• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why the festival calendar is mixed: settlement history explains the celebrations

Explain the festival mix of the islands from the waves of settlement, and answer statement and assertion-reason questions linking history and culture.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions ask why, not only what. Why does a small group of islands celebrate Durga Puja, Pongal, Onam and Ugadi side by side? The answer is not found in religion alone but in the history of how people came to live here. Once you see the pattern, the festivals stop being a list and become evidence of the past.

Waves of settlement and the festivals they carried

Each wave left a mark on the calendar
WaveWho cameFestival evidence today
Penal settlementPrisoners from many parts of India, some of whom stayed after releaseFestivals of many regions, kept by families who stayed
After Partition in 1947Families displaced from East Bengal, settled in the AndamansDurga Puja and the Bengali new year
From the southern statesFamilies from Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh and Kerala, who came for land and workPongal, Ugadi and Onam
Chota Nagpur workersThe 'Ranchi' community, who came especially for forest workCustoms of the Chota Nagpur region; check local sources for the festivals
Indigenous communitiesPresent for thousands of yearsNicobarese feasts and canoe races; protected cultures of the Andaman peoples

The causes behind a mixed calendar

  • History
    • Penal settlement brought prisoners from many regions
    • Partition brought East Bengal families
  • Work and land
    • Southern families came for land and work
    • Chota Nagpur workers came for forest work
  • Older roots
    • Indigenous communities with their own traditions
    • Languages and customs older than the settlements
Why the calendar is mixed

Notice what the table does not say. It does not claim that every Bengali family came after Partition, or that every southern family came for the same reason. Where a table lists a wave, it states the main pattern only. Advanced questions often include such over-statements as traps, using words like 'all', 'only' and 'always'.

Three habits help with advanced statement questions. First, split every statement into its separate claims and test each one. A statement can be half right, and a half-right statement is wrong. Second, look for words that make a claim too strong: 'all', 'only', 'always', 'never'. Third, ask whether the claim is about the islands as a whole or about one community. A claim about Bengali families is not a claim about all settlers.

Also keep in mind that the settlers are not the whole story. The indigenous communities have lived on the islands for thousands of years, with traditions that are not borrowed from the mainland. A question that treats the Nicobarese as late arrivals, or that gives them mainland festivals as their own, should be rejected at once.

A short checklist can be kept for such questions: which wave, which region, which festival, which season. If an option breaks any link in that chain, it is probably wrong. Practise by choosing any festival of the islands and writing the chain for it in a single line.

Worked example 1: statement analysis

Question: (1) The presence of Durga Puja among the island festivals is partly explained by the settling of families from East Bengal after 1947. (2) The Nicobarese brought Durga Puja to the islands. Working: Statement 1 is a fair reading of the history: Bengali families were settled in the Andamans after Partition. Statement 2 is false: Durga Puja is the festival of Bengal, while the Nicobarese have their own feasts and many are Christian. Answer: 1 only.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason

Question: A: The islands celebrate Pongal and Onam. R: Families from Tamil Nadu and Kerala settled in the islands. Working: Pongal is Tamil and Onam is Malayali. A is true and R is true. R explains A, since the festivals travelled with the families. Answer: both true, and R explains A.

Worked example 3: reasoning from a clue

Question: A village on the islands keeps a harvest festival in the middle of January with a boiling pot, and another in August or September with a flower carpet. Which two regions do the families' ancestors most likely share a link with? Working: the January pot is Pongal, from Tamil Nadu; the flower carpet is Onam, from Kerala. Answer: Tamil Nadu and Kerala, with both communities living in the village.

Festival = evidence of migration. Match the wave to the region, then the region to the festival, and beware words like all and only.

Key takeaways: the calendar is a record of settlement. Link the wave, the region and the festival, and treat absolute words in options with suspicion.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Statements: (1) Settlement of East Bengal families helps explain Durga Puja on the islands. (2) Durga Puja is a Nicobarese festival.

    1. 1 only
    2. 2 only
    3. Both 1 and 2
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Statement 1 is a fair historical link. Statement 2 is false; Durga Puja belongs to Bengal.

  2. 2. A: Pongal is celebrated on the islands. R: Families from Tamil Nadu settled there.

    1. Both true, but R does not explain A
    2. A true, R false
    3. Both true, and R explains A
    4. A false, R true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both are true, and R explains how Pongal came to the islands.

  3. 3. Statements: (1) All the families of the islands came after Partition. (2) The islands were settled in waves.

    1. 1 only
    2. Both 1 and 2
    3. Neither 1 nor 2
    4. 2 only
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Statement 1 is false because settlers came in several waves, including penal settlement and southern families. Statement 2 is true.

  4. 4. A: Festivals of many regions are celebrated on the islands. R: Festivals are fixed by the Union Territory's government.

    1. Both true, and R explains A
    2. A true, R false
    3. Both true, but R does not explain A
    4. A false, R true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A is true, but R is false. Festivals came with settlers; they are not fixed by government.

  5. 5. Which wave best explains the presence of Onam?

    1. Prisoners of the penal settlement only
    2. East Bengal families after 1947
    3. Families from Kerala who settled for land and work
    4. The Sentinelese
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Onam is the festival of Kerala and travelled with Malayali families.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery