Syllogism
Practice questions
Which of these is a complementary pair (exactly one must be true)?
- All A are B and No A is B
- Some A are B and Some A are not B
- Some A are B and No A is B
- All A are B and Some B are A
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Either some A are B or none is, so exactly one of the pair is true. All and No can both be false, Some and Some-not can both be true, and 'All A are B' with 'Some B are A' are not opposites at all.
Statements: All kittens are cats. Some cats are brown. All brown things are furry. Which pair of conclusions makes an either-or?
- All kittens are furry; no cat is furry
- Some cats are furry; no cat is furry
- Some kittens are furry; no kitten is furry
- Some brown things are kittens; all kittens are brown
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The chain gives Some cats are furry, but nothing definite about kittens, so neither 'Some kittens are furry' nor 'No kitten is furry' follows alone. They are Some and No on the same terms: an either-or pair. In the other pairs, a member follows or the terms differ.
Statements: All A are B. Some B are C. No C is D. Which conclusion is only a possibility, not certain?
- Some B are not D
- Some B are C
- Some C are B
- Some A are D
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Some B are not D is certain, and the other two options are the statement and its reversal. A can sit inside B, and the part of B outside C may overlap D, so Some A are D is possible only.
Statements: All pens are tools. No tool is a toy. Some toys are red. Which conclusion follows?
- All red things are toys
- Some red things are not pens
- No red thing is a pen
- Some pens are red
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
All pens are tools and No tool is a toy give No pen is a toy. The red toys are not pens, so Some red things are not pens follows. 'No red thing is a pen' is too strong.
Statements: Some men are teachers. All teachers are wise. All wise people are old. Which conclusion follows?
- Some men are old
- All men are old
- All teachers are men
- No wise person is a man
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Some men are teachers and All teachers are wise give Some men are wise; with the third statement, Some men are old. The other conclusions are not forced.
Statements: All A are B. All B are C. Some C are D. Which conclusion follows?
- Some D are C
- Some A are D
- All D are C
- Some B are not D
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Reverse the third statement. The chain A, B, C gives All A are C, but All B are C with Some C are D gives no link from A or B to D, so only the reversal follows.
Statement: Some fruits are not sweet. A student writes 'Some sweet things are not fruits'. What should you do?
- Accept it, because it is a reversal
- Accept it, because it is an either-or
- Reject it, because it contradicts the statement
- Reject it, because Some-not cannot be reversed
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Some A are not B cannot be reversed. The new sentence is not forced, though it does not contradict the statement.
Statement: All bags are boxes. Which of these is only a possibility, not a certainty?
- Some bags are boxes
- Some boxes are bags
- Some boxes are not bags
- All bags are boxes
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Boxes outside the bags are possible but not forced, since the circles may coincide. The other three are certain.
Statement: Some roads are wet. I. All roads are wet. II. Some roads are not wet. What is the correct answer?
- Only conclusion I follows
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Neither follows alone, since the statement settles neither. They are the All and Some-not pair on the same terms, so one of them must be true.
Statements: Some cats are black. Some black things are rare. Which conclusion follows?
- None of the three below
- Some cats are rare
- Some rare things are cats
- Some cats are not rare
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Two Some statements never give a conclusion. Cats that are black and black things that are rare may be different members.
Statement: All lamps are bright. A student concludes 'All bright things are lamps'. What is wrong?
- An All statement cannot be reversed
- Lamps are not bright
- The conclusion is too weak
- The statement is a possibility
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
All A are B reverses only to Some B are A. 'All bright things are lamps' would need the circles to be identical.
Statements: No cup is a plate. No plate is a bowl. Which answer is correct for I. Some cups are bowls and II. No cup is a bowl?
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion I follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Two No statements give no conclusion, so neither follows alone. The conclusions are Some and No on the same terms, so exactly one is true: either I or II.
Statements: No tiger is a cow. Some cows are white. Which conclusion follows?
- Some tigers are not white things
- No tiger is a white thing
- Some tigers are white things
- Some white things are not tigers
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
No A is B with Some B are C gives Some C are not A: Some white things are not tigers. The conclusion about tigers being not white does not follow.
Statements: Some pens are red. No red thing is cheap. Which conclusion follows?
- No pen is cheap
- All pens are cheap
- Some pens are not cheap
- Some cheap things are pens
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C. The pens that are not red are not covered by the second statement, so No pen is cheap is too strong.
Statements: All roses are flowers. No flower is a stone. Which conclusion follows?
- Some roses are stones
- No rose is a stone
- Some stones are roses
- All stones are flowers
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C. The other options contradict this or say something not stated.
Statements: No bus is a boat. All boats float. Which conclusion follows?
- Some floating things are not buses
- Some buses are not floating things
- No floating thing is a bus
- All buses are floating things
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
No A is B with All B are C gives Some C are not A: Some floating things are not buses. 'No floating thing is a bus' is too strong.
Statements: All kings are men. No man is immortal. I. No king is immortal. II. Some men are not kings. Which answer is correct?
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Only I follows
- Neither follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
All A are B with No B is C gives No A is C, so I follows. II does not follow: it is possible that every man is a king, so no man need lie outside the kings.
Statements: All dogs are animals. Some animals are brown. I. Some dogs are brown. II. No dog is brown. Which answer is correct?
- Only conclusion I follows
- Either I or II follows
- Only conclusion II follows
- Neither conclusion follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
All A are B with Some B are C gives nothing, so neither follows alone. I and II are Some and No on the same terms, so one of them must be true: either I or II.
Statements: Some cars are blue. Some blue things are old. I. Some cars are old. II. Some old things are cars. Which answer is correct?
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Two Some statements never give a conclusion. Neither conclusion follows, and since both are Some conclusions they are not an opposite pair.
Statements: Some shirts are cotton. No cotton is silk. I. Some shirts are not silk. II. No shirt is silk. Which answer is correct?
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Both follow
- Neither follows
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Some A are B with No B is C gives Some A are not C, so I follows. II is stronger than anything the statements give, so it does not follow.