Chapter 9 Government Organisation
Practice questions
Match correctly, as the textbook classifies them: Indian Railways, Life Insurance Corporation of India, Coal India Ltd.
- Public corporation, Government company, departmental undertaking
- Government company, departmental undertaking, public corporation
- Departmental undertaking, public corporation, Government company
- Departmental undertaking, Government company, public corporation
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Indian Railways is run by the Ministry of Railways (departmental); LIC is created by statute (public corporation); Coal India Ltd is in the textbook's list of Government companies.
A State wants a new enterprise that can be set up quickly, hire professional managers and change its line of work without going to the legislature. Which form fits best?
- Government company
- Departmental undertaking
- Public corporation
- None of the three
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
A Government company is formed by executive decision, has its own personnel policy, and changes by altering its Memorandum. A public corporation needs an Act; a departmental undertaking has civil servants and red-tapism.
'Board of Directors packed with yes-men' refers to a weakness of:
- Multinational corporations
- Sole traders
- Departmental undertakings only
- Government companies
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
In a Government company the Government, as major shareholder, appoints directors who may simply agree with it and not run the company in a businesslike way.
Which statement about Government companies is correct according to the textbook?
- Their revenues go into the treasury
- They cannot be sued
- Except officials on deputation, their employees are not governed by civil service rules
- They need a special Act to change their objectives
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A Government company has its own staff outside civil service rules (apart from deputationists); it keeps its revenues, can sue and be sued, and changes objectives by altering its Memorandum.
A Government company is created by:
- a special Act of Parliament
- an executive decision of the Government, without approval of the legislature
- nationalisation only
- a resolution of the CAG
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
No legislative approval is needed; it is formed by executive decision and registration under the Companies Act.
Made-up figures: paid-up capital ₹120 crore; Central Government ₹40 crore, two State Governments ₹12 crore each. What is the total Government share?
- 33.3%, so it is not
- 43.3%, so it is not
- 64%, so it is a public corporation
- 53.3% (about), so it is a Government company
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Government holding = ₹40 + ₹12 + ₹12 = ₹64 crore. 64 ÷ 120 × 100 = 53.33%. This is at least 51%, and holding partly by the Centre and partly by States counts.
Which is a disadvantage of a public corporation given in the textbook?
- Reasonable pricing policy
- Tailor-made statute
- Not affected by political changes
- Clash of divergent interests on the Board of Directors
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Representatives of different groups may clash on the board, hampering efficiency. The other three are advantages.
Assertion (A): A public corporation has a rigid constitution. Reason (R): Its constitution cannot be changed without amending the statute that created it.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true, R is false
- A is false, R is true
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Because its powers come from an Act, any change requires the legislature to amend that Act, which makes it rigid.
The main objective of a public corporation, according to the textbook, is:
- service, while being self-supporting and earning reasonable profits
- maximum profit for shareholders
- secrecy in strategic work
- earning foreign exchange only
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
A public corporation is service-motivated but is expected to be self-supporting and earn reasonable profits.
Which feature belongs to a public corporation but NOT to a departmental undertaking?
- Ultimate responsibility of a minister to the legislature
- Revenues paid into the treasury
- Separate legal entity with perpetual succession and common seal
- Staff are civil servants
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A public corporation exists independently of the Government and can own property and sue in its own name. The other options describe a departmental undertaking.
Made-up figures: a departmental undertaking's loss of ₹60 crore is met by raising extra tax equally from 3 crore taxpayers. How much extra does each pay?
- ₹20
- ₹2
- ₹200
- ₹180
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
₹60 crore ÷ 3 crore = 60,00,00,000 ÷ 3,00,00,000 = ₹20 per taxpayer. This is the 'incidence of additional taxation'.
Which of these is an ADVANTAGE of a departmental undertaking?
- Red-tapism
- Financial dependence
- Casual approach to work
- Lesser risk of misuse of public money
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Because government budgeting, accounting and audit procedures apply, misuse of public money is less likely. The others are disadvantages.
Revenues of a departmental undertaking are:
- kept by the undertaking for expansion
- paid into the government treasury
- paid to private shareholders
- sent to the minister's personal account
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Government financing means budget appropriations come in and revenues are paid into the treasury.
Which pair is a correct example of a departmental undertaking and the ministry that runs it, as given in the textbook?
- Post and Telegraph - Ministry of Communication
- Indian Railways - Ministry of Finance
- All India Radio - Ministry of Railways
- Delhi Milk Scheme - Ministry of Defence
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Post and Telegraph services are run as a department under the Ministry of Communication; Indian Railways is under the Ministry of Railways.
According to the textbook, why did government intervention in business become necessary?
- Because private businesses were banned
- Because governments wanted to stop all trade
- To safeguard the public from exploitation of consumers and workers by profit-driven private enterprise
- Because MNCs asked for it
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
The book says private entrepreneurs worked only for profit and exploitation of consumers and workers was common, so governments stepped in to protect public interest.
Made-up figures: a State holds ₹74 crore of a company's paid-up capital of ₹100 crore. Which form is it, and why?
- A public corporation, because it is owned by the State
- A Government company, because 74% is more than 51%
- A departmental undertaking, because the State owns it
- Not a public enterprise, because 26% is private
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Share = 74 ÷ 100 × 100 = 74%, which is not less than 51%. A company registered with this holding is a Government company.
Which form can be sued only with the consent of the Government?
- Public corporation
- Government company
- All three equally
- Departmental undertaking
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
A departmental undertaking has sovereign immunity. A public corporation and a Government company are separate legal entities and can be sued in their own names.
Why is a Government company criticised as 'a fraud on the Companies Act and the Constitution'?
- It can be exempted from many provisions of the Act and is created without consulting Parliament
- It pays more tax than private companies
- It has no Board of Directors
- It is run by a foreign MNC
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The Government may exempt it from several provisions of the Act, and Parliament is not taken into confidence when it is created.
The textbook's example of 'private participation' through a Government company is:
- Indian Railways buying new engines
- LIC selling policies
- Hindustan Steel Limited obtaining technical and financial help from abroad for its steel plants
- All India Radio starting a channel
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Hindustan Steel Limited got help from the U.S.S.R., West Germany and the U.K. for its plants at Bhilai, Rourkela and Durgapur.
Objectives and powers of a Government company can be changed by:
- amending a special Act of Parliament
- altering its Memorandum of Association
- a vote of the State Legislature only
- an order of the Comptroller and Auditor General
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Being a registered company, it changes its objectives by altering its Memorandum, without seeking Parliament's approval.