Moral Thinkers of the World
Practice questions
A health officer considers telling villagers that a vaccine is 'compulsory by law' when it is not, to raise turnout. Which assessment fits this course?
- Acceptable, as a modern version of Plato's noble lie, because the health benefit is large
- Wrong: it deceives citizens and treats them merely as means; honest persuasion, as in the cave allegory, is required
- Acceptable, if the hedonic calculus shows that the total pleasure or benefit is greater
- Irrelevant to ethics, since health is a technical matter for experts, not for philosophy
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Modern public ethics rejects the noble lie. Deception treats citizens merely as means and undermines trust; the officer should persuade with honest evidence.
Why is the philosopher-ruler idea usually reinterpreted rather than adopted directly in a democracy?
- Because Plato favoured elections as the way of choosing rulers, and the idea therefore needs no change
- Because expertise is irrelevant to governance in any modern state, which should rely on public opinion
- Because expert authority must remain accountable to citizens and elected representatives
- Because it was invented by Hobbes to defend the absolute sovereign and has no place in a democracy
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The idea supports knowledge-based administration, but in a democracy expert power must answer to the people; Plato did not favour democratic rule.
A 'Public Grievance Cell' exists only on paper. Which Confucian remedy fits best?
- Rename the cell so as to lower the public's expectations
- Abolish all procedures and rely on the officers' own goodwill
- Rely only on penalties for staff who do not do the work
- Make the cell's conduct match its name, with the head setting the example
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Rectification of names requires conduct to live up to the title; Confucius stresses leadership by example over punishment alone.
Hobbes and Locke would both support emergency measures to protect life during riots. On what would Locke insist more strongly?
- That the sovereign's power be absolute and beyond challenge
- That emergency powers be limited, temporary and accountable to the people
- That the general will be discovered by a vote of all citizens
- That pleasures be measured and added up for all persons
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Locke grounds government in consent for the protection of rights, so power must be limited and answerable. Hobbes was readier to accept a strong sovereign.
Which rule would Mill's harm principle most clearly NOT justify?
- Fining factories for releasing toxic smoke into nearby villages
- Banning drunk driving on roads used by other people
- Requiring adults to follow a government-approved daily diet
- Punishing assault on another person with a prison term
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A compulsory diet restricts self-regarding conduct for the person's own good, which Mill rejects as a ground for coercion. The others prevent harm to others.
Which statement about Aristotle's mean is FALSE?
- The mean is always exactly halfway between two extremes
- Some acts, such as theft or murder, have no mean at all
- Practical wisdom is needed to find the mean in each case
- Virtue becomes settled through repeated habit and practice
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The mean is relative to us and to the situation, not an arithmetic midpoint. The other three statements are correct.
Which case shows Kant and an act utilitarian most likely disagreeing?
- Repaying a loan on time to a lender who has asked for the money back and is owed it
- Falsely telling a mob that a suspect has escaped, to prevent a lynching
- Publishing accurate exam results on the date announced, as the rules of the board require
- Allocating funds by clear rules that are known to all the departments and applicants
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
An act utilitarian may approve the lie to prevent violence; Kant forbids lying whatever the outcome. In the other cases both agree.
A hospital board allocates scarce beds by published medical criteria applied to everyone. Why does this satisfy Kant as well as a utilitarian?
- Because it maximises the board's pleasure, which is the aim of Kantian duty
- Because it is a mean between two vices, which is all that Kant requires
- Because the rule can be accepted by every rational person and treats each patient as an end
- Because the majority voted for it, and Kant accepts the will of the majority
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A transparent rule applied equally can be universalised and respects persons as ends; it also tends to save the most lives, satisfying the utilitarian.
Officer Neha could win a bigger grant by reporting false enrolment figures. A careful utilitarian and a Kantian would both reject this. Which pair of reasons is correct?
- Utilitarian: long-term harms to trust and fund allocation outweigh the gain; Kantian: the maxim cannot be universalised and deceives the funders
- Utilitarian: lying is always forbidden whatever the result; Kantian: the grant is too small to matter much to anyone
- Utilitarian: Neha's character is weak and unfit for office; Kantian: the result of the act is bad for the funders
- Both: the law forbids it, so ethics need not be considered at all, and neither theory has anything to add here
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The utilitarian counts all consequences, including long-term trust; Kant tests universalisability and forbids using the funders merely as means through deception.
Why is Plato's 'noble lie' generally rejected in modern public administration?
- Because it produces too much pleasure for the citizens who are told
- Because Aristotle invented it and his theory has since been rejected
- Because it requires a veil of ignorance behind which no one can act
- Because deceiving citizens violates accountability and treats them merely as means
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Deception by officials undermines democratic accountability and, in Kantian terms, treats citizens merely as means.
Which action best reflects Confucius' approach to improving discipline in an office?
- Issuing a strict circular on punctuality, with penalties for latecomers, and then leaving the station
- Installing cameras at the entrance and in the corridors without any explanation to the staff
- The head arriving on time, serving visitors personally and using penalties only as support
- Transferring all the staff at once to other offices and branches and bringing in a new team
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Confucius favoured governing by virtue and example, with laws and punishments in a supporting role.
In Mill's unsafe-bridge example, why may a person be held back when there is no time to warn him?
- Because the state owns the bridge and may stop anyone who uses it, whatever he intends
- Because he does not actually want to fall into the river, so stopping him does not violate his liberty
- Because the majority wishes it and the person's own liberty must give way to their view
- Because his life belongs to the community and so may be saved without regard to his wishes
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Mill argues that liberty means doing what one wants; the person does not want to fall, so holding him back briefly respects rather than violates his liberty. Where there is only risk, he should be warned.
Under Mill's harm principle, which rule is most clearly justified?
- Fining adults who do not read newspapers every day
- Banning adults from eating spicy food at public places
- Requiring adults to sleep for eight hours each night
- Prohibiting the dumping of chemical waste into a village pond
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Dumping waste harms others' health and water, so coercion is justified. The other rules restrict self-regarding conduct.
A department starts monthly sessions where senior officers model and discuss fair handling of complaints. This best reflects Aristotle's idea that:
- Pleasures differ in quality, not only in amount
- Virtue is a mean of quantities, as in arithmetic
- Moral virtue is developed through habit and example
- The state of nature is violent and needs a sovereign
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Aristotle held that moral virtues are acquired by practice and habituation, which mentoring and modelling support.
In the completion-certificate case, why is going straight to the media described as an excess?
- Because the media is always wrong in what it reports
- Because it shows rashness by skipping measured internal steps
- Because truthfulness has no mean and so cannot be excessive
- Because Kant forbids any contact with the media by officers
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Courage lies between cowardice and rashness; escalating publicly before using proper channels leans to rashness.
An officer refuses ever to take decisions without written orders from above, even on routine matters. In the self-assurance spectrum this is:
- Confidence, the healthy mean
- Arrogance, an excess
- Practical wisdom, the mean
- Timidity, a deficiency
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Avoiding all decisions out of fear is the deficiency of confidence; arrogance would be the excess.
A contractor has endangered children by using substandard material. The virtuous response in Aristotle's terms is:
- Half the contractual penalty, as a compromise between the two extremes of severity and leniency
- Ignoring it altogether to keep the project on time and within cost, since the children were not harmed
- Full enforcement of the penalty, since the mean is relative to the seriousness of the case
- Publicly humiliating the contractor, well beyond what the contract allows, so that others are deterred
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The mean is relative to the situation; serious danger calls for firm enforcement. Half measures are not automatically the mean, and humiliation beyond the rules is an excess.
An officer argues that a rule permitting officials to lie in emergencies would, over time, destroy trust in all official statements, so lying should be rejected. This argument is:
- Kantian, based on duty alone and not on any results
- Rule utilitarian, judging the rule by its long-run results
- Aristotelian, based on habit and the formation of character
- Confucian, based on ritual and respect for one's elders
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Judging a general rule by the consequences of everyone following it is rule utilitarian reasoning, even though it reaches the same verdict as Kant.
In the four-step template, the Kantian step asks:
- Which option maximises the total pleasure of the people affected
- Whether the option's principle can be universalised and respects people as ends
- Which option is the mean between two extremes of conduct and feeling
- Which option is preferred by the majority of the people concerned
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Kant's two key tests are universalisability and the humanity formula (never treat people merely as means).
Which situation most clearly shows Kantian and act-utilitarian verdicts diverging?
- Paying contractors on time as the contract and the rules require
- Reporting accurate data to the higher authorities in the department
- Following open tender rules in the awarding of public contracts
- Telling a crowd a comforting lie to prevent a riot
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A narrow act-utilitarian count might approve the lie to prevent violence, while Kant forbids lying regardless of outcome. In the other options both lenses agree.