Chapter 21 The Sale of Goods Act, 1930
Practice questions
Made-up terms: price ₹60,000, agreed interest 10% a year, paid 4 months late. Total amount payable?
- ₹62,000
- ₹66,000
- ₹60,400
- ₹64,000
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Interest = 60,000 × 10/100 × 4/12 = ₹2,000. Total = 60,000 + 2,000 = ₹62,000.
Goods are on a ship to the buyer, who becomes insolvent. When does the seller's right to stop them end?
- When the ship sails
- When the buyer's insolvency is announced
- When, on arrival, the carrier tells the buyer it holds the goods for him
- Never
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Stoppage in transit ends when goods are delivered to the buyer or his agent, or when the carrier at the destination acknowledges holding them for the buyer.
A seller receives a cheque for the full price, which is dishonoured. He is:
- a paid seller
- an unpaid seller
- a carrier
- a pledgee
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
A seller whose negotiable instrument given as conditional payment is dishonoured is an unpaid seller.
Made-up figures: a buyer pays ₹25,000 for a machine sold to him free of charges, but a bank that had a loan secured on it takes it away. He had spent ₹2,000 on fitting it. Which term is broken and what can he claim?
- Sample; ₹2,000
- Freedom from encumbrance (and title); ₹27,000
- Merchantability; ₹25,000 only
- No term; nothing
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
A hidden charge in favour of a third party breaks the warranty of freedom from encumbrance (and his possession is disturbed). Loss = 25,000 + 2,000 = ₹27,000.
A dairy sells milk contaminated with disease germs and a customer falls ill. Which implied condition is broken?
- Wholesomeness
- Quiet possession
- Description only
- Sample
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Eatables must be wholesome, not just merchantable; contaminated milk breaks the condition as to wholesomeness.
A buyer insists on a car that seats seven; a seller supplies a five-seater in the colour the buyer wanted. The buyer may:
- only claim damages
- do nothing
- only ask for a new colour
- reject the car and claim damages, as a condition is broken
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Seating seven was essential to the buyer's purpose, so it is a condition; its breach allows the buyer to cancel and claim damages.
A tractor is sent on approval with no time fixed; the buyer uses it for six weeks and then tries to reject it. The likely result is:
- ownership has passed, as a reasonable time has elapsed
- the seller must take it back
- the contract is void
- ownership never passes on approval
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Where no time is fixed, ownership passes when a reasonable time has expired without rejection; six weeks of use is beyond a reasonable trial.
A seller fills oil into bottles the buyer supplied for that purpose. Ownership passes on filling because:
- the seller alone ascertained the goods
- the buyer consented to appropriation by supplying the bottles
- the price was paid
- the goods are perishable
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Appropriation needs the consent of both parties; by supplying the bottles, the buyer consented, so ownership passed when the oil was filled.
Specific goods in a deliverable state are sold unconditionally; payment and delivery are to be next week. When does ownership pass?
- On payment
- On delivery
- When the contract is made
- When the buyer uses the goods
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
For an unconditional contract of specific goods in a deliverable state, ownership passes at the time of the contract; the time of payment or delivery does not matter.
Under a sale, the buyer becomes insolvent before paying, and the goods are still with the seller. According to the textbook's comparison, the seller generally:
- keeps the price and the goods
- must hand the goods to the Official Receiver and claim a rateable dividend, subject to his unpaid seller's rights
- can resell freely without any rule
- becomes the owner again automatically
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
In a sale ownership has passed, so the goods belong to the insolvent buyer's estate and the seller claims a rateable dividend; but as an unpaid seller in possession he can still use his lien.
A contract to supply 500 school uniforms that the tailor has yet to stitch concerns:
- specific goods
- existing goods
- future goods
- contingent goods only
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Goods to be made by the seller after the contract are future goods; a contract for them can only be an agreement to sell.
Under an agreement to sell, the goods are destroyed while with the buyer for inspection. Who bears the loss?
- The seller, as ownership has not passed
- The buyer, as he has possession
- The carrier
- Both equally
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
Risk follows ownership. Under an agreement to sell, ownership is still with the seller, so the seller bears the loss even though the buyer holds the goods.
Which is goods under the Act?
- Money due under a life insurance policy
- A fixed deposit receipt
- A plot of land
- Trees agreed to be cut and sold
Answer and explanation
Answer: D
Things attached to land that are agreed to be severed before sale are goods. Insurance money due and FD receipts are actionable claims; land is immovable.
When surplus goods of a dissolved partnership are divided among the partners, the textbook says this is:
- a sale, attracting sales tax
- not a sale, because the partners were joint owners
- a barter
- an agreement to sell
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
The partners were themselves joint owners and could not be both sellers and buyers, so the court held there was no sale.
Which is an essential element of a contract of sale?
- Three parties
- Transfer of possession only
- A price in money
- Registration in a court
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
A contract of sale needs two parties, transfer of ownership, goods and a money price. Possession alone is not enough.
An unpaid seller may resell the goods without waiting when they are:
- perishable
- made of steel
- insured
- already delivered to the buyer
Answer and explanation
Answer: A
The textbook lists perishable goods as a case where the unpaid seller can resell; otherwise he gives notice and waits a reasonable time, unless the contract reserves resale.
Made-up terms: price ₹40,000 paid 6 months late, agreed interest 9% a year. Interest due is:
- ₹3,600
- ₹1,800
- ₹2,400
- ₹900
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Interest = 40,000 × 9/100 × 6/12 = 40,000 × 0.09 × 0.5 = ₹1,800.
Which event ends the seller's right of lien?
- The seller sends the documents of title to the buyer but keeps the goods
- The buyer lawfully obtains possession of the goods
- The buyer becomes insolvent
- The credit period expires
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
Lien depends on possession; it is lost when the buyer lawfully gets possession, when goods go to a carrier without reserving disposal, or by waiver. Sending documents alone does not end it.
The right of stoppage in transit can be used when:
- goods are with the seller and the buyer is solvent
- goods are with the buyer
- goods are with a carrier and the buyer has become insolvent
- the price has been fully paid
Answer and explanation
Answer: C
Stoppage in transit requires the goods to be in transit with a carrier and the buyer to have become insolvent.
A seller received ₹9,900 out of a price of ₹10,000. He is:
- not an unpaid seller, as most is paid
- an unpaid seller
- a buyer
- an agent only
Answer and explanation
Answer: B
A seller is unpaid when the whole price has not been paid; even a balance of ₹100 makes him an unpaid seller.