Chapter 31 Discharge and Breach of a Contract
Practice questions
Damages are awarded mainly to:
- make good the loss suffered by the injured party
- reward the party in breach
- punish every party in breach
- cancel taxes on the contract
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The main purpose is to make good the injured party's loss (the textbook's doctrine of restitution). Punishment is only for exemplary damages in special cases.
A seller fails to deliver goods priced at ₹45,000; the buyer pays ₹48,000 for the same goods elsewhere on the delivery date. The buyer also loses a ₹10,000 profit on a resale the seller never knew about. The buyer can recover:
- ₹13,000 as ordinary and special damages
- ₹3,000 as ordinary damages
- ₹48,000
- ₹10,000 only
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Ordinary damages = ₹48,000 − ₹45,000 = ₹3,000. The resale loss is special damage, recoverable only if the seller knew of it when contracting; he did not.
A contractor builds 3 of 5 agreed classrooms at ₹2,00,000 each; the school then refuses to let him continue. On quantum meruit he can claim:
- ₹10,00,000
- ₹4,00,000
- nothing, as the work is incomplete
- ₹6,00,000
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The school's refusal discharges the contract by breach. Payment for work done = 3 × ₹2,00,000 = ₹6,00,000 (damages for further loss may also be claimed).
Specific performance is NOT granted when the contract is made by a company:
- with a bank
- after registration
- beyond its Memorandum of Association (ultra vires)
- in writing
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The textbook lists contracts made by a company ultra vires its Memorandum of Association among those where specific performance is refused.
A shopkeeper sold his business and promised not to open a similar shop nearby for an agreed period, then does so. The remedy that stops him is:
- quantum meruit
- an injunction
- nominal damages
- remission
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
He is breaking a negative term (a promise not to do something). An injunction restrains him from doing it.
A court will refuse specific performance where:
- damages are an adequate remedy
- the item is unique
- money compensation cannot be obtained
- there is no standard for measuring damage
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
If money damages are adequate, specific performance is not granted. The other three are reasons for granting it.
Which of these is a remedy for breach rather than a mode of discharge by agreement?
- Remission
- Waiver
- Novation
- Specific performance
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Specific performance is a court remedy for breach. Remission, waiver and novation are ways the parties agree to end or change a contract.
An insolvent, once adjudged, is discharged from:
- all future contracts
- liabilities incurred after adjudication
- liabilities incurred prior to his adjudication
- nothing at all
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The textbook states that an insolvent is discharged from all liabilities incurred prior to his adjudication.
A contract with a famous artist to paint a mural is discharged when the artist dies before starting. This is discharge by:
- operation of law (death)
- remission
- waiver
- accord and satisfaction
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
A contract depending on personal skill is discharged by operation of law on the promisor's death.
A seller who agreed to deliver a particular car sells it to someone else before the delivery date. The seller:
- is excused by supervening impossibility
- is discharged by merger
- can claim quantum meruit
- is liable for breach, as the impossibility was his own act
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A party cannot rely on impossibility that he himself caused. Selling the car elsewhere is a breach, and the buyer may claim a remedy.
A promisee does not file a suit within the period fixed by the Limitation Act, 1963. The result is that:
- the promisor must pay double
- the promisee loses his remedy at law
- the contract becomes illegal
- the contract is novated
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Lapse of time deprives the promisee of his remedy in court, so the contract is discharged in practice.
An agreement to sell a horse which, unknown to both parties, had already died is:
- voidable at the seller's option
- valid but unenforceable
- void, because of impossibility existing at the time of agreement
- discharged by lapse of time
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The subject matter did not exist when the agreement was made: initial impossibility not known to the parties. Such an agreement is void.
The parties agree to accept a different performance instead of what was promised, and it is actually given. This is:
- accord and satisfaction
- rescission
- remission
- injunction
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Accord is the agreement to accept something different; satisfaction is giving it. Together they discharge the contract.
Three parties agree that a new debtor will replace the old one, and the old debtor is released. This is:
- alteration
- waiver
- merger
- novation
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Substitution of a new contract, here with a new party, for the old one is novation.
A contract in which both parties have fully performed their obligations is discharged by:
- operation of law
- performance
- impossibility
- lapse of time
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
When both parties have done what they promised, the contract is discharged by actual performance.
A token amount awarded where a right is breached but no real loss is suffered is called:
- special damages
- quantum meruit
- nominal damages
- exemplary damages
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Nominal damages simply recognise that the injured party's legal right was broken, without real loss.
A buyer's contract price is ₹30,000; on the delivery date, the same goods cost ₹33,500 in the market and the seller fails to deliver. Ordinary damages are:
- ₹33,500
- ₹3,500
- ₹30,000
- ₹63,500
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Ordinary damages = market price − contract price = ₹33,500 − ₹30,000 = ₹3,500.
Damages awarded to punish the party in breach, as for breach of a promise to marry, are:
- nominal damages
- ordinary damages
- special damages
- vindictive or exemplary damages
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Vindictive or exemplary damages go beyond compensation and are meant to punish; they are awarded only in special cases such as these.
Which section of the Indian Contract Act deals with compensation for loss caused by breach?
- Section 73
- Section 56
- Section 10
- Section 38
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Section 73 deals with compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract.
Quantum meruit means:
- let the buyer beware
- something for something
- as much as earned
- a thing speaks for itself
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The textbook explains the phrase as 'as much as earned': payment for what has actually been done.