Chapter 30 Performance of Contract
Practice questions
The debtor gives no direction and nothing in the circumstances shows which debt a payment is for. The creditor:
- must return the payment
- must apply it in proportion
- may apply it to any lawful debt due to him from the debtor
- must ask a court
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Section 60 gives the creditor discretion to apply the payment to any lawful debt actually due from the debtor.
A debtor owes ₹12,000 (due 1 May) and ₹18,000 (due 1 May) to one creditor and pays ₹10,000 without appropriation; the creditor also makes none. How is it applied?
- All ₹10,000 to the ₹18,000 debt
- ₹4,000 and ₹6,000
- ₹5,000 to each
- All ₹10,000 to the ₹12,000 debt
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Equal standing, so proportionately (Section 61). Total ₹30,000. 10,000 × 12,000 ÷ 30,000 = ₹4,000; 10,000 × 18,000 ÷ 30,000 = ₹6,000. Check: 4,000 + 6,000 = 10,000.
In a cash-and-carry sale, the buyer pays and receives goods at the same moment. The promises are:
- mutual and independent
- mutual and dependent
- mutual and concurrent
- joint promises
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Promises to be performed simultaneously are mutual and concurrent.
Goods to be delivered on a fixed day, without application; no place named. The seller must:
- ask the buyer to appoint a reasonable place and deliver there
- deliver at the seller's own home
- wait for the buyer to call
- deliver to the nearest court
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Section 49 puts the duty on the promisor to apply to the promisee to appoint a reasonable place and to perform there.
Which section allows a creditor to accept a car in part payment of a money debt?
- Section 49
- Section 61
- Section 41
- Section 50
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Section 50: performance may be made in any manner or at any time which the promisee prescribes or sanctions.
A contract fixes no time for delivery of a machine. Delivery is due:
- within 24 hours
- only when the buyer sues
- within a reasonable time, depending on the circumstances
- at the end of the financial year
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Section 46: where no time is specified, performance must be within a reasonable time, which depends on circumstances, trade usage and intention.
Sections 42 and 45 deal respectively with:
- tender and reciprocal promises
- joint rights and joint liabilities
- joint liabilities and joint rights
- time and place of performance
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Section 42 covers devolution of joint liabilities; Section 45 covers devolution of joint rights.
A promise is made to Arif and Bina jointly. Arif dies. Who may now claim performance?
- Bina together with Arif's legal representative
- Bina alone
- Arif's representative alone
- The promisor decides
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Section 45: after one joint promisee dies, the right rests with his representative jointly with the survivor.
Three partners jointly borrow ₹60,000. All three die before repayment. Who must repay?
- The lender bears the loss
- Only the last partner's heirs
- Nobody, the debt ends
- The legal representatives of all three, jointly
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Section 42: after the death of the last survivor, the representatives of all must fulfil the joint promise jointly.
A singer agrees to perform at a festival and dies a week before it. The contract:
- must be performed by her legal representatives
- comes to an end
- must be performed by her agent
- becomes illegal
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Contracts depending on personal skill come to an end on the promisor's death; the legal representatives are not bound.
P promises Q to pay ₹8,000 to R. P does not pay. As a general rule, who can sue P?
- R
- Q
- Both Q and R separately
- Neither
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Q is the promisee. R is a stranger to the contract and, outside special cases like trusts, cannot enforce it.
A painter agrees to paint a portrait and sends his assistant instead. The client may refuse because:
- the contract depends on the promisor's personal skill
- agents can never perform contracts
- the contract was executory
- the price was not paid in advance
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Under Section 40, where personal skill is the basis of the contract, the promisor must perform personally.
Which is NOT an essential of a valid tender in the textbook's list?
- It must be made to the proper person
- It must be made at the proper time and place
- It must be for the whole obligation where full performance is required
- It must be approved by a court
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Court approval is not needed. The essentials concern the condition, quantity, person, time, place, form, and inspection of goods.
A tender of ₹40,000 is offered on the due date, on condition that the creditor withdraws a complaint. The tender is:
- valid, because the amount is correct
- valid, because it was on time
- invalid, because it is conditional
- invalid, because cash cannot be tendered
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A valid tender must be unconditional. Attaching a new condition makes it invalid, even if the amount and time are right.
Section 37 requires the parties to a contract to:
- register every contract
- perform or offer to perform their promises, unless excused by law
- always perform in person
- perform only if the other party performs first
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Section 37 places a duty to perform or offer to perform, unless performance is dispensed with or excused under the Act or any other law.
Two debts of ₹30,000 and ₹20,000, both due on the same day, and an unappropriated payment of ₹10,000. How much goes to the ₹30,000 debt?
- ₹10,000
- ₹5,000
- ₹4,000
- ₹6,000
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Equal standing means proportionate application. Total = ₹50,000. Share = 10,000 × 30,000 ÷ 50,000 = ₹6,000 (and ₹4,000 to the other).
A debtor owes ₹10,000 due in January and ₹15,000 due in March to one creditor. He pays ₹10,000 and neither party appropriates it. Under Section 61 it settles:
- the March debt in part
- both debts proportionately
- the January debt
- neither debt
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
When neither party appropriates, payment is applied in order of time. The January debt is older, so the ₹10,000 clears it.
The question of appropriation of payments arises when:
- a debtor owes only one debt
- a debtor owes several debts to the same creditor and pays less than the total
- the creditor refuses all payment
- the debt is paid in full
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Appropriation decides which debt a payment settles. It matters only when there are several debts to one creditor and the payment is insufficient for all.
A builder agrees to construct a house and the owner agrees to supply cement first. The promises are:
- mutual and dependent
- mutual and independent
- mutual and concurrent
- not reciprocal
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The builder's performance depends on the owner supplying cement first, so the promises are mutual and dependent.
Promises which form consideration or part of consideration for each other are:
- joint promises
- contingent promises
- gratuitous promises
- reciprocal promises
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Section 2(f) defines reciprocal promises as promises forming the consideration, or part of it, for each other.