Critical Reasoning
Practice questions
'Because the monsoon was late, the dam levels are low. Therefore the city must start water rationing.' Which is an unstated assumption?
- The monsoon was late in arriving over the catchment of the dam
- The dam levels are low at present, at the start of the season
- The dam levels will not recover soon enough to avoid rationing
- Rationing is popular with residents and has the support of the city
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The late monsoon and the low dam levels are stated premises. The gap between low dam levels and the need to ration is that the levels will not recover in time - unstated, but needed.
Original: 'No fish are mammals. A shark is a fish. So a shark is not a mammal.' Which argument has the same form?
- No cars are bicycles. This is a car. So it is not a bicycle.
- No cars are bicycles. This is not a car. So it is a bicycle.
- Some cars are bicycles. This is a car. So it is a bicycle.
- All cars are bicycles. This is a car. So it is a bicycle.
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The form is: no A are B; C is A; so C is not B. Only 'No cars are bicycles. This is a car. So it is not a bicycle.' follows it.
Original: 'If it rains, the match stops. It did not stop. So it did not rain.' Which has the same form?
- If the bell rings, school ends. School ended. So the bell rang.
- If the bell rings, school ends. School did not end. So the bell did not ring.
- If the bell rings, school ends. The bell rang. So school ended.
- If the bell rings, school ends. The bell did not ring. So school did not end.
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The form is: if A, B; not B; so not A. Only 'If the bell rings, school ends. School did not end. So the bell did not ring.' follows it.
Original: 'All pilots are trained. Sunil is trained. So Sunil is a pilot.' Which argument has the same form?
- No cats are birds. This animal is a bird. So it is not a cat.
- All cats are mammals. This animal is a cat. So it is a mammal.
- All cats are mammals. This animal is a mammal. So it is a cat.
- Some cats are mammals. This animal is a cat. So it is a mammal.
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The form is: all A are B; C is B; so C is A. Only 'All cats are mammals. This animal is a mammal. So it is a cat.' has this form.
Argument: 'Since the town installed streetlights, crime at night will fall.' Which statement most strengthens it?
- The new lights use LED bulbs, which are brighter and last a long time
- In nearby towns, night-time crime fell on streets after lights were installed
- The lights cost a lot to install and to maintain every year
- Many residents sleep early and stay at home at night
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Evidence that the same step worked in a similar case makes the conclusion more likely. The other statements do not affect crime.
'No one has shown that this game harms children, so it is harmless.' What is the flaw?
- Attacking the person making it
- False either-or choice offered
- Hasty generalisation from one case
- Treating lack of proof as proof
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The absence of evidence of harm is treated as evidence of safety. Not having proved harm is not the same as proving there is none.
Argument: 'Our café has more customers than any other café on the street, so it serves the best coffee.' What is assumed?
- The number of customers reflects the quality of the coffee
- The café is cheap compared with the other cafés
- The street is busy at all hours of the day
- The café has many tables and chairs for customers
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The argument jumps from customer numbers to coffee quality. That needs the assumption that more customers means better coffee; if customers come for low prices or location instead, the conclusion fails.
'Cities with more hospitals have more sick people, so hospitals make people sick.' What is the flaw?
- Attacking the person making it
- Correlation taken as cause
- False either-or choice
- Circular reasoning in the claim
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Hospitals and sick people go together because hospitals are built where many people (and so many patients) live. Two things happening together does not show one causes the other.
Argument: 'The town has opened a free health clinic, so residents' health will improve.' What is assumed?
- The new clinic building is well built
- The town is small and has few residents
- Residents will actually use the clinic
- The doctors at the clinic are friendly
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A clinic can improve health only if people go to it. Negation: if residents do not use it, the conclusion fails. So the argument assumes they will use it.
How does the negation test check an assumption?
- Turn the assumption into its opposite and see whether the argument falls apart
- Remove the conclusion and reread the passage to see what remains
- Add a new premise and see if it agrees with the conclusion
- Count how many premises the argument has and compare them to the conclusions
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
If the opposite of a statement destroys the argument, the argument needed that statement, so it is a necessary assumption.
Argument: 'The school's exam results improved this year, so the new principal must be effective.' What is assumed?
- The principal is well qualified and has long experience in teaching
- Results are announced every year in the same month
- The school is large and has many classrooms
- The improvement was not caused by something else, such as an easier exam
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The argument links better results to the principal. It assumes nothing else caused the improvement. Negation test: if an easier exam caused it, the argument falls apart.
Argument: 'The new irrigation canal will increase crop yields in the district.' Which statement most weakens it?
- The canal is very long and passes through several villages
- The canal was opened in winter, during the dry season, with a ceremony
- Most farmland in the district is too far from the canal to receive its water
- Farmers in the district grow rice and wheat on most of their land
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
If most farms cannot get the canal water, the canal cannot raise most yields, so the conclusion becomes less likely. The other statements do not affect whether yields will rise.
Argument: 'This coaching centre is the best because 90% of its students pass.' Which statement most weakens it?
- The centre has air-conditioned rooms, a large library and a canteen for students
- The centre is near the railway station and is easy to reach from the city
- The centre admits only students who already scored very highly in an entrance test
- The centre collects its fees monthly instead of once a year
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
If the centre admits only top students, the high pass rate may come from the students rather than the teaching. This breaks the link between the pass rate and the claim that the centre is the best.
Argument: 'Planting trees along roads will lower summer temperatures in the city.' Which statement most strengthens it?
- Tree planting is cheap compared with other ways of cooling a city, and it is easy to organise
- In a nearby city, streets lined with trees were measured to be cooler than similar streets without trees
- Some residents dislike falling leaves in the autumn and complain about the cleaning
- Many trees are planted during the monsoon months, when they grow quickly
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Evidence that the plan worked in a similar case makes the conclusion more likely. Cost, leaves and planting season say nothing about temperature.
Argument: 'Sales at the shop rose after it started playing music, so the music caused the rise.' Which statement most weakens it?
- The shop also began free home delivery at the same time
- The music played in the shop is mostly classical
- The shop has two floors for its different products
- The owner enjoys music and chose the songs himself
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Free home delivery starting at the same time offers another explanation for the rise in sales, so the music may not be the cause. The other statements do not affect the link.
What is the 'why' (because) test for finding the conclusion?
- Put 'because' after the sentence you think is the conclusion and see whether the other sentences answer it
- Choose the longest sentence in the passage, because the main claim needs the most words to explain
- Choose the first sentence of the passage, because the main claim always comes at the start
- Count the signal words and pick the sentence with the most of them near it
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The conclusion is the claim the other sentences support. If you write 'because' after it and the other sentences give the reason, you have found it. Position and length do not decide it.
'The town's literacy rate rose after the library opened, so the library raised the literacy rate.' Which most strengthens it?
- The library has a large reading room with seating for two hundred readers at a time
- School enrolment did not change in that period, and the rise was largest among regular library members
- Literacy also rose by a similar amount in the nearby towns that had no new libraries
- The library opened in the month of May, with a ceremony attended by the district officials
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Unchanged enrolment rules out the main other explanation, and a larger rise among library users links the library to the result. A rise in towns without libraries would weaken it.
'The new road reduced accidents, because accidents in the area fell by 20% the following year.' Which most weakens it?
- The road is long and passes through several villages and two small towns of the district
- The road has street lights along its entire length, installed at the time it was built
- Many people use the road every day, including buses, trucks and two-wheelers
- Accidents fell by about 20% across the whole state that year, including areas with no new road
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A similar fall everywhere, even without a new road, suggests something else caused it, so the road may not be the reason.
'Rohan scored well in his mock tests, so he will do well in the real exam.' What is a key assumption?
- Performance in the mock tests reflects performance in the real exam
- Rohan studies every day for several hours after school and on holidays
- The real exam is easier than the mock tests were in every subject
- The mock tests were taken online under the supervision of the teachers
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The premise is about mock tests and the conclusion is about the real exam. The bridge is that mock performance predicts real performance.
'Crop yields fell this season even though farmers used more fertiliser.' Which fact best resolves this?
- Fertiliser prices rose this season, and the government raised the price of seeds too
- Farmers bought fertiliser from a new shop in the market town, at a slightly lower price
- A severe drought this season damaged the crops more than the extra fertiliser helped
- Yields were high two seasons ago, because the monsoon was very good in that year
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A drought that outweighed the fertiliser's benefit explains how yields fell despite more fertiliser. The other facts do not explain the fall.