Foundations of Ethics
Practice questions
An officer handling a recruitment learns her nephew is a candidate. She evaluates fairly but tells no one. What is still wrong?
- Nothing; the decision was fair, so there is no conflict that needed to be declared
- She should have rejected the nephew's application to avoid any suspicion
- She should have favoured the nephew, since family is owed loyalty before duty
- She failed to disclose the conflict and step aside, which damages trust even if the result was fair
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A fair outcome does not cure an undisclosed conflict of interest. Disclosure and recusal protect both fairness and the public's trust in the process.
Which statement about loyalty in public service is correct?
- Loyalty to a superior covers lawful instructions but never concealing wrongdoing
- Loyalty to a superior overrides the law whenever the two conflict
- Loyalty has no place in public service, where only rules matter
- Loyalty is owed to friends who helped one's career, above the public
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Loyalty is a real value but is bounded by the law and the public interest. It does not extend to hiding wrongdoing.
A businessman with no pending work sends a district officer a costly gift soon after the officer takes charge. The best response is to:
- Accept, since no business is pending yet and refusing would offend a well-wisher
- Accept and share it with staff so that no one person benefits from it
- Decline politely and record it, since the value is high and the giver may seek favour later
- Report the businessman to the police immediately and ask for his arrest
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Value and timing raise a red flag even without pending business; future dealings are likely. Declining and recording is proportionate. Police action at once is excessive for an offer of a gift.
Which pairing of step and purpose in the eight-step method is correct?
- Options: to restate the facts of the case in the officer's words
- Interests and rights: to note what each stakeholder needs and is entitled to
- Evaluation: to list the stakeholders affected by the decision
- Implementation: to name the values that are in conflict in the case
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The interests and rights step records each stakeholder's needs and entitlements. The other pairings are mismatched.
A factory pollutes a stream but employs many local workers. Which option best reflects a balanced stakeholder decision?
- Permit the pollution to continue unchanged so that the jobs of the local workers and the economy of the area are protected
- Close it permanently at once without a hearing, and leave the workers to find other work on their own as best they can
- Order an immediate halt to untreated discharge and a time-bound treatment plan with monitoring, with closure as a lawful last resort
- Leave it to the owner's conscience and trust him to decide for himself whether to treat the discharge or not
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The balanced option protects health now, gives livelihoods a lawful path to survive and upholds the law. The others sacrifice one stakeholder group or abandon duty.
In a flood rescue, an influential person demands priority for his less-threatened village. Using stakeholder analysis, the strongest response is to:
- Follow need-based priority, explain it to him, and give his village a definite place in the plan
- Obey him to keep the peace, since an influential person must not be offended
- Ignore him and refuse all communication with his village for the rest of the operation
- Divide the boats equally between villages regardless of the danger each faces
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Need-based triage respects the equal right to life; explaining and scheduling his village keeps cooperation. Obeying breaks impartiality; ignoring is needlessly hostile; equal division ignores urgency.
Which factor usually does NOT reduce responsibility?
- A genuine threat to life if the act is not done
- Ignorance that could not reasonably be avoided by any careful person
- No time to consult anyone in a real and sudden emergency
- Knowing a practice is wrong but following it because 'everyone does it'
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Common practice is not an excuse when one knows the act is wrong. The other three can genuinely reduce responsibility.
A junior obeys an unlawful oral order from a superior, knowing it is unlawful, under fear of a poor report. Which verdict is most defensible?
- Fully excused, since he obeyed orders from a superior and had no choice
- Fully to blame, and the superior bears no responsibility for the order
- Responsibility is shared: reduced for the junior by the pressure, but not removed
- No one is responsible, since no law was clear on the matter
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The superior bears much of the responsibility for the order. The junior knew it was unlawful and faced only career pressure, so his responsibility is reduced but not removed.
Which reason reflects virtue ethics?
- 'This will give the greatest benefit to the largest number of people.'
- 'I have a duty to keep my word, whatever the consequences may be.'
- 'It benefits me and my family in the long run.'
- 'A fair-minded officer would listen to both sides before deciding.'
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Virtue ethics appeals to what a person of good character, here fair-minded, would do. The others appeal to outcomes, duty and self-interest.
An officer refuses a bribe only because he fears being caught. In Kant's terms the refusal:
- Has full moral worth because the result is the same as acting from duty
- Is an example of the golden mean between honesty and corruption
- Is in accordance with duty but lacks moral worth because it is not done from duty
- Is wrong, since the motive was selfish and the act therefore has no value
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
As with Kant's shopkeeper, the right act is done from self-interest, not from duty, so it lacks moral worth, though it is not wrong in itself.
A candidate's answer spends half its length on the officer's career risks. The main error is:
- Confusing prudential considerations with the ethical issue
- Ignoring the law that governs the officer's powers
- Overusing virtue ethics throughout the whole answer
- Listing too many stakeholders, including remote ones
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Career risk is a prudential concern. It may be acknowledged, but the ethical question concerns what is right for all affected.
In a case, an officer must decide whether to certify a building as safe when the inspection is incomplete and the builder is pressing. The core ethical issue is best stated as:
- The officer's chance of promotion if he keeps the builder happy
- Whether the building code permits certification on partial inspection
- The builder's financial loss if the certificate is delayed
- Honesty and public safety versus pressure to oblige the builder
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The ethical issue is the clash of values: truthful certification and safety against pressure. Promotion is prudential, the code is legal input, and the builder's loss is one stakeholder interest.
A friend asks the tender officer for confidential estimates. Why is 'ignore the message and say nothing' a weak answer?
- It is illegal to ignore a friend's message in any circumstances
- It is passive and leaves the conflict of interest undisclosed
- It is too dramatic a response for a simple request
- It treats the friend too harshly, since he only asked for help
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Ignoring is passive. The officer still has an undisclosed private tie to a bidder. The better response is to refuse, disclose the relationship and withdraw from the evaluation.
A token box of sweets from a neighbour who has no official dealings with an officer is generally:
- Acceptable, since there is no link to official business and the value is a token
- A serious corruption offence under the Prevention of Corruption Act, in every case
- Acceptable only if the officer pays the neighbour back for it in cash
- Required to be returned in every case, even when a neighbour offers it socially
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
With no pending business, token value and a social occasion, the gift tests pass. Treating every token as corruption is a trap.
A public servant's loyalty is owed first to:
- Their immediate superior personally, whatever he orders
- Their own family and relatives, who depend on them
- The lawful purposes of the organisation and the public
- Their political associates who helped them in service
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Loyalty to a superior covers lawful instructions. It is subordinate to loyalty to the law and the public, which require refusing unlawful orders.
An answer recommends the right option but gives no steps, timeline or documentation. Its main weakness is:
- It uses too many theories and not enough facts from the case
- It ignores stakeholders who are affected by the decision
- It lacks implementation, which makes the decision look unrealistic
- It is too balanced and avoids taking a clear position
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The final step, implementing and following up, turns a decision into action. Without it, a good choice remains a statement of intent.
Why should a candidate list at least three options in a case answer?
- Examiners count the number of options, not the quality of reasoning
- Extreme options are always correct and a middle course is never lawful
- Three is a rule of law that every case answer must follow
- Two extremes often hide a balanced, lawful course that serves more stakeholders
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Cases usually present two extremes. A third, balanced option is often lawful and protects more interests; generating it shows judgement.
In stakeholder analysis, which group is most often wrongly left out?
- The officer making the decision and his immediate subordinates
- The person who complained first and the officials who handled his complaint
- Voiceless stakeholders such as future generations, children and the environment
- The head of the department who will approve the final order
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Voiceless stakeholders cannot press their interests, so they are easily forgotten. A good analysis lists them explicitly.
A clerk alters a beneficiary list to include his neighbour, saying the neighbour is poor. The neighbour is in fact poor but did not apply in time. The best verdict is:
- Fully justified, since the motive was good and the neighbour truly needed the help
- The act is wrong, since it bypassed fair procedure, though the motive slightly reduces blame
- No issue, since the outcome helped a poor person who deserved the benefit
- Only a legal issue about the list, not an ethical one
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Altering a list bypasses fairness to other applicants and the rules. A good motive does not justify the act; at most it reduces blame. The proper course was to guide the neighbour to apply in the next round.
Why should the act be described in neutral words at the first step?
- To make the answer longer and give it more weight in marks
- To show sympathy for the officer before judging what he did
- To make the act appear legal before any analysis has been done
- To avoid building a verdict into the description before analysing it
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Words such as 'helped' or 'stole' already contain a judgement. Neutral description lets the later steps decide the verdict on evidence.