- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading history through its sites: timelines and cross-checks
Use the sites of the islands as evidence for history, solve timeline problems with years and spot statements that mix different periods.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level a monument is a piece of evidence. The Cellular Jail, Ross Island, Viper Island and the Chatham Saw Mill each belong to a period, and a question may give you a clue about one and ask about another. This lesson trains you to place every site on a single timeline and to find the contradiction in a mixed statement.
By the end of this lesson you can:
- Place the sites on one timeline and calculate gaps between them
- Use a site's features to infer its period
- Judge multi-part statements where one part may be wrong
One timeline for all the sites
| Period | Site or event | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| 1789 to 1796 | Chatham Island settlement, then Port Cornwallis, abandoned | First British attempt and its failure through disease |
| From 1858 | Penal settlement at Port Blair | Kala Pani; convict labour clears forest |
| 1872 | Hope Town: Lord Mayo stabbed | The settlement was of national importance |
| 1883 | Chatham Saw Mill | The timber industry of the settlement |
| 1896 to 1906 | Cellular Jail | Solitary confinement for political prisoners |
| 1941 to 1945 | Ross Island earthquake, Japanese occupation from March 1942 | Headquarters abandoned; bunkers built |
| 30 December 1943 | Tricolour at Port Blair | Azad Hind and the names Shaheed and Swaraj |
| 1979 | National Memorial | Remembrance of the freedom struggle |
From failed settlement to memorial
- 1789 to 1796 Chatham Island and Port Cornwallis
- 1858 Penal settlement begins
- 1883 Saw mill works
- 1896 to 1906 Cellular Jail is built
- 1942 to 1945 Japanese occupation
- 1979 Memorial declared
Inferring a period from a feature
A bunker means the Second World War, so it is linked with the Japanese occupation from March 1942, not with the penal settlement. A gallows means the early penal settlement and, on Viper Island, the jail that came before the Cellular Jail. A church and a Chief Commissioner's house mean the headquarters of the administration on Ross Island. Seven wings and solitary cells mean 1896-1906. If an option gives a feature and a period that do not belong together, it is wrong.
Worked problems
Worked example 1. Question: 'How many years did the first British settlement last, from its start on Chatham Island to its abandonment?' Working: it began in 1789 and was abandoned in 1796. 1796 minus 1789 is 7. Answer: seven years.
Worked example 2. Question: 'The saw mill started 13 years before the Cellular Jail construction began. Is that consistent?' Working: 1896 minus 1883 is 13. Answer: Yes, consistent.
Worked example 3. Question: 'A statement claims that Japanese bunkers on Ross Island date from the period after the 1941 earthquake and before 1945. Is that reasonable?' Working: the Japanese occupation ran from March 1942 to 1945, and the island was abandoned after the 1941 earthquake and the war began to affect the islands. A bunker from 1942 to 1945 fits. Answer: Yes.
Worked example 4. Question: 'Statements: (i) the jail was built after the saw mill; (ii) Lord Mayo was killed after the jail was completed; (iii) the tricolour was hoisted after the occupation began.' Working: (i) 1883 before 1896, true. (ii) 1872 before 1906, false. (iii) 1943 after March 1942, true. Answer: (i) and (iii) only.
A note on wording. Compound statements use 'and', 'before' and 'after'. A statement with 'and' is true only if both parts are true. A statement with 'before' or 'after' is tested by comparing the two years, not by the order in which you remember the sites. If two sites share a time range, as Ross Island and the Japanese occupation do, check whether the question asks about the same year or the full range. Careful reading of such small words wins more marks than extra facts.
Feature gives period. Period gives order. Order gives the answer.
Key takeaways: build the one timeline; use a feature to infer a period; compute gaps carefully; test each part of a compound statement separately.
Check your understanding
-
1. The first British settlement of the islands lasted:
- Three years
- Seven years
- Ten years
- Twelve years
Show answer
Answer: B. It began in 1789 and was abandoned in 1796, so it lasted seven years.
-
2. Which statement is wrong?
- The saw mill was set up before the Cellular Jail was built
- Lord Mayo was killed before the jail was completed
- The tricolour was hoisted after the Japanese occupation had begun
- The National Memorial was declared before the jail was built
Show answer
Answer: D. The memorial declaration of 1979 came long after the jail was built in 1896-1906.
-
3. A feature that points to the Second World War on Ross Island is:
- A gallows
- A church
- A Chief Commissioner's house
- Japanese bunkers
Show answer
Answer: D. Bunkers date from the Japanese occupation. The church and house belong to the earlier headquarters.
-
4. How many years after the saw mill did construction of the Cellular Jail begin?
- 13
- 23
- 3
- 33
Show answer
Answer: A. 1896 minus 1883 is 13.
-
5. The best evidence that Viper Island belongs to the early penal period is:
- Its gallows and early jail
- A museum
- Japanese bunkers
- Radhanagar Beach
Show answer
Answer: A. The early jail and gallows belong to the penal settlement before the Cellular Jail.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.