The short answer: a paid learning app is worth it only if it does something your child cannot already get from you, from school and from good free material, and only if it fits inside sensible screen time. The price does not tell you the quality. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) points out that most apps parents find under the "educational" category in app stores have no evidence that they work, and that the thinking skills children need for school are best built through play and through time with caring adults. So try free first, watch how your child actually uses an app, and pay only when you can answer the questions below with confidence.

What the guidelines say about apps for children

Two sets of paediatric guidelines are useful here. In its 2016 policy statement Media and Young Minds, the AAP says that well-designed programmes can help children aged 3 to 5, but that most "educational" apps target only rote academic skills, are not based on established curricula, and use little or no input from developmental specialists or educators. It also says that skills like task persistence, impulse control, emotion regulation and creative, flexible thinking are best taught through unstructured and social (not digital) play, and through responsive parent-child interaction.

The Indian Academy of Pediatrics (IAP) guidelines from 2022 set the time limits. For children aged 24 to 59 months, screen time should be a maximum of 1 hour per day, with each session not more than 20 to 30 minutes, and the content should be educational, age-appropriate, non-violent, healthy and preferably interactive. For children aged 5 to 10, the IAP says less than 2 hours per day, and this includes time on screens for school assignments at home. Any app you pay for has to fit inside these limits, not on top of them.

A free-first approach

  1. Start with what you already have. Your child's school textbook, a library card, old newspapers, a deck of cards and a kitchen full of things to count will teach a great deal. Ask the class teacher what your child most needs to practise.
  2. Use free, ad-free material next. Try free resources for a few weeks and notice what your child enjoys and what they learn. This tells you whether a screen helps your child at all.
  3. Name the exact gap. "Better at maths" is too vague. "Reads two-letter Hindi words with matras" or "knows the 6 and 7 times tables" is a gap you can test.
  4. Only then look at a paid app, and only one at a time. Use any free trial with the question "is this closing the gap?", not "does my child like it?". Cancel reminders matter: set one on your own calendar the day you sign up.
  5. Review after a month. If you cannot see a change in what your child can do away from the screen, stop.

Questions to ask before you pay

The UK government's guidance for parents on early years apps offers some good questions, and the AAP adds advice on testing apps yourself. Put together, here is a checklist you can use for any learning app:

  • Are the learning aims clear? The UK guidance asks exactly this. A good app tells you what it teaches and for which age.
  • Has it been tested? The AAP asks app makers to formally and scientifically evaluate products before making educational claims. Look for what the company says about how it checked its claims, not just testimonials.
  • Are ads and links locked away? The UK guidance asks whether in-app adverts or links to the internet sit behind a parental gate, for example a hard maths sum.
  • What happens to your child's data? Ask whether the app makes clear how your data and your child's data are collected and used.
  • Does it bring people in? The UK guidance asks whether the app encourages your child to interact with other people or with characters in the app, and whether it gives feedback to an adult so they can support learning.
  • Is it calm? The AAP advises avoiding fast-paced programmes and apps with lots of distracting content.
  • Does it end? An app that keeps offering one more level, streaks to protect or rewards for coming back is built to hold attention, not to teach.

Before you pay for a learning app

  1. Name the gap One specific skill, agreed with the teacher if possible
  2. Try free first Books, play, school material and ad-free resources
  3. Check the app Clear aims, no ads, clear data use, calm design
  4. Test it yourself Play it before your child does
  5. Review in a month Can your child do the skill away from the screen?
Pay only when every step has a clear yes.

Test the app yourself, then play together

The AAP's advice to families is simple: test apps before the child uses them, play together, and ask the child what they think about the app. For children aged 2 to 5, it recommends co-viewing, helping children understand what they are seeing, and helping them apply what they learn to the world around them. The UK guidance notes that even just 10 minutes of doing an activity together is beneficial.

A parent-child activity: the "show me without the phone" test. After your child has used an app for a week, close it and ask them to teach you what they learnt, using real things. If the app was about counting, give them a plate of peanuts or buttons (not for children under 3, who can choke on small objects) and ask them to count out seven. If it was about letters, ask them to find the letter on a newspaper headline. If they can do it, the app is helping. If they can only do it inside the app, it is teaching the app, not the skill.

Common mistakes

  • Paying because other parents are paying. A school WhatsApp group is not a review. Your child's needs are their own.
  • Using the app as a babysitter. The AAP recommends shared use between parent and child to promote enhanced learning and greater interaction.
  • Counting app time as "study" and not as screen time. The IAP limit for 5 to 10 year olds includes educational screen time at home.
  • Ignoring how your child feels. If an app makes your child anxious about scores or streaks, it is costing more than money.

If you want something free to start with, Sikhora Kids has short learning games for ages 2 to 12, with no ads and no chat. You can set break reminders and a daily play limit on the grown-ups' page, and for ages 2 to 5 the screen pauses when the session time is up. Use it the same way as anything else: try it, sit with your child, and keep it only if it helps. For older children, Sikhora School has chapter lessons by class that you can read through together.

Not sure how much screen time is right for your family? Agree the rules together with this free printable.

Print the family screen agreement

Frequently asked questions

Is a paid app better than a free one?

Not necessarily. Price is not a measure of quality. Some free resources are carefully made and ad-free, and some paid apps are full of rewards designed to keep children playing. Judge every app by the same questions: clear aims, no ads, clear data use, calm design and a visible change in what your child can do.

My child's school recommends an app. Should we buy it?

Ask the teacher what it is for, how long your child should use it each day, and whether the school will use the results. If it is optional, you can ask whether the same practice can be done on paper. Rules and expectations differ between schools, so ask your own.

Can an app replace tuition or a teacher?

An app can give practice, but the AAP says the thinking skills children need for school are best taught through play and responsive interaction with parents. If your child is struggling, talk to the class teacher first about what exactly is difficult.

What about apps for toddlers under 2?

The IAP says children below 2 years should not be exposed to any type of screen, apart from occasional video calls with family far away. The AAP also says parents should not feel pressured to introduce technology early, because children figure out these interfaces quickly once they start.

Browse more guides on screens, learning and play in our parent guides, including how to choose good apps for young children.

Play along: Sikhora Kids has free learning games by skill and age, free to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.

Sources