- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The constitutional logic of a Union Territory without a legislature
Reason from Articles 239, 240 and 246(4) to explain how a territory with no assembly is governed and how laws reach it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions do not ask for a single fact. They ask you to reason: given that the islands have no legislature, what follows? This lesson builds the chain of reasoning from the Articles you already know, so that you can answer an unfamiliar question by deduction instead of by memory.
Starting point: no assembly
The islands are a Union Territory without a legislature. Everything else follows from this. A government in the parliamentary pattern needs an elected assembly to which a council of ministers is responsible. If there is no assembly, there is no such council of ministers of the territory's own, and therefore no Chief Minister. Executive power is exercised by the President through the administrator, as Article 239 provides.
The chain of reasoning
From no assembly to the law
- No assembly The islands have no legislature of their own
- No Chief Minister There is no council of ministers answerable to an assembly
- Administrator governs Article 239: the President acts through an administrator
- Laws from above Parliament under Article 246(4), or the President under Article 240
Two sources of law
| Source | Basis | Strength | Example of use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Act of Parliament | Article 246(4) | Applies to any matter, including matters in the state list | General laws extended to the islands |
| Presidential regulation | Article 240 | Same force as an Act; may repeal or amend an Act | 1956 Protection of Aboriginal Tribes Regulation |
Notice what the combination means. Because Parliament's power under Article 246(4) is not limited by the lists in the Seventh Schedule for areas outside the states, no subject is closed to it. Because Article 240 allows regulations, the Union can act quickly without waiting for a full Act. The cost is that decisions are made far from the islands, which is why local bodies and consultation matter.
Where Article 240 is limited
Article 240 applies to certain Union Territories only. If a Union Territory has a legislature, the power of regulation is suspended for it while the legislature exists. This is why the logic hinges on the absence of an assembly. Check the current legal position, because Parliament may alter the arrangement for any Union Territory.
Worked example 1: deduction
Question: if a body of elected members existed for the islands to which ministers were responsible, what would that mean for Article 240? Working: the regulation power exists for territories without a legislature. If a legislature were created, the regulation power would not be used in the same way. The reasoning shows that Article 240 and an assembly are alternatives.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: the islands have no Chief Minister. Reason: the islands have no legislature to which a council of ministers could be responsible. Working: both statements are true, and the reason explains the assertion. The answer is that both are true and the reason is the correct explanation.
Worked example 3: false link
Assertion: Parliament makes laws for the islands. Reason: the islands send one member to the Lok Sabha. Working: the assertion is true. The reason is also true, but it does not explain the assertion. Parliament's power comes from Article 246(4), not from the number of seats. Both are true but the reason is not the correct explanation.
A useful habit for hard questions is to ask what would change if one premise changed. Suppose a territory had an elected assembly: then ministers could be responsible to it, and a head of government could emerge from it. That is the arrangement some other Union Territories have. Because the islands do not have it, every answer in this lesson points back to the President, Parliament and the administrator. Always check the current legal position, because Parliament can change the arrangement for a Union Territory by law.
No assembly, so no Chief Minister; the President governs through an administrator; laws come from Parliament (246(4)) or from the President (240).
Key takeaways: treat the absence of an assembly as the starting point. From it follow no Chief Minister, an administrator under Article 239, and laws by Parliament or Presidential regulation. In assertion-reason questions, test the link as well as each statement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Assertion: the islands have no Chief Minister. Reason: they have no legislature. Which is correct?
- Both true but the reason does not explain
- Assertion true, reason false
- Assertion false, reason true
- Both true and the reason explains the assertion
Show answer
Answer: D. Without an assembly there is no council of ministers answerable to it.
-
2. Parliament's power to legislate on any matter for the islands comes from:
- Article 246(4)
- Article 239
- Article 241
- Article 243
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 246(4) covers areas not in a state.
-
3. The regulation-making power of the President is suspended for a Union Territory when it:
- Has a High Court
- Has a Lok Sabha seat
- Has a legislature
- Has a district
Show answer
Answer: C. The power is meant for territories without a legislature.
-
4. Which sequence is correct?
- Chief Minister, no assembly, Governor
- Vidhan Sabha, Governor, Parliament
- No assembly, no Chief Minister, administrator under Article 239
- Administrator, Chief Minister, assembly
Show answer
Answer: C. The sequence follows the logic of the lesson.
-
5. Which pair of sources of law is correct for the islands?
- Act of Parliament and Presidential regulation
- State Act and Governor's order
- Gram Sabha resolution and Act
- Chief Minister's order and Act
Show answer
Answer: A. These are the two routes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.