Unit 7 Political Thought
Practice questions
Which sequence correctly follows Marx's account?
- Classless society, class struggle, dictatorship of the proletariat, withering away of the state
- Class struggle, dictatorship of the proletariat, classless society, withering away of the state
- Withering away of the state, class struggle, classless society
- Dictatorship of the proletariat, class struggle, capitalism
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Class struggle leads to revolution and the dictatorship of the proletariat; this abolishes classes, producing a classless society, and the state then withers away.
According to Marx, the change that takes place in society through the 'struggle of opposites' is explained by:
- the general will
- natural law
- utilitarianism
- dialectical materialism
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Dialectical materialism holds that society is material and in constant motion, and that contradictions within it produce change.
Mill's paradox in Considerations on Representative Government was that:
- the monarch has power and the people have wisdom
- the majority has power but the minority often has wisdom
- the minority should never vote
- liberty and democracy cannot coexist
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Mill, though a democrat, argued that the majority ought to rule but that the minority often has wisdom, which made him wary of majority tyranny.
Which feature of sovereignty did Rousseau NOT accept?
- It is inalienable
- It is indivisible
- It can be handed over to a representative body
- It belongs to the general will
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Rousseau held sovereignty to be inalienable and indivisible, resting in the general will; representative bodies develop interests of their own, so the general will cannot be represented.
Rousseau located the origin of inequality mainly in:
- the rise of private property
- differences in reason
- the will of God
- the Industrial Revolution
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Rousseau traced inequality to the changes that ended the state of nature, above all private property, which split society into rich and poor.
Locke is called the father of:
- political science
- behaviouralism
- scientific socialism
- philosophical liberalism
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The textbook calls Locke the father of philosophical liberalism. Aristotle is the father of political science, and Machiavelli is called a pioneer of behaviouralism.
Which statement fits Hobbes and NOT Locke?
- The sovereign must be absolute
- People keep their natural rights after the contract
- Government is based on consent
- The legislature is the supreme power
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Hobbes argued for an absolute sovereign. Locke kept natural rights and made the legislature supreme. Both based government on consent, so that statement fits both.
Why, according to the textbook's assessment, did Machiavelli advocate monarchy though he preferred a republic?
- Because he admired Plato's philosopher kings
- Because the Church demanded it
- Because Italy, divided into five parts and morally corrupt, needed a strong ruler to build a nation-state
- Because he rejected the idea of a state
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
As a patriot he wanted a strong nation-state for a divided Italy, so he advised monarchy for its existing condition while preferring a republic in general.
Divine law, in Aquinas's scheme, is:
- reason operating in the whole universe
- the revealed word of God in Scripture
- law made by kings
- moral law found by reason alone
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Divine law is a special category of eternal law, revealed in Scripture. Eternal law is reason operating in the universe; natural law is found by reason alone; human law is made by people.
Which pair is correctly matched?
- Aquinas - The Prince
- Machiavelli - Summa Theologica
- Aquinas - On Kingship
- Hobbes - Discourses on Livy
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
On Kingship is by Aquinas. The Prince and the Discourses on Livy are Machiavelli's; Summa Theologica is Aquinas's.
Aristotle differs from Plato in that he:
- proposed the best practicable state rather than an ideal state
- wanted philosophers alone to rule
- rejected all classification of states
- abolished private property
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Aristotle proposed the best practicable state, as against Plato's ideal state, and defended limited private property.
Assertion (A): Aristotle held that the state is a natural institution. Reason (R): Families, unable to meet their growing needs alone, combined to form the state.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Both are in the textbook, and R explains A: the state grows naturally out of families combining to satisfy needs they could not meet alone.
Case: in Plato's education system, a student shows great skill in trade and farming but little interest in reflection or combat. At the first elimination this student would be:
- trained as a philosopher king
- sent to the military class
- expelled from the state
- placed in the economic class
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
The first elimination separates those suited to economic duties from those suited to ruling and military service, so this student joins the economic class.
Which of Plato's works were named in the textbook as his three most important?
- Politics, Ethics and Rhetoric
- The Republic, The Statesman and The Laws
- Leviathan, De Cive and The Laws
- Emile, The Republic and The Prince
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The textbook names The Republic, The Statesman and The Laws. Politics is Aristotle's; Leviathan and De Cive are Hobbes's; Emile is Rousseau's; The Prince is Machiavelli's.
In Plato's ideal state, justice means:
- each class doing its own proper work without interfering in others'
- everyone ruling in turn
- the majority deciding everything
- equal wealth for all classes
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Plato held that justice is each part of the soul, and each class of the state, doing its own proper work.
Using made-up figures: a worker's labour creates goods worth ₹900 in a day and the worker is paid ₹350. What is the surplus value in Marx's sense?
- ₹350
- ₹1,250
- ₹550
- ₹900
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Surplus value = value created − wage paid = ₹900 − ₹350 = ₹550. Check: ₹350 + ₹550 = ₹900.
In Marx's theory, the 'dictatorship of the proletariat' is:
- the permanent rule of a single leader
- a transitional period in which the working class holds state power between the overthrow of bourgeois rule and a classless society
- rule by landowners
- the final stage after the state has withered away
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Marx used the phrase for the working class taking state power during the transition from bourgeois rule to a classless society; the withering away of the state comes after it.
Which work is described in the textbook as the 'Bible of the working class'?
- The Communist Manifesto
- Principles of Political Economy
- Leviathan
- Das Kapital
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Das Kapital (first volume 1867) was called the Bible of the working class. The Communist Manifesto (1848) was Marx's joint work with Engels.
Mill compared human nature to:
- a tree that must grow on all sides by its own inner forces
- a machine built to a model
- a soldier obeying orders
- a river flowing to the sea
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Mill said human nature is not a machine built after a model but a tree that needs to grow and develop on all sides, which is his argument for individuality.
According to Mill's On Liberty, the only purpose for which people may interfere with someone's liberty of action is:
- religious duty
- economic growth
- self-protection
- the wishes of the majority
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Mill's one simple principle is that self-protection is the sole end that warrants interference with anyone's liberty of action. He specifically feared majority pressure.