Unit 5 Federalism in India

Practice questions

The Rajamannar Committee recommended deleting Articles 256, 257 and 339(2) because they:

  1. enable the Centre to issue directions to state governments
  2. create the Rajya Sabha
  3. deal with river water disputes
  4. provide for the Finance Commission
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

These Articles allow the Union to direct state governments; the Committee saw them as against state autonomy.

Under the Bommai judgment, what must happen before a state Assembly can be dissolved under Article 356?

  1. The Governor must resign
  2. Both Houses of Parliament must approve the proclamation
  3. The Supreme Court must give prior permission
  4. A referendum must be held in the state
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Bommai held that the Assembly may not be dissolved until both Houses of Parliament approve the proclamation; meanwhile it can only be suspended, and the proclamation is subject to judicial review.

Which recommendation was made by the Sarkaria Commission?

  1. Abolish the office of Governor
  2. Transfer residuary powers to the states
  3. Appoint eminent, non-partisan persons as Governors
  4. Abolish the All India Services
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Sarkaria rejected abolition of the Governor's office and consultation demands, but wanted eminent, politically neutral Governors. Residuary powers to states and abolishing AIS were Rajamannar proposals.

In 2015, which body replaced the Planning Commission?

  1. The Finance Commission
  2. The Inter-State Council
  3. The NITI Aayog
  4. The National Development Council
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

In January 2015 the NITI Aayog replaced the Planning Commission, with the Prime Minister as chairperson and an aim of fostering co-operative federalism.

Which statement about water disputes tribunals is correct?

  1. Their awards can be appealed in any district court
  2. They are set up before any negotiation is attempted
  3. Their members are elected by state legislatures
  4. Their decision, once published in the Official Gazette, is final and binding
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

Negotiation comes first; tribunal members are nominated by the Chief Justice of India; the published award is final and binding, and courts have no jurisdiction over a referred dispute.

Which pair is correctly matched?

  1. Inter-State Council: Article 262
  2. Zonal Councils: States Reorganisation Act, 1956
  3. NITI Aayog: Article 280
  4. River water tribunals: Article 263
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Zonal Councils come from the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. The Inter-State Council is Article 263, river disputes are Article 262 and the Finance Commission is Article 280; NITI Aayog was created by executive decision in 2015.

The Finance Commission recommends measures to augment a state's Consolidated Fund for which purpose?

  1. To pay the salaries of judges
  2. To fund national defence
  3. To supplement the resources of panchayats and municipalities
  4. To fund elections to Parliament
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Article 280 asks the Finance Commission to recommend measures to supplement the resources of panchayats and urban local bodies, besides tax sharing and grant principles.

Using made-up figures: the divisible pool is ₹2,000 crore and the states' share is 41 percent. What do the states receive?

  1. ₹820 crore
  2. ₹1,180 crore
  3. ₹410 crore
  4. ₹200 crore
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

41/100 × 2,000 = 820, so the states get ₹820 crore and the Union keeps 2,000 − 820 = ₹1,180 crore.

A Concurrent List subject has a Union law and a conflicting state law. Who usually holds executive power on Concurrent subjects, and whose law prevails?

  1. The Union holds executive power; the state law prevails
  2. The states hold executive power; the state law prevails
  3. The states ordinarily hold executive power; the Union law prevails
  4. The Union holds both and the state law is void in all cases
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Executive power on Concurrent subjects ordinarily lies with the states, subject to Union directions; in a conflict the law of Parliament prevails.

Which feature shows that Indian states have no guaranteed right to existence?

  1. Parliament can change state boundaries and names by ordinary law under Articles 3 and 4
  2. States elect members of the Rajya Sabha
  3. States have their own High Courts
  4. States levy some taxes
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Under Articles 3 and 4 Parliament can create, merge, rename or abolish states by a simple majority, so India is an indestructible Union of destructible states.

Which of these is part of the 'Territory of India' but not of the 'Union of States'?

  1. Tamil Nadu
  2. Kerala
  3. The Central Government
  4. A union territory such as Puducherry
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The Union of States means the states with the Central Government. The Territory of India also includes union territories and any acquired territory.

Why does the textbook call the Rajya Sabha's structure 'anti-federal'?

  1. It is directly elected
  2. Its seats are distributed by population, not equally among states
  3. It has no members from states
  4. It cannot discuss bills
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

In an ideal federation the upper House gives states equal representation, as in the US Senate. India's Rajya Sabha allots seats by population: Uttar Pradesh 31, Nagaland one.

Arrange in order: (1) Nehru Report (2) Regulating Act (3) Government of India Act introducing provincial autonomy (4) Government of India Act introducing dyarchy in provinces.

  1. 2, 1, 4, 3
  2. 2, 4, 1, 3
  3. 4, 2, 1, 3
  4. 2, 4, 3, 1
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

Regulating Act 1773 (2), Government of India Act 1919 with dyarchy (4), Nehru Report 1928 (1), Government of India Act 1935 with provincial autonomy (3): so 2, 4, 1, 3.

Assertion (A): India's Constitution is called rigid. Reason (R): Article 368 provides a special amendment procedure, and federal provisions need ratification by half the states.

  1. Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
  2. Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
  3. A is true but R is false
  4. A is false but R is true
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

Both are true and R explains A: a special procedure, beyond ordinary law-making, is what makes a constitution rigid and protects the states.

The most important feature of a federal constitution, according to the textbook, is:

  1. Political parties
  2. A strong national government
  3. Regional governments created and protected by the Constitution
  4. A hereditary head of state
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The fundamental attribute of a federal constitution is constitutionally created and protected state or regional governments, with powers divided between them and the Centre.

According to the Bommai judgment, which of these is a valid ground for President's rule?

  1. A mere law-and-order problem
  2. The state's ruling party losing heavily in a Lok Sabha election
  3. A hung Assembly where no party or coalition can form a government
  4. The Governor's personal dislike of the Chief Minister
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

Bommai allows Article 356 only for a genuine constitutional breakdown, such as a hung Assembly with no possible government. Law and order or a poor Lok Sabha result are not grounds.

Which amendment moved education from the State List to the Concurrent List?

  1. The 44th Amendment
  2. The 42nd Amendment
  3. The 73rd Amendment
  4. The 86th Amendment
Answer and explanation

Answer: B

The 42nd Amendment (1976) transferred education to the Concurrent List; many states, including Tamil Nadu, demand its return to the State List.

Which commission recommended fixed tenure for Governors and localised emergencies under Articles 355 and 356?

  1. The Sarkaria Commission
  2. The Rajamannar Committee
  3. The Venkatachaliah Commission
  4. The Punchhi Commission
Answer and explanation

Answer: D

The Punchhi Commission (2007, report 2010) recommended fixed tenure and impeachment-like removal for Governors, and localised emergencies.

Which commission recommended the abolition of All India Services such as the IAS?

  1. The Rajamannar Committee
  2. The Sarkaria Commission
  3. The Punchhi Commission
  4. The First Administrative Reforms Commission
Answer and explanation

Answer: A

The Rajamannar Committee recommended abolishing the All India Services, seeing them as against the spirit of federalism and state autonomy.

Which body was set up by the Tamil Nadu Government to study Centre-State relations?

  1. The Sarkaria Commission
  2. The Punchhi Commission
  3. The Rajamannar Committee
  4. The Venkatachaliah Commission
Answer and explanation

Answer: C

The Rajamannar Committee was set up by the Tamil Nadu Government and reported in 1971. The others were set up by the Union Government.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery