The short answer: this is very common, and usually not a problem. Children learning English as a second language often understand much more than they can say, and many go through a quiet stretch before they start speaking it. What helps most is keeping English relaxed and short, talking to your child in English without demanding replies, accepting answers in your home language, and never making speaking a test. If your child is also silent in their home language in some places, or seems frozen and anxious, that is different, and worth discussing with the teacher or a doctor.
Why it happens
Understanding comes before speaking. In her advice for parents on the British Council's LearnEnglish Kids site, author Opal Dunn notes that young children understand much more than they can say in English. A handout for early years staff from Bolton Start Well in the UK says that children just starting to learn English as an additional language commonly go through a 'silent period' which may last 6-9 months, and stresses that this is not a passive stage: learning is taking place.
In Indian classrooms, English is often a second language. NCERT's note on its Class 3 English textbook, Santoor, explains that children develop speaking, reading and writing in two languages, and that they move faster in the first one while gaining familiarity with the second gradually. Slow speaking in English is part of that normal path.
Other everyday reasons: your child may be shy of making mistakes, may have been laughed at once, may hear English only at school, or may simply find it easier to answer in Hindi, Tamil or Bengali because they know you understand.
What to do at home
- Keep talking in English, and do not demand a reply. The Bolton handout advises adults to continue to talk to children even if they don't respond in words. Describe what you are doing: "I am cutting the mango. It is very juicy."
- Accept any answer. If you ask in English and your child answers in your home language, that is a real answer. Reply warmly, and say it back in English: "Yes, the mango is sweet."
- Repeat and stretch, do not correct. The British Council article suggests reflecting back what the child has said and enlarging it. If your child says "dog run", you say "Yes, the dog is running fast!" The Bolton handout also advises modelling and extending children's language rather than focusing on mistakes.
- Keep sessions short. Opal Dunn suggests English sessions lasting from just a few minutes up to about ten, once or twice a day. Short and happy works better than long and serious.
- Use songs, rhymes and stories. Songs and rhymes are repetitive, so children learn whole lines without the pressure of making sentences. Picture books let your child point and name things.
- Let a toy do the talking. The British Council article suggests a toy that speaks only English: you ask it questions and pretend it answers. Many children will happily speak for a puppet when they will not speak as themselves.
- Do not drop your home language. The Bolton handout is firm that removing one language will NOT make learning the remaining language easier, and that families should never be told to speak only English. A strong home language supports English, it does not compete with it.
Ideas by age
| Age | Try this | Keep in mind |
|---|---|---|
| 3 to 5 | Action rhymes, naming games during bath or meals, a puppet who only speaks English | Single words and gestures count as speaking |
| 6 to 8 | Read a picture book together, then ask your child to tell it back to a toy; play shop with English words | Praise the attempt, not the grammar |
| 9 to 12 | Let your child teach you something in English, such as a game rule or a science fact; watch a short English programme together and chat about it | Older children are often most worried about sounding wrong, so keep it private and light |
A parent-child activity: the English toy shop
Set up a small shop on the floor with things from the kitchen: a packet of biscuits, an onion, a steel bowl, a comb. Write prices on paper slips and use toy notes or paper money. You are the shopkeeper who only understands English; your child is the customer. Start with gestures and single words ("biscuit"), and model the full sentence yourself: "You want one packet of biscuits? Here you are!" After a few rounds, swap roles so your child is the shopkeeper. Keep it to about ten minutes and stop while it is still fun. Safety: for younger brothers and sisters under 3, leave out coins, buttons and anything small enough to swallow.
Sikhora Kids has a free Toy Shop world where children play shop with pretend rupees, with no ads and no chat. A short round can be a warm-up before your own shop game.
Visit the Toy ShopCommon mistakes
- Making your child perform. "Say something in English for Masi!" puts a shy child on the spot and can make the next time harder.
- Correcting every word. Your child stops trying when every sentence gets fixed.
- Laughing at accents. The British Council article notes that parents may worry about their own accent, but young children can adapt their accent. Nobody's accent is a joke.
- Switching the whole home to English. This can cut a child off from the language they think and feel in, and the Bolton handout advises against it.
- Comparing with cousins or classmates. Children learn languages at very different speeds.
When to look more closely
A child who chats freely at home in your language but is quiet in English is usually just still learning. It is different if your child does not speak at all in certain places, such as school, even in their home language, and seems to freeze when expected to talk. The NHS describes selective mutism as an anxiety disorder where a person is unable to speak in certain social situations, and says it most often starts in early childhood, between age 2 and 4. Its advice to parents is not to pressurise or bribe a child to speak, and not to accept that a child will grow out of it or is 'just shy'. If anything about your child's speech in any language worries you, talk to the class teacher and your paediatrician, who can refer you to a speech and language therapist if needed.
For more on languages at home, read English medium or mother tongue and our list of English rhymes for nursery. The storybooks in the Castle world on Sikhora Kids are another gentle way to hear English.
Frequently asked questions
My child is 7 and understands everything in English class but never answers. Should I worry?
Usually not, if your child talks freely in your home language and is learning in class. Understanding often comes well before speaking. Tell the teacher, keep English at home short and relaxed, and see how things go over the coming months. If your child is silent in every language at school, ask for advice.
Should we stop speaking our home language so our child picks up English faster?
No. The Bolton Start Well handout states that removing one language will not make learning the remaining language easier, and that families should never be advised to speak only English.
My own English is not good. Can I still help?
Yes. Opal Dunn writes on the British Council site that parents, even with a basic knowledge of English, can successfully support their young child. Songs, picture books and simple everyday phrases are enough.
Should I reward my child for speaking English?
A warm smile and praise for trying are better than bribes. For children who are anxious about speaking, the NHS advises against pressurising or bribing them to speak.
How long does the quiet phase last?
It varies. The Bolton handout says the silent period for children just starting to learn English may last 6-9 months. If you are unsure whether what you see is normal, talk to the teacher or your paediatrician.
Play along: Sikhora Kids has free reading, phonics and alphabet games for kids to play in the browser, with no ads and no chat.