state government gives written permission in full
- Use emergency procurement provisions, record reasons, check prices and disclose afterwards
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Emergency rules allow speed; records and disclosure preserve accountability.
A viral video shows a junior being rude to a citizen. Which response best balances accountability and fairness?
- Suspend him immediately without giving him a hearing, to show the public quick action
- Ignore the video, because a clip on social media is not proof of anything
- Apologise to the citizen, resolve her work, and take proportionate action after a quick inquiry
- Delete the accounts of the office on social media, so that nobody can see it
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
It respects the citizen and due process together.
In the ambulance case, why is arranging other vehicles for the accident victims part of the model answer?
- To avoid using the ambulance at all for the injured at the scene
- Because every legitimate resource should be used to save as many lives as possible
- Because accident victims are less important than the original patient waiting
- Because the rules forbid the use of ambulances for road accident victims
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Using backup transport while the ambulance clears the nearer case maximises the chance of saving all lives.
Which approach best combines honesty and compassion when giving very bad news?
- A deliberate lie told with kindness, to spare the feelings of the listener
- Truthful communication with careful choice of timing, manner and messenger
- Blunt disclosure of the facts, without regard for the state of the listener
- Avoiding the person entirely until someone else has given the news to him
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Many ethicists favour truthful but compassionate communication rather than either deception or bluntness.
A journalist friend asks an officer for an unannounced list of households to be relocated, with personal details. What is right?
- Share it with the journalist, because transparency is always good in every case
- Share it without the names, but with all the other details about the households
- Decline, and press for a timely official announcement with information on rights and rehabilitation
- Sell it to the highest bidder among the newspapers that are interested in the list
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Personal data must be protected, and transparency is served properly by official announcement, not by leaks.
Before disclosing a patient's infection to an at-risk spouse, what should the doctor first do?
- Counsel the patient to disclose and offer help
- Post the news on the hospital notice board, so that the spouse is certain to see it
- Tell the patient's employer, who can then talk to the family of the patient
- Do nothing, because medical secrecy applies in every case without exception
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Seeking consent and supporting voluntary disclosure comes first; disclosure without consent is a last resort, limited to what is necessary.
A student tells a counsellor he plans to harm a named classmate on a stated day. What should the counsellor do?
- Keep it secret from everyone, to maintain the trust of the student, and offer him counselling in the school
- Share it with the other students in the class, so that they can protect themselves and warn their friend
- Wait to see whether it happens, and act only if the classmate is actually harmed on the day that was stated
- Inform the school head and parents as policy requires, protect the classmate, and keep supporting the student
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A specific, serious threat to an identifiable person overrides confidentiality; support for the student continues.