Probity in Governance
Practice questions
Which pair of elements best completes a case answer on misuse of welfare funds?
- A quotation and an apology, followed by a request for further time
- Immediate correction of the list and a system fix such as public verification
- A media statement and the resignation of the officer in charge
- Silence about the case and the transfer of the staff involved
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Strong case answers fix the immediate problem and prevent recurrence.
A PIO forwards every difficult request to the head of department to decide. This is weak because:
- The PIO is responsible for deciding and giving reasons within time
- Heads have no information about the requests in the department
- The Act bans consultation with any other officer in the office
- It is too transparent for officers who work in the department
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The PIO may seek assistance but carries the duty to decide within time and give reasons.
Which option is the classic trap in probity MCQs?
- Recording reasons for decisions in the file
- Declaring conflicts of interest before acting
- Hearing the third party before disclosure
- Refusing information because it is embarrassing
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Embarrassment is not an exemption; it is a deliberately tempting wrong option.
Disclosing evidence of fraud first on social media is weak mainly because it:
- Is always illegal under the law, whatever the evidence or the reason for posting it
- Can damage the investigation and weaken legal protection; competent authorities should be approached
- Is too slow to reach the public, so it is better to write a letter to the newspapers first
- Protects the wrongdoer's privacy and gives him time to plan a defence of the matter
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Formal disclosure to competent authorities protects both the inquiry and the whistleblower.
Entrenched petty corruption in an office is best tackled by:
- Raids alone, repeated at random times every few months
- Tolerating it as a minor and unavoidable problem of the office
- Transferring all the staff to other offices at the same time
- System fixes plus a clear warning and firm action afterwards
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Systemic reform reduces opportunities; credible enforcement changes expectations.
A spouse joins a firm that often deals with your department. This is:
- An actual conflict that must be ended
- Not a conflict as no decision is yet affected
- Embezzlement of funds by the spouse
- A potential conflict to declare and manage
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
No decision is yet influenced, but one could be; it should be declared and managed.
A hospital head wants to promise a fifteen-minute wait with too few doctors. The best advice is:
- Publish honest waiting times, set achievable targets, add triage and request staff with data
- Make the promise anyway to impress visitors and hope that the staff will meet it somehow
- Remove the charter altogether so that the hospital cannot be held to any promise
- Stop seeing new patients until more doctors can be posted to the hospital
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Realistic standards and capacity improvements build trust; impossible promises destroy it.
In the Sevottam model, 'service delivery capability' refers to:
- The printing quality of the charter and where it is displayed
- The number of complaints received by the department in a year
- The people, infrastructure and processes needed to keep service promises
- Political support for the department from the elected leaders
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Capability is the means to deliver the standards promised in the charter.
Agents outside an office sell appointment slots. Which fix addresses the cause most directly?
- Posters asking citizens not to use agents or pay them any money
- A transparent online first-come slot system and published daily capacity
- Longer lunch breaks for the staff at the counters in the office
- Removing the grievance number from the notice board of the office
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Agents exploit scarce, discretionary access; transparent booking removes their leverage.
An applicant asks whether a road safety audit found a bridge unsafe. The department wants to avoid alarm. The PIO should:
- Disclose; public safety is a strong public interest and alarm is not an exemption
- Refuse to avoid panic among the people who use the bridge every day
- Delay beyond the time limit until the department decides how to respond
- Disclose only after repairs have been completed and the bridge declared safe
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Preventing embarrassment or alarm is not a ground for refusal, and safety strengthens the case for disclosure.
A request seeks the price at which a contract was awarded, after the award. The best response is to:
- Refuse as a commercial secret in all cases, since contract prices belong to the contractor
- Disclose the price and evaluation after giving the third party notice; withhold only genuine trade secrets
- Ask the applicant's motive and release the price only if the reason is convincing to the PIO
- Forward the request to the contractor to reply directly to the applicant after the award
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Award prices concern public money; third-party notice is given and only genuine trade secrets may be withheld.
A case-based probity answer should end with:
- A long quotation from a thinker or a committee report
- A list of all the laws in India that relate to the case
- An immediate step and a system fix, then a one-line conclusion
- An apology to the people affected by the lapse in the office
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Combining immediate correction with prevention shows practical judgement.
The weakest claim about controlling corruption is:
- Reducing discretion helps in practice
- More punishment alone will solve it
- Transparency helps to expose misuse
- Culture matters for lasting change
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Punishment alone is insufficient; discretion, transparency, enforcement and culture must work together.
In a housing case with ineligible beneficiaries added under pressure, the strongest course is to:
- Ignore it to keep peace with the local leaders who recommended the names, and move on
- Remove the names quietly, without any notice, reasons or report about the pressure
- Add more names to balance it, so that no eligible family feels left out of the list
- Verify publicly, remove ineligible names with reasons, report the pressure and publish the final list
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
This corrects the list, addresses the cause and builds transparency for the future.
The statement 'it was legal, so there is no probity issue' is:
- A trap, because probity also requires a fair and open process
- Always correct, because legality is the only test of probity
- Correct only for contracts and purchases, not for other decisions
- Correct only for RTI requests and not for other decisions
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Probity looks beyond legality to fairness, openness and absence of private interest.
Which is a valid reason for a PIO to refuse information?
- The information embarrasses the department or its officers
- The applicant will not say why he wants the information
- A specific exemption in the Act applies, with reasons given
- The head of department prefers secrecy on the subject
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Only a stated exemption, with reasons, justifies refusal; embarrassment and motive are not grounds.
Which law provides a framework for public interest disclosures about public servants in India?
- The Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014
- The Right to Information Act, 2005
- The Companies Act, 2013 (as amended)
- The Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act, 2013 only
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014 provides the framework for such disclosures and protection against victimisation.
Your superior is approving payments for work never done. Internal reporting goes to him. You should:
- Post the evidence on social media first so that the public can put pressure on him
- Make a formal disclosure with evidence to the competent vigilance or designated authority
- Confront him publicly at a meeting and demand that he stop the payments at once
- Do nothing because he is senior and it is not your place to question him
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
When internal channels are compromised, a formal disclosure to a competent authority is the correct route.
As a new head, you find routine petty bribes at counters. The best overall strategy is to:
- Raid the office once, suspend everyone found at the counters and consider the matter closed
- Ignore it to avoid trouble with the union and to keep the staff on good terms with you
- Fix the system (tokens, online appointments, fee charts, CCTV), warn staff and enforce firmly afterwards
- Join in quietly to keep harmony with the staff and to avoid being isolated
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
System reform plus credible enforcement addresses causes and changes behaviour more lastingly than a single raid.
A supplier offers a purchase officer an all-expenses-paid resort conference. The best response is to:
- Accept since the supplier has called it a technical conference for officers
- Accept but not tell anyone, since the trip is for official benefit
- Decline; the department may send someone at its own cost if it is genuinely useful
- Ask for cash instead of the resort stay, to be used for official purchases
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Hospitality from a supplier creates at least an apparent conflict; the department, not the supplier, should fund genuine training.